120 likes | 202 Views
Measuring democracy:. Can it be done?. Problem:. How can we systematically assess whether a country is a liberal democracy or not?. Solutions:. Clarify what you mean: decide what kinds of criteria you should assess
E N D
Measuring democracy: Can it be done?
Problem: • How can we systematically assess whether a country is a liberal democracy or not?
Solutions: • Clarify what you mean: decide what kinds of criteria you should assess • Consider whether you can develop operational measures for the criteria you want to assess • Decide whether these should be qualitative (judgmental) or quantitative
Criteria: What do we expect to find in a democracy? • Inclusiveness • all or almost all of the adult population entitled to vote • Elections • free and fair elections -- elections with choice • Competition for power – public contestation
Using quantitative indicators What are they? • Numerical indicators, sometimes based on quantitative data – e.g. Gross national product • Sometimes based on expert judgments, e.g. placing a country on a scale • Examples: • Freedom House Scores • Human development index
Freedom House Scores • Freedom House: • an NGO or non-profit org. dating from World War II • Assesses democracy in 193 countries by examining the availability of • Political rights • civil liberties • Uses reports, assessments by scholars & experts to rate each country on a 7 point scale: • 1 is high…………......7 is low www.freedomhouse.org
Political rights: 10 scales in three subcategories • Electoral Process (3 questions) • Political Pluralism and Participation (4) • Functioning of Government (3)
Civil liberties: 15 scales in four categories • Freedom of Expression and Belief (4 questions) • Associational and Organizational Rights (3) • Rule of Law (4) • Personal Autonomy & Individual Rights (4)
Overall ratings • Free = mean score of 1.0 - 2.5 • Partially Free = mean score 3.0 – 5.0 • Not free = mean score 5.5 - 7.0 Some scores
Library Session: • Friday, September 21st, L1015