80 likes | 230 Views
IEEE 802.11-IETF March Summary. Dorothy Stanley, Agere Systems. IETF/IEEE 802.11 January 15 th , 2004 Meeting Summary. CAPWAP Potential need for additional IEEE 802.11 AP functionality and interface requirement definition Continue planned liaison and review activities
E N D
IEEE 802.11-IETF March Summary Dorothy Stanley, Agere Systems D. Stanley, Agere Systems
IETF/IEEE 802.11 January 15th, 2004 Meeting Summary • CAPWAP • Potential need for additional IEEE 802.11 AP functionality and interface requirement definition • Continue planned liaison and review activities • RADIUS Extensions (RADEXT) Interaction • Process for RADIUS attribute definition: Same as IEEE 802.1 (Publish as Internet Draft for Review) • EAP Network Discovery • Q: Is This being Addressed in 802.11? • A: Network Discovery alternatives are in scope for proposed Wireless Interworking SG D. Stanley, Agere Systems
Attendees • IETF: Bert Wijnen (AD Operations), Bernard Aboba (IAB), James Kempf (IESG), Dave Nelson (RADEXT, also .11) • IEEE 802.11: Stuart Kerry (Chair), Bob O’Hara, David Halasz (Chair 802.11i), Dorothy Stanley (IEEE 802.11 to IETF Liaison), Clint Chaplin (Chair Fast Roaming SG) D. Stanley, Agere Systems
IETF/IEEE 802.11 Meeting CAPWAP Discussion - 1 • Several vendors have come to the IETF requesting definition of a CAPWAP protocol; Definition of any CAPWAP protocol(s) require assumptions on AP functionality partitioning between AP and AC. Together the AP and AC provide the traditional “AP” functionality • Current IEEE 802.11 AP functionality and interface requirements definition is sparse, and located across several documents. Need a cohesive, complete definition. • Consider the AP “functional” architecture and the “network” architecture • IEEE 802.11 owns the definition of AP functionality. • IETF successfully defines protocols for use between network elements, typically at layer 3 and above. • Once the AP functions are defined, they can be mapped to a network architecture, and the IETF can define/re-use existing protocols for communication between the network elements. D. Stanley, Agere Systems
IETF/IEEE 802.11 Meeting CAPWAP Discussion- 2 • CAPWAP Working Group has been formed with a charter to perform a taxonomy of existing vendor implementations, to identify protocols in use. • CAPWAP Working Group should also identify elements of AP functionality definition that are needed – as input to IEEE 802.11 further AP functional architecture definition • IEEE 802.11 will initiate a call for interest for AP architecture definition • IEEE 802.11 Wireless LANs Next Generation (WNG) committee March 14-19 agenda includes: AP Functional Definition. The purpose is to codify the functional architecture including functional blocks, interfaces and information exchanges • Continue planned liaison and review activities D. Stanley, Agere Systems
IETF/IEEE 802.11 Meeting – RADIUS Extensions • RADIUS Extensions (RADEXT) Working Group to be formed • What process should be used for RADIUS attribute definition? • Define attributes in IEEE 802.11? • Define attributes in IETF? • Had issues in the past with IEEE 802.11f incorrectly defining RADIUS commands • Some of the IEEE 802.11 attributes actually are more general in scope; useful to have these defined centrally, to identify general needs across applications (IEEE 802.11, 802.1, 3GPP, Wi-Fi, etc) • Agreement: Process for RADIUS attribute definition: Same as IEEE 802.1 (Publish IEEE 802.11 needs as an Internet Draft to obtain Review within IETF) • Agreement: RADIUS command definition in RADEXT D. Stanley, Agere Systems
IETF/IEEE 802.11 Meeting – Discussion EAP Network Discovery • Is EAP network discovery being addressed in IEEE 802.11 working groups? • Network Discovery alternatives are in scope for proposed WLAN Inter-working with External IP networks SG • Determine impacts on IEEE 802.11, for example:network selection: is anything additional required in the MAC to support network selection, such as operator advertisement, discovery of network capabilities before authentication etc? • Work underway on an Internet draft summarizing the requests and current status of IETF work (B. Aboba, J. Arrko), see http://www.ietf.org/internet-drafts/draft-ietf-eap-netsel-problem-00.txt • Have received requests to use EAP as a mechanism for WLAN network discovery • Discussion of these requests should be in new IEEE 802.11 SG D. Stanley, Agere Systems
IEEE 802.11 EAP Requirements • IEEE 802.11 has documented the requirements on EAP methods for WLAN applications, see IEEE document 11-04-0160-01-000i-ieee-802-11-eap-requirements.doc • Informational RFC drafted to document the requirements in the IETF, see http://www.ietf.org/internet-drafts/draft-walker-ieee802-req-00.txt • Stuart Kerry (IEEE 802.11 Chair) requested publication of this document as an informational RFC • IETF last call will complete March 28, 2004 D. Stanley, Agere Systems