270 likes | 498 Views
Theoretical Perspective. The adolescent transition in seeking intimacy, affection and support: From parents, to peers and (eventually) to romantic partnersAn
E N D
1. Observed Autonomy And Connection With Parents And Peers As Predictors Of Early Adolescent Sexual Adaptation Joseph P. Allen Felicia HallUniversity of Virginia
2. Theoretical Perspective The adolescent transition in seeking intimacy, affection and support:
From parents, to peers and (eventually) to romantic partners
An “intimacy and affection gap” in early adolescence?
Teens try to rely on parents less, but peer relationships are still slowly developing
Same-gender peer relations may help fill this intimacy gap as may parents, to a decreasing degree.
Overarching Hypothesis:
Early adolescents will seek intimacy prematurely from romantic relationships when they are not able to obtain it with parents and same-gender peers.
3. Central Question:
Do high quality close relationships with parents and peers predict a slower onset of dating and sexual behavior?
If so, which aspects of these relationships are most important?
4. Sample 148 Adolescents, their Parents and Best Friends
Assessed Annually, Beginning at Age 13
Equal numbers of Males and Females
Community-based Sample from a small urban area.
31% African American; 69% European American
Highly Socio-economically Diverse (Median Family Income= $38,000)
5. Measures: Dating & Sex Dating Behavior
Computer-assisted Interviewing to maintain anonymity
5-items, Assessing Dating History and Low-level romantic/sexual behavior (e.g., holding hands, kissing, etc.)
Summed into a single overall scale.
Mean at Wave 1 (age 13): 12.56 s.d. = 8.80
Mean at Wave 2 (age 14): 14.28 s.d. = 8.12
Mean at Wave 3 (age 15): 15.72 s.d. = 9.00
6. Measures: Dating & Sex Sexual Behavior
Computer-assisted Interviewing to maintain anonymity
Multiple questions about intercourse, but focus here on presence or absence of a history of consensual sexual intercourse.
Sexually Active at Age 13: 10.3%
Sexually Active at Age 14: 13.7%
Sexually Active at Age 15: 23.4%
7. Measures: Dating & Sex Attitudes Toward Sexual Behavior
Assessed for Both Mothers and Adolescents
“At What Age Are Each of the Following Appropriate:
referring to someone as a boyfriend/girlfriend
going out on dates in groups
going out on dates alone
kissing
falling in love
having sex
Items are averaged to yield an overall measure of Liberal Attitudes (e.g., activities are appropriate at younger ages.)
Mother and Teen Values are significantly correlated: r = .52***, but…
8. Mean Age (Years) at Which Mothers and Adolescents See Different Romantic Behaviors as Acceptable:
9. Maternal Views of Acceptable Ages for Various Behaviors vs.Actual Incidence of Behaviors by Age 13
10. Predictions from Adolescent Attitudes at Age 13 to Change in Dating Behavior from Age 13 to Age 15
11. Hypothesized Relationship Predictors of Adolescent Dating and Sexual Behavior Competence with:
Autonomy Establishing Behaviors
Relatedness/Connection Maintaining Behaviors
12. Hypothesized Relationship Predictors of Adolescent Dating and Sexual Behavior Competence with:
Autonomy Establishing Behaviors:
Observing a Disagreement in a Revealed Differences Task
Coded via Autonomy & Relatedness Coding System (Allen et al., 1998)
Can disagreements be handled in a way that preserves both members’ autonomy and sense of relatedness with one another?
13. Hypothesized Relationship Predictors of Adolescent Dating and Sexual Behavior Competence with:
Connection-Promoting Behaviors:
8-minute task conducted separately with
Adolescents and their Mothers
Adolescents and their Closest Friend
Discussing a Topic about which the Teen “would like some help.”
Discussions cover a broad range of topics selected by the teen (e.g., how to earn income, to peer teasing, to academic issues)
14. Measures: Supportive Behavior Interaction Task(Crowell et al., in press; Julien, Markman et al., 1997) Coded for:
Emotional support provided by parent or peer
Degree of Engagement with other person in the interaction
Listener’s Accurate Interpretation of the problem
Apparent Teen Satisfaction with Interaction
15. Predictions from Competence with Autonomy Tasks: No Predictions Were Found
The scales from the Autonomy & Relatedness Coding System were consistently and robustly not linked to adolescent dating or sexual behavior.
Handling of disagreements with parents is not linked to adolescent dating and sexual behavior in early adolescence
16. Predictions from Satisfaction withSupportive Interaction Task with Mothers (Age 13)
17. Predictions from Peer Engagement withSupportive Interaction Task with Closest Friend (Age 13)
18. Predictions from Peer Interpretation Skill inSupportive Interaction Task with Closest Friend (Age 13)
19. Predictions from Teen Engagement inSupportive Interaction Task with Closest Friend (Age 13)
20. Predictions from Teen Satisfaction with Supportive Interaction Task with Closest Friend (Age 13)
21. Predictions from Maternal Engagement inSupportive Interaction Task with Mothers (Age 13)
22. Conjoint role of Maternal & Peer Engagement in Predicting Adolescent Sexual Behavior
23. Prediction of Teen Attitudes Toward Romantic/Sexual Behavior
24. Prediction of Teen Attitudes Toward Romantic Behaviors from Maternal Attitudes X Maternal Engagement
25. Prediction of Changes in Teen Attitudes Toward Romantic/Sexual Behavior
26. Predictors of Adolescent Dating & Sexual Behavior Overarching Conclusion:
Qualities of Adolescent’s NON-Sexual relationships are good predictors of dating and sexual behavior
Specific Findings:
Autonomy processes do not generally appear as predictors of dating or sexual behavior
A Strong Connection to Parents and Peers is the most consistent predictor of avoidance of early dating and sex.
27. Predictors of Adolescent Dating & Sexual Behavior Limitations
Longitudinal analyses do not support causal inferences
Need to consider other aspects of peer relations
Have not yet examined autonomy in peer relations
Predictors of behavior at age 14 may be different from those later in adolescence