200 likes | 357 Views
Translating Climate Change Issues Into Operational Reality. David Clarry March 5, 2008. Climate Change. Why is the world paying more attention to climate change What is the operational / technical “target” for CO2 emissions reduction
E N D
Translating Climate Change Issues Into Operational Reality David ClarryMarch 5, 2008
Climate Change • Why is the world paying more attention to climate change • What is the operational / technical “target” for CO2 emissions reduction • What are the mechanisms that put a cost on CO2 emissions, and what might that cost be • What are the implications in steel production costs • What can we do Climate Change
IPCC Summary Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change – Climate Change 2007: Physical Science Basis, February 2007 Why
Reduce by how much ? From IPCC Fourth Report
A very rough reduction scenario … • Canadian target of 20% below 2005 by 2020 • Bali non-binding agreement to 25% to 40% reduction in Annex 1 countries by 2020 35% intensity reduction by 2020 How Much ?
Some key jurisdictional actions • Europe – ETS, system of hard caps on emissions • United States – state initiatives aimed initially at energy sector • Canada • Alberta – regulation in place as of July 2007 • 12% intensity reduction target by December 31, 2007 • Achieved by reductions, purchasing offsets, or paying $15/tonne • National - draft Clean Air Act • 18% intensity reduction from 2006 levels by 2010 • 2% annual intensity reduction every year thereafter • Australia – state initiatives, potential for national initiative How Much ?
A world of opportunities and/or regulation Most of world is part of Kyoto Many of our project countries are eligible for credits How Much ? Kyoto Annex 1 Countries (emissions targets) Kyoto Annex 1 but no mechanism in place Kyoto “Non-Annex 1” – credit opportunities Non-Kyoto reduction regulation
Developing Country Credits are Real • ~$2 Billion of CDM credits have been sold to date • ~ $200 million of this revenue has gone to Iron & Steel projects How Much ? Ref: www.cdmpipeline.org (January 26, 2008)
Carbon credits represent real projects • Yangquan Coal Industry (Group) Co., Ltd. - Environmental Finance Magazine “Carbon Finance Transaction of the Year” • use of coal mine methane for power generation and alumina production projects • reduce emissions of CO2 by 17.8 million tons between 2007 and 2012 • Also reduces SOx, NOx • Iron & Steel • Combined Cycle Power Plant to generate electricity from blast furnace and coke oven • 6.6 MtCO2 reduction over 10 years
Potential mitigation / trading costs • EU credit value has ranged from less than 1 Euro to more than 20 Euros over the past year • A longer term view can be gained from costs of abatement How Much ?
Industry impact: example for integrated steel • A “typical” integrated steel mill could experience carbon costs in the range of $17/t to $55/t steel • If CO2 credits were $40/t (McKinsey curve) this would be higher How Much ?
Industry impact: example for aluminum • Cost of GHG emissions from “average” smelter is ~ $200/t • From recent concept study of “BAT” plant using hydroelectric power • Smelter & anode emissions ~ 1,000 to 2,000 kg CO2e per 1,000 kg Al • Cost of emissions $25 to $50 at $25/t CO2e • Actual cost of CO2e ? • Europe winter 2008 - $40/t CO2e How Much ?
Impact on industry • Regulatory changes and uncertainty • Regulation in Europe & Japan (and Alberta) • Pending regulation in many jurisdictions • Evolving global agreements will lead to more regulation within plant lifespans • How to level playing field with developing countries • Public scrutiny • Some EIA processes now require GHG analysis • Investors and stakeholders looking for GHG responses • Financial opportunities • Some Jurisdictions (South America, Russia, China, …) offer projects the potential to sell GHG credits Impact
Impact on industry (cont.) • A changing climate • Permafrost and ice roads less reliable • Anticipated trends in water availability, sea levels, …. • Warnings of more extreme weather variations Impact
Areas of response • Abatement • Energy & GHG efficiency • Process technology (non-carbon reduction, biomass reductants) • Alternative energy sources • CO2 capture and sequestration / fixation • Adaptation • Design standards • ESIA considerations • Retrofit
Stages of response • Planning / risk management • Technology development / demonstration • Operations / management action • Capital investment
What is happening now - Hatch Project Examples • GHG Inventories & lifecycle analysis • GHG abatement planning • Energy efficiency studies with GHG component • Competitiveness studies • Clean coal technologies – studies and demonstration plants • Coal Bed Methane liquefaction for transportation fuel • CO2 capture / sequestration / fixation • Boiler flue gas CO2 capture for process use • Captured CO2 for enhanced oil recovery • Reducing bauxite residue PH through CO2 fixation (Alcoa) • Development of GHG credits for project financing • Alternative Energy • Adaptation - Australia Western Corridor water recycling Hatch