1 / 20

Side-by-Side Comparison of Eight Field Test Methods with ASTM Reference Tests

Side-by-Side Comparison of Eight Field Test Methods with ASTM Reference Tests. Dr. Don Heck November 3, 2010. Purpose of Study:. Many field-test instruments becoming available: Portable Fast Convenient Cost effective How comparable are the results to the reference ASTM/EN procedures?.

jena
Download Presentation

Side-by-Side Comparison of Eight Field Test Methods with ASTM Reference Tests

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Side-by-Side Comparison of Eight Field Test Methods with ASTM Reference Tests Dr. Don Heck November 3, 2010

  2. Purpose of Study: • Many field-test instruments becoming available: • Portable • Fast • Convenient • Cost effective • How comparable are the results to the reference ASTM/EN procedures?

  3. InfraCal (Wilkes)- Mid-IR Spectrometer • InfraSpec (Wilkes)- Mid-IR Spectrometer • Irox Diesel (Grabner)- Mid FT-IR Spectrometer • MiniDis (Grabner)- Atmospheric Distillation

  4. PetroOXY (Petrotest)- Rapid Small Scale Oxidation test • QTA (Cognis)- Mid FT-IR Spectrometer • QTA Mini (Cognis)- “QTA Lite” • Sulfur Express (Antek)- UV Fluorescence Spectrometer • ZX-101C (Zeltex)- Near-IR Spectrometer

  5. Fuel Samples Used

  6. B100 B100

  7. Anecdotal Thoughts…. • InfraCal and InfraSpec • Easy to run, easy to clean; InfraSpec needed computer • Minimal consumables, chemicals etc. • Irox Diesel • Relatively easy to operate, no consumables, no cleaning • Some warm-up time needed, hexane needed as reference • MiniDis • Small sample volume, faster than D86, minimal cleaning (disposable sample cups) • Crimped lines- easy fix; heating error- self corrected

  8. PetroOxy • Definitely faster, easy to use/maintain, minimal consumables • Correlates with EN 15751 • Does require oxygen line • QTA & QTA Mini • fast, multiple analyses, minimal consumables, easy to clean/maintain • On-line access 24/7 • Sulfur Express • Compact, easy to set up, stand-alone (no gasses) • Not recommended for B100 (plugged needles); not recommended for high throughput • Some consumables, 45 min warm-up, incessant beeping! • ZX-101C • Very simple and easy to use • Relatively large sample volume • Calibration curves possibly switched

  9. Acknowledgements • DOE • Josh Hayes • Kelly Kuester

More Related