930 likes | 1.04k Views
Homosexual Rights. Overview. Homosexuality has been a taboo subject Millions of gay and lesbian Americans are not only open about sexuality, they are campaigning for new laws. Overview. Want same rights as heterosexuals- want right to marry. Episcopalian church now has openly gay clergy
E N D
Overview • Homosexuality has been a taboo subject • Millions of gay and lesbian Americans are not only open about sexuality, they are campaigning for new laws
Overview • Want same rights as heterosexuals- want right to marry
Episcopalian church now has openly gay clergy • Half of Americans now say in surveys that homosexuality should be considered an acceptable alternative lifestyle-compared to 1 in 3 people 20 years ago
Overview • Surveys show Americans have mixed feelings about how far the government should go in giving rights to gays/lesbians • Emotionally charged issue, many Americans still view it as objectionable
Overview • 2-10% of Americans are homosexual • Many Americans lie or refuse to answer survey questions about sexuality, so we do not know accurate percentage
1969- New York City police raided a popular gay bar- the Stonewall Inn, for allegedly selling liquor without a license. This caused two days of rioting, started the gay awareness movement
1978- shooting death of San Francisco official Harvey Milk, openly gay man elected to office in a large city • Killer received 5 year sentence
AIDS • 1981- small group of gay men in San Francisco started getting sick and dying • Identified it as Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) • Virus destroys body’s immune system
AIDS • Spread through exchange of bodily fluid • Federal government slow to respond • 1985: study showed that more than half of Americans believed government would research AIDS more if it didn’t primarily affect gay men
AIDS • ActUp and Human Rights Campaign- wanted public attention and government action • “silence is death” • AIDS spreading, not limited to gay men- could spread through heterosexual sex and drug users sharing needles
Civil Rights • Matter of equality- Homosexuals felt they should have the same rights and protections as heterosexuals
Rights • Protection against discrimination in employment, housing, and immigration • Expansion of hate crime laws to include sexual orientation • Domestic partner benefits similar to those granted to married couples
Rights • Right to marry or have their relationships recognized in “civil unions” • The ability to serve in the military without hiding their sexuality
Rights • For many Americans, issue hinges on the question of whether homosexuality is a choice or an innate characteristic with which people are born
Rights • Advocates of gay rights say sexual orientation, like race or disability, can’t be changed, and therefore they should be protected like any other minority group
Rights • Opponents of gay rights- many have religious roots. Most major religions oppose homosexuality as a violation of the law of God
Rights • Opponents of gay rights also worry that children who interact with openly gay adults- teachers or Boy Scout leaders, will view these adults as role models and make that same sexual choice
Rights • 2003: US Supreme Court ruled that gays and lesbians have a right to sexual privacy and are “entitled to respect for their private lives.”
Partner and benefits • 1989: Denmark became the first nation to grant legal rights to gay couples, calling the unions “domestic partnerships”
Partner and benefits • 1999: Netherlands allowed full fledged same-sex marriages • Many Americans oppose granting legal recognition of same-sex couples, saying it would make a shift in definition of marriage
Partner and benefits • Marriage between man and a woman sanctifies the creation of new life and establishes the cohesive family (opponents) • Supporters: marriage is a fundamental right under Constitution and denying its benefits to homosexuals is discrimination
Partner and benefits • U.S. Constitution: states are required to offer “full faith and credit” to legal actions in other states, including marriage • Some legal experts argue there is an exception if states believe an out of state decision violates their own public policy
Partner and benefits • For example: if some state or foreign country allowed bigamy or underage marriages, other states could refuse to recognize it • Congress passed the Defense of Marriage Act in 1996 allowing states to refuse to recognize same sex marriage
Defense of Marriage Act 1996 • President Bill Clinton • “marriage” is a union between one man and one woman • All federal laws about marriage apply exclusively to opposite sex couples
Civil Unions- state benefits to same sex couples • State tax benefits, family health plans, co-parenting privileges, guardianship and decision making authority for medically incapacitated partner, protection under divorce and separation laws
Government Accountability Office lists 1,138 federal laws that pertain to married couples
Taxes: couples in a civil union may file a joint state tax return, but must file federal tax returns as single persons- this may be advantageous to some couples, but not for others