220 likes | 341 Views
Adolescent Narcissism and the Double Edge of Risk and Adaptation. Daniel K. Lapsley Michael Earley Ball State University O’Dea High School Nathan M. Dumford Miami University SRA 2006 San Francisco. Narcissism has “two faces”. Narcissism as adaptation
E N D
Adolescent Narcissism and the Double Edge of Risk and Adaptation Daniel K. LapsleyMichael Earley Ball State University O’Dea High School Nathan M. Dumford Miami University SRA 2006 San Francisco
Narcissism has “two faces” • Narcissism as adaptation • narcissism as defensive compensatory stance that helps adolescents cope with sep-ind • narcissism supports self-extension, ambition, creativity, growth • Narcissism as self-pathology or personality disorder
The study of adolescent narcissism requires new assessment strategies Three studies chart development of a theoretically-derived adolescent narcissism scale
Theoretical Considerations Adolescent narcissism emerges for good developmental reasons to cope with self-vulnerabilities that attend separation-individuation subjective omnipotence
Narcissistic omnipotence… …”denotes a defensive and reactive heightening of self-esteem to cope with inner feelings of low self-worth, depressive mood and empty feelings” --Sarnoff (1987)
Study 1 examined relationship between subjective omnipotence (personal fable) and narcissism (NPI) risk behavior internalizing symptoms positive adjustment
Study 1 Participants 222 8th-graders (101 males, Mage = 13.39) 142 10th-graders (72 males, Mage = 15.43) 102 12th-graders (46 males, Mage = 17.45) N = 467
Study 1 • Omnipotence (α = .79) • NPI (α = .83) • Internalizing Symptoms • Children’s Depression Inventory (α = = .86) • CES-D suicidal ideation (α = .86) • Risk Behavior • Rowe: “Delinquent” risk behavior (α = .92) • Substance use (α = =.74) • Positive adjustment • SIQYA: Mastery Coping (α = .76) • SIQYA: Superior Adjustment (α = .70)
Omnipotence • strongly associated with mastery coping and adjustment • counterindicates depression • counterindicates suicidal ideation • converges with NPI narcissism • sex effect (favoring males)
Study 2 • standard scale development procedures yields 33 item scale • EFA • 228 undergraduates • (73 males, Mage = 21.85) • 3 factors retained • scree and parallel analysis criteria • 40% of the variance
Three Factors • Omnipotent Action/Control • “Everybody knows that I am in charge” • 12 items (α = .85) • Omnipotent Leadership • “I would make a great leader because of my abilities” • 13 items (α = .83) • Omnipotent Influence • “I influence how others behave” • 7 items (α = .80)
Other Measures CES-Depression Adolescent Invulnerability Scale Delinquent Risk Behavior
Summary • Omnipotence scales converge with NPI-Narcissism • Omnipotence scales show differential relationship with risk behavior and depressive symptoms
Study 3 Document convergent validity in younger sample (using NPI-C) Distinguish adolescent narcissism from self-worth Explore relationship between narcissism and separation-individuation
Study Details • N = 142 males (Mage) = 16 • Instruments • Adolescent Omnipotence Scale • Action (α = .83) • Leadership (α = .80) • Influence (α = .80) • Narcissistic Personality Inventory-C (α = .86) • Self-Perception Profile (α’s = .53 to .85) • Dysfunctional Separation-Individuation • Self Dysfunctional S-I (α = .68) • Relational Dysfunctional S-I (α = .73) • Self-Image Questionnaire for Young Adolescents • Mastery Coping (α = .76) • Superior Adjustment (α = .79)
Summary • Omnipotence converges with narcissism • omnipotence scales associated with indices of positive adjustment • are related to dysfunctional sep-ind • counterindicate self-worth • in test of means: • younger Ss more feelings of subjective omnipotence than older Ss
General Conclusions • theoretically-derived and reliable measure of adolescent narcissism • factors converge with NPI and NPI-C • predict adolescent risk behavior • counterindicates internalizing affect • positively associated with mastery coping and adjustment • which may be compensatory • association with dysfunctional sep-ind • low scores on several dimensions of self-worth