320 likes | 333 Views
Present and future of Early Hearing Detection and Intervention Systems in the European Area Ferdinando Grandori National Res. Council - Institute of Biomedical Engineering. Association for Research on Infant Hearing (non-profit). A QUESTION OF TERMINOLOGY
E N D
Present and future of Early Hearing Detection and Intervention Systems in the European AreaFerdinando GrandoriNational Res. Council - Institute of Biomedical Engineering Association for Research on Infant Hearing (non-profit)
A QUESTION OF TERMINOLOGY • < 2000 UNHS = Universal Newborn Hearing Screening • ~ 2002 EHDI = Early Hearing Detection and Intervention • ~ 2005HDI = Hearing Detection and Intervention
Summary_________________________________________________________________Summary_________________________________________________________________ • Penetration of EHDI systems • Protocols and Recommendations (i.e. genetic testing) • Int’l Group on Childhood Hearing
EHDI SYSTEMS IN THE EUROPEAN AREA IMPLEMENTED (>85%) PARTIALLY IMPLEM. ADV. PLANNING PILOTS
EHDI Systemsin the European area • The quality of audiological services varies dramatically from state to state • The success of the newly established EHDI programs does NOT reflect the economic conditions • Implementation of successful programs is more the result of (pre-existing) coordination among clinical communities at regional/ national level (the concept of integrated diagnostic-rehab path for each pathology)
EHDI Systemsin the European area • Not always (rarely?!) the process was driven by pediatric audiologists, nor by audiologists themselves • In many countries of the EU pediatric audiology was already in good shape. • Allthroghout Europe the quality of audiological services (and not only for pediatric audiology) is receiving a tremendous positive impulse from the implementation of EHDI programs • The concept of UNHS as an accelerator of Audiology and related disciplines (the horse of Troy)
EHDI Systemsin the European area • Countries with a national health service in place were able to implement better and more efficient EHDI and HDI systems • Countries where health services are organized at a regional level (Germany, Italy, Spain, and partially Sweden) are still behind (the concept of critical mass)
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ • Penetration of EHDI systems • About protocols and Recommendations (i.e. genetic testing) • Int’l Group on Childhood Hearing
Genetic testing • Genetic defects produce more than 60% of the congenital hearing losses • About 30% of these are syndromic • The remaining 70% are due to non-syndromic mendelian hereditary or mytocondrial defects: • Recessive (~80%) • Dominants (~20%) • X-linked (~1%) • Mytocondrial (~1%)
Genetic testingThe need for recommendations • Though recommendations may be tailored to local specific population-based studies, some general guidelines on genetic testing are needed • A few studies are coming out • An example of guidelines: a proposal coming from a working group on genetic deafness www.gendeaf.org
refer Acquired hearing loss Audiological assessment Unkown etiology Genetic testing
Individual and family examination refer Genetic testing Genetic investigations
Genetic investigation Non-syndromic Syndromic No mutations GJB2 dysmorphologies Composite Homo-heterozygote (recess.) or heterozyg. (dom.) Heteroz. Recess. Genetic tests (if available) DelG JB6D13 S1830 positive negative Identified genetic defect RR RR MtA15 5 5 G Unidentified geneticdefect positive negative Family screening
SCREENING PROTOCOLS Towards a two-track protocol • At-risk (NICU): AABR-based (+OAE, for AN screening) • Well-babies: • 1- or 2-stage AOAE+AABR • 1-stage AABR
SCREENING PROTOCOLS • Several large scale national/ regional programs have adopted the two-track protocol (e.g. England, Denmark, regions of Spain, most of the Swiss programs) • Overall, the AOAE+AABR model is predominant (>80% of the local screening programs)
AOAE pass fail STOP AABR fail pass STOP REFER 3rd GENERATION AOAE+AABR DEVICES
COMBINED AOAE+AABR • Intracanal calibration for OAE and ABR • Lower refers and false-positive cases • Great flexibility to cope with the variety of screening conditions: nursery, NICU…. • Minimal parental anxiety (no more a real problem) • Fewer diagnostic tests • Less infants lost to follow-up • Quicker & more appropriate management • Screening for auditory neuropathy in just 1 session
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ • Penetration of EHDI systems • About protocols and recommendations (i.e. genetic testing) • International Working Group on Childhood Hearing
3 1 2
SUB-GROUPS • Permanent observatory of EHDI / childhood hearing • Outcomes of EHDI programs • Genetics • Minimum requirements / standards for screening and diagnostic equipment • Pediatric audiology services
Argentina FEW Armenia ATTEMPTS Australia +++PI Brazil FEW Bulgaria ATTEMPTS Canada +++PI China +ATTEMPTS Cuba ++PI India ATTEMPTS Indonesia ATTEMPTS Israel ++++I
Japan +++PI Jordan ATTEMPTS Mexico ATTEMPTS N. Zealand +PI Palestinian Authority ATTEMPTS Russia +FEW Serbia&Montenegro ATTEMPTS Singapore +FEW South Africa +FEW South Korea ATTEMPTS Turkey +FEW