150 likes | 243 Views
NACP meeting 2013. Tree-rings and vegetation models. Observed and simulated climate sensitivity of large-scale forest productivity. Flurin Babst 1,3 , Ben Poulter 1,2 , Valerie Trouet 3 , Kun Tan 2 , Burkhard Neuwirth 4 ,
E N D
NACP meeting2013 Tree-rings and vegetationmodels Observed and simulatedclimatesensitivityof large-scaleforestproductivity • Flurin Babst1,3, Ben Poulter1,2, Valerie Trouet3, KunTan2, Burkhard Neuwirth4, • Rob Wilson5, Marco Carrer6, Michael Grabner7, Willy Tegel8, Tom Levanic9, • Momchil Panayotov10, Carlo Urbinati11, Olivier Bouriaud12, Philippe Ciais2, David Frank1 • 1Swiss Federal Research Institute WSL, Switzerland • 2LSCE CNRS, France • 3Laboratory of Tree-ring Research, University of Arizona, USA • 4DeLaWi TreeRingAnalyses, Windeck, Germany • 5School of GeoSciences, University of Edinburgh, UK • 6Forest Ecology Research Unit, University of Padova, Italy • 7Universität für Bodenkultur Vienna, Austria • 8University of Freiburg, Germany • 9SlovenianForestry Institute Ljubljana, Slovenia • 10University of Forestry Sofia, Bulgaria • 11UniversitaPolitechnica delle MarcheAncona, Italy • 12Forest Research and Management ICAS, Romania
Motivation Forestsworldwidecurrentlyassimilateapproximately 25% of theanthropogenic fossil fuelemissions(Friedlingstein et al. 2010, Nature Geoscience). Understandingtheclimaticdrivers of forest growth at a large scale. Empiricalobservations? Nemani et al. 2003, Science Beer et al. 2010, Science
Tree-ringnetwork Tree-ringdatacanhelp to: Assesstheclimateresponse of forests at large scales. Evaluatetheclimatesensitivity of dynamic global vegetationmodels ~ 1000 sites 36 species Common period: 1920-1970
Monthlyclimateresponse Correlationsbetween radial growth and monthlytemperature monthlyprecipitation fromprevious April to current September Monthlyclimatedata: CRU 3.0, 1901-2006 (Mitchell & Jones, 2005) Downscaled to 1 x 1 km resolution Pinuscembra: • Climatecorrelationfunctionsfor all sites • Basis forfurtheranalyses precipitation temperature
Climatesignals Self-organizingmaps (SOMs) to dividethenetworkintoclusters of siteswithsimilarclimateresponses. SOM grid: T signal P signal M signal Babst et al. 2013, GEB
Latitude / altitude Limitingfactorsfortree growth canbeestimated as a function of latitude and elevation (temperature)
Tree-rings vs. DGVMs T P • Novelapplication of tree-ringdata: • Large-scalevalidation of vegetationmodels Babst et al. 2013, GEB
Seasonality Tan et al. in review, ERL temperateconifers temperatebroadleaf borealconifers T borealconifers P tree-rings % siteswithsign. pos. correlations temperateconifers model
Conclusions I Nemani et al. 2003, Science Beer et al. 2010, Science Babst et al. 2013, GEB
Conclusions II • DGVMsshow a strongerdroughtsensitivitythantree-rings. • Seasonality in climateresponse of DGVMsdiffersstronglyfromobservations. • Lag-effectsare not considered in simulations. • Tree-ringnetworkdoes not provide absolute productivity. Outlook: • DGVMs: • - Improveseasonality and includecarry-overeffects • Tree-rings: • Worktowards absolute biomassincrement • Combinationswithotherin-situmeasurements (e.g. eddy-fluxes)
Carry-overeffects All temperature and precipitationlimitedsites Climateconditions (bootstrapped) leading to contemporaneousorlagged growth extremes. Babst et al. 2012, ERL