1 / 28

Critical Theory of Communication Approach to Organizations

Critical Theory of Communication Approach to Organizations. Of Stanley Deetz in Em Griffin, A First Look at Communication Theory (4th ed.). CLICKER QUESTION. With regard to communication in the organization, Deetz is concerned with: = POWER = CONTROL IN DECISION-MAKING

hae
Download Presentation

Critical Theory of Communication Approach to Organizations

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Critical Theory of Communication Approach to Organizations Of Stanley Deetz in Em Griffin, A First Look at Communication Theory (4th ed.)

  2. CLICKER QUESTION With regard to communication in the organization, Deetz is concerned with: = POWER = CONTROL IN DECISION-MAKING = COMMUNICATION PRACTICES IN THE ORGANIZATION

  3. CLICKER Deetz views multinational corporations such as GM, AT&T, IBM, Time-Warner, and Amoco, as the dominant force in society; A = TRUE B = FALSE

  4. CLICKER Deetz challenges the view that communication is the transmission of information (the conduit model); A = TRUE B = FALSE

  5. CLICKER According to Deetz’s view, language does not represent things that already exist, language takes part in creating reality; A = TRUE B = FALSE

  6. CLICKER THE APPROACH TO MANAGEMENT THAT DEETZ FAVORS IS: A = STRATEGY; B = CONSENT; C = INVOLVEMENT; D = PARTICIPATION;

  7. Corporate Colonization of Everyday Life • Deetz views multinational corporations such as GM, AT&T, IBM, Time-Warner, and Amoco, as the dominant force in society; • The multinational corporations are seen as more powerful than the church, state or family in their influence of individuals’ lives; • For instance, over 90 % of mass media outlets--newspapers, broadcast, cable, telephone lines, and satellites--are owned by just a handful of corporations;

  8. Critical • Deetz’s theory of communication is criticalin that he wants to critique the easy assumption that “what’s good for General Motors is good for the country;” • Deetz wants to examine communication practices in organizations that undermine fully representative decision making, thus reducing the quality, innovation, and fairness of company policy;

  9. Information versus Communication • Deetz challenges the view that communication is the transmission of information (the conduit model); • Implicit in this model of transmission is the idea of an independent reality [World View I], one that is referred to by words that represent those things;

  10. : A CONDUIT OR TRANSMISSION MODEL

  11. Information versus Communication • Deetz sees the belief in a transmission (conduit) model as part of perpetuating corporate dominance; • As examples, the annual report of the corporation is presented as facts that stand apart from human decisions; • Instead, Deetz points out that what seems to be value-free information is really meaning in formation;

  12. Information versus Communication • In place of the information model, Deetz offers a communication model that regards language as the principal medium through which social reality is produced and reproduced; [DOES THIS IDEA SOUND FAMILIAR TO YOU? IT SHOULD. What comes to mind here is the Semiotic Tradition, Symbolic Interactionism and Constructivism];

  13. Information versus Communication • According to Deetz’s view, language does not represent things that already exist, language takes part in creating reality;

  14. Information versus Communication • People who adopt the language of big business may not be aware that they are putting corporate values into play; • For instance, “the bottom line” (an economic metaphor) is not necessarily the most important thing, there may be non-financial considerations to take into account;

  15. Communication & Power • Deetz thinks of communication as ongoing social construction (like Pearce and Cronen, chapter 5); • But Deetz differs in adding the issue of poweras central; • For Deetz, the fundamental issue is control and how different groups are represented in decision-making;

  16. Free expression but no voice in decisions Overt control Stakeholder democracy in action Covert control

  17. Strategy: Overt Control • Managerialism: discourse based on “a kind of systematic logic, a set of routine practices, and ideology;” • It comes down to control; • Choice is limited to loyalty or exit; • Regardless of a company’s product line or service, “control is the management product and is most clearly the one on which individual advancement rests.” • Efficiency becomes control as the key;

  18. Control • Nowhere is the quest for control more apparent than in the corporate aversion for public conflict; • Managers are rewarded for “putting out fires,” “running a tight ship,” or “making things run smoothly;”

  19. Consent: Covert Control Without Objection • Consent is when employees willingly give loyalty to the organization without getting much in return; • The employee actively, though unknowingly, “is complicit in her or his own victimization”; • The force of an organizational practice is strongest when no one even thinks about it [“That’s the way it’s done around here”];

  20. INVOLVEMENT: FREE EXPRESSION OF IDEAS • Shifting from the Managerial Control side of the figure on Organizational Practices to the Co-Determination side, is a shift from autocracy to liberal democracy; • Deetz says “the right of expression appears more central than the right to be informed or to have an effect;”

  21. INVOLVEMENT: FREE EXPRESSION OF IDEAS • Many managers use these open sessions as a way to let employees blow off steam; • When workers find out that their ideas aren’t represented in the final decision, they quickly become cynical about the process;

  22. Participation: Stakeholder Democracy in Action • Deetz believes that joint, open decisions in the workplace are possible; • One of the goals of his theory is to reclaim the possibility of open negotiations of power;

  23. Participation • Expand the list of people who should have a say: • investors • workers • consumers • suppliers • host communities • greater society and the world community

  24. Participation • Deetz believes that those who are affected by corporate decisions have a say; • He sees no legitimate basis for privileging one group of stakeholders over another;

  25. Participation • Deetz maintains that managerialism impedes democratic stakeholder participation through systematically distorted communication; • Systematic distortion operates through norms and expectations--it is subtle, e.g., arbitrary authority relations within an organization, suppression of conflict;

  26. Participation • Deetz would have managers take the role of mediators rather than persuaders, coordinating the conflicting interests of all parties affected by corporate decisions (p. 268); • Deetz suggests management start by gettting to know workers;

  27. Saturn: A Model of Stakeholder Participation • Saturn does much of what Deetz recommends: • Every member thinks and acts like an owner; • Management of work is reintegrated with the doing of work; • Quality information is widely distributed; • Social structure grows from the bottom rather than enforced from the top, i.e., work teams with authority;

  28. Critique • If everything is in play (constructivism), then do we have a right to participate in decisions that affect us; • Tongue-in-cheek summary:”If we just didn’t find it natural and right and unavoidable to hand power over to managers, everything would be very different and our problems would be solved” (quoting McPhee, p. 269);

More Related