120 likes | 242 Views
New Directions in Federal Telecom Policies. Presentation by Professor Robert G. Harris California Conference of Public Utility Counsel Monterey, CA October 5, 2009. Regulatory Policy: FCC Antitrust & Competition Policy: FTC & DOJ
E N D
New Directions in Federal Telecom Policies Presentation by Professor Robert G. HarrisCalifornia Conference of Public Utility CounselMonterey, CA October 5, 2009
Regulatory Policy: FCC • Antitrust & Competition Policy: FTC & DOJ • Promotional Policy: NTIA/Commerce & RUS/DOA (Broadband Stimulus) Triangle of Telecom Policy-Making Agencies
Reviewing, overturning FCC regulatory decisions (UNE-P) • Restricting application of antitrust laws in private enforcement actions (Trinko, LinkLine) In the Shadow of the Law: The Role of the Courts
Will Court decisions limiting reach of antitrust laws cause policy-makers to use regulatory instruments instead? • Will Courts limit use of regulatory intervention (e.g. sale of wireless spectrum not subject to “net neutrality”)? Regulation and Antitrust as Substitutes and as Complements
The “Wave” Effect (cross-industry tendencies) • Deregulation of 1970’s-80’s • Reregulation of 2008-16? Major Forces of Change
Personnel FCC: Genachowsi DOJ: Varney FTC: Leibowitz NTIA: Strickling • Agenda for Change • Activist Philosophical Approach Major Forces of Change
Cooperative Institutional Relationships • Broadband: NTIA stimulus grants, FCC “broadband policy” • Exclusive handset agreements (Apple-AT&T): DOJ, FCC Major Forces of Change
Continuing shift toward Federal v state policy-making • Digital convergence across content and media • Globalization of communications and information services • Federal fiscal policy (stimulus) Major Forces of Change
More aggressive merger enforcement • Testing the limits of Sherman Section 2 monopolization cases • Use of consumer protection provisions of Section 5 • Use of antitrust enforcement to protect against “patent holdup” Antitrust, Competition Policy & Consumer Protection
Net neutrality (Regulating VOIP, GoogleVoice?) • Wireless competition • Public subsidies to broadband investment • Universal service: expand to wireless? broadband? • Industry consolidation (e.g. cable systems, wireless) Regulatory Policy
Health Care: remote service delivery, digitization of records • Education: connecting schools to broadband, learning “at home” • Energy: smart grid Telecom as an “Enabler”