1 / 11

Solving the Roaming Physicist problem: Towards a HEP Virtual Organization?

Solving the Roaming Physicist problem: Towards a HEP Virtual Organization?. Manuel DELFINO Director, Port d’Informació Científica. Socio-geographical changes in HEP: A very rough and personal classification. Be “Anywhere” Located at: Home Institute

gvillareal
Download Presentation

Solving the Roaming Physicist problem: Towards a HEP Virtual Organization?

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Solving the Roaming Physicist problem:Towards a HEP Virtual Organization? Manuel DELFINODirector, Port d’Informació Científica Solving the Roaming Physicist problem / M. Delfino / PIC / IHEPCCC meeting

  2. Socio-geographical changes in HEP:A very rough and personal classification Solving the Roaming Physicist problem / M. Delfino / PIC / IHEPCCC meeting

  3. Be “Anywhere” Located at: Home Institute Another Home Institute part of a sub-collaboration A given Laboratory Person’s residence Private facility (hotel, conf. center, Ministry, etc.) At a public facility (airport lounge, train) Feel “At home” Need environment and access to resources of: Home Institute Another Home Institute part of a sub-collaboration Many Laboratories The general Internet/Web What do “anywhere” and “at home” mean? Solving the Roaming Physicist problem / M. Delfino / PIC / IHEPCCC meeting

  4. But today we are far from providing this in an economical way • A small example … visitors coming to Barcelona for IHEPCCC meeting: • Great luck that VRVS was acceptable to most…still • Only way to ensure success was to assign static IP addresses to visitors and network expert had to re-configure firewall, and we ran several bi-lateral tests • I requested access to Agenda Maker at CERN, which solved the problem of where to put the files…but… • Simplest way was to e-mail files to Stephanie and let her upload (alternative was to send password by e-mail, which would violate CERN service rules) • And…we still don’t have a mailing list and depend on “reply-all” to communicate Solving the Roaming Physicist problem / M. Delfino / PIC / IHEPCCC meeting

  5. Have others solved similar problems? • Yes, multinationals have solved the problem since a long time ago, essentially by geographically distributing a single security domain. • Partially, teenagers and other home users (including physicists!) by joining AOL, Yahoo, MSN, etc. Limitation: No inter-operation. • No, essentially everyone else (to the extent that I know…) Solving the Roaming Physicist problem / M. Delfino / PIC / IHEPCCC meeting

  6. What is at the root of the difficulties? • Security Model tied to Geographical Location • Pseudo-Anonymity • Every physicist that I know is registered in at least two institutions • But Institutions do not share registration information • So Tokyo University has no way to know that a UAB physicist is registered at CERN as an ATLAS collaborator Solving the Roaming Physicist problem / M. Delfino / PIC / IHEPCCC meeting

  7. What are some additional problems? • The “why should I pay” problem • Makes HEP-wide solutions based on commercial products or services not possible • The “why should I give services to people who don’t use my Laboratory” problem • Laboratory budgets are very strained, so it is understandable, but it means we loose “natural leadership”. • Can non-Laboratory institutes get organized and do something? • The “fear of Big Brother” effect makes a centralized registration repository difficult Solving the Roaming Physicist problem / M. Delfino / PIC / IHEPCCC meeting

  8. Will Grid solve these problems? • Maybe … someday … but current efforts are very oriented to batch and “production” • More optimistically, note that as part of development and deployment of Grid(s), we have (or will very soon have): • A reasonably complete set of interoperable X.509 Certification Authorities which are federated (important in order to comply with national laws) • A real-world set of functional managed Virtual Organizations (LHC expts, D0, etc.) • Some interesting “gridified” Internet utilities, for example “GridSite”, a gridified Apache Web server. Solving the Roaming Physicist problem / M. Delfino / PIC / IHEPCCC meeting

  9. Solving the problem is more an organizational than technical issue • What can we do to move forward? • I suggest a two-pronged approach with a feedback that can help “bootstrap” the system • Find a way to economically create and maintain a list of HEP Institutes and a “Registration Contact” for each. (Particle Data Group? SLAC-Spires? CERN?) • Deploy simple but useful service(s) based on voluntary but verified registration as “Member of HEP Community”. • Simplest imaginable useful service (to me!):A set of read/write Web servers using X.509 access control to be used as a “collaborative digital scratchpad”. • Next simplest would be X.509 access control to simple printing services at some key sites. • Another possibility: MAC address repository to automate MAC address registration at some key sites. • Another possibility: Tag email automatically as “HEP Community” Solving the Roaming Physicist problem / M. Delfino / PIC / IHEPCCC meeting

  10. Few more details on the proposal • Use of X.509/PKI is industry-standard. Revocation lists permit synchronized account management at a huge number of sites. • Registration Contacts are crucial • In order to solve another problem in HEP: People leave the community but their accounts are left open for long periods of time. • In order to quickly deal with security incidents. • “Infrastructurization” is important: Services should be viewed as “HEP Community”, not CERN, KEK, PIC, etc. • But at the end some institute must run some part of the service • How to collaborate and how to fund? • A disclaimer would have to be worked out to avoid any liabilities for malfunction (similar to Yahoo, AOL, etc.) • Services probably have to be in a “Closed Community” in order to avoid liability for misuse (illegal software, music, etc. distribution) • The devil is in the details… Solving the Roaming Physicist problem / M. Delfino / PIC / IHEPCCC meeting

  11. Summary • Today, High Energy Physicists “slice” their time between several experiments and many physical locations • This requires read/write access to information and other digital resources in a location independent manner • Grid(s) may solve the problem someday… • but in the meantime re-using some existing organizational and technical resources could make possible some simple services that would make the “Roaming Physicist” much happier. Solving the Roaming Physicist problem / M. Delfino / PIC / IHEPCCC meeting

More Related