1 / 11

BART Progress in Alabama

BART Progress in Alabama. Larry W. Brown 334-271-7886 lwb@adem.state.al.us May 2007. Things I’m Going to Talk About. BART History BART Results (We think) RFP (Reasonable Freaking Progress for those of me that don’t know much about what I am talking about.). BART History. Class I Areas

issac
Download Presentation

BART Progress in Alabama

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. BART Progress in Alabama Larry W. Brown 334-271-7886 lwb@adem.state.al.us May 2007 adem.alabama.gov

  2. Things I’m Going to Talk About • BART History • BART Results (We think) • RFP (Reasonable Freaking Progress for those of me that don’t know much about what I am talking about.) adem.alabama.gov

  3. BART History • Class I Areas • Sipsey - North West Alabama • Breton - South West of Mobile in LA • Cohutta - North East in Georgia • St. Marks - South East in Florida • Great Smoky - North East in Tennessee Mountain adem.alabama.gov

  4. BART History • 37 Sources met original criteria • 3 sources excluded with reinterpretation of VOC inclusion as BART pollutant • 2 sources excluded with interpretation of boilers being integral to a process • 1 source shut down BART eligible unit • 2 sources synthetic minored < 250 TPY • 28 sources screened out < .5 deciview impact • 1 source agreed to limitations to reduce impact < .5 deciview by 1-1-13 adem.alabama.gov

  5. BART History • 2 sources remaining (not including any sources in Jefferson County) • Preliminary BART submittals have been received. THREE TIMES EACH! • Its too expensive, there isn’t enough visibility improvement to justify anything, it’s going to put us out of business, we will have to shut those units down, yada yada yada…. adem.alabama.gov

  6. BART Results • Source A • Boiler 1 536 mmbtu/hr coal fired • Install overfire air – NOX reductions 48% (668 TPY) [actually being done to comply with boiler MACT] • Flue gas Sorbent Injection – SO2 reductions 60 % (1441 TPY) 932 $/T • Boiler 2 & 3 360 and 350 mmbtu/hr coal fired • Reduce coal %S ~50% reduction • 1066 $/T • 2 Units no controls economically feasible without shutting down operation. adem.alabama.gov

  7. BART Results • Source B • Boiler 1 679 mmbtu/hr Coal/wood fired • Install low NOx burners and air system 20 % reduction (218 TPY) 1598 $/T • Boiler 2 470 mmbtu/hr Recovery Furnace • No controls economically feasible (3633 $/T) • Boiler 3 365 mmbtu/hr Gas fired swing boiler • No additional controls economically feasible (2767 $/t) • Boiler 4 398 mmbtu/hr Coal/wood fired • Boiler will be limited to operation as back up unit only when other boilers are not in operation. adem.alabama.gov

  8. BART Results

  9. REAL BART Results • Estimate that 5 man (woman) years have been spent by ADEM on BART to date. • Let’s round that off to about $500,000 • 1970 total tons reduced • $254 per ton vs Title V fees of $35 • Less than 1 stinking deciview improvement adem.alabama.gov

  10. RFP • We are currently working on review. • Performing (Q/D)RTmax analysis • Currently, it appears that the glide path is being met for Sipsey Wilderness Area • No further action has been identified by (Q/D)RTmax analysis at this time. • Waiting on final RFP guidance from EPA adem.alabama.gov

  11. Summary • 2 Sources implementing controls • 1970 tons reduction • $2,000,000 per year • 0.9 deciview improvement adem.alabama.gov

More Related