70 likes | 88 Views
Ex Post evaluation of cohesion policy intervention 2000-2006 financed by the Cohesion Fund (incl. ISPA) WP C – CBA of Environmental Projects Workshop with Member States, Brussels 3 February 2011 Session 4 b.
E N D
Ex Post evaluation of cohesion policy intervention 2000-2006 financed by the Cohesion Fund (incl. ISPA) WP C – CBA of Environmental ProjectsWorkshop with Member States,Brussels 3 February 2011Session 4 b Christina van Breugel, Tine Skyggebjerg, Szabolcs Szekeres, Birgitte Holt Andersen (COWI) Davide Sartori, Silvia Vignetti (Csil Ex post eval cohesion fund_DG Regio
10 case studies 17 Barcelona 01 Bulgaria 06 Crete Water management 09 Zaragosa 03 Pilsen Waste management 13 Madrid 50 Portugal 22 Dublin 29 Poland Waste water management 27 Hungary Ex post eval cohesion fund_DG Regio
Key Question No 1 • What are the strengths and weaknesses of the CBA methodologies applied by Member States? Ex post eval cohesion fund_DG Regio
Key question No 2 • How effective is CBA as a tool to support project generation and project decision of Member States and EC?? Ex post eval cohesion fund_DG Regio
Key Question No 3 • To what degree is the CBA used ex-post by project promotors, MS and EC? Ex post eval cohesion fund_DG Regio
Key Question No 4 • How good is CBA to evaluate impacts in an ex-post context? Ex post eval cohesion fund_DG Regio
Key Question No 5 • In practice how do you identify and judge the intangible environmental costs and benefits? • …and how can they become part of the decision process? Ex post eval cohesion fund_DG Regio