130 likes | 256 Views
Evaluating Business Opportunities Jamie Goldstein nbvp.com. Evaluating Business Opportunities. The Deal Scorecard Real World Feedback Q&A. The Deal Scorecard. 1. 10. 1. Management. 2. Market. 3. Competition. 4. Product/Technology. 5. Ability to Forecast Results. 6. Capital Intensity.
E N D
Evaluating Business Opportunities Jamie Goldstein nbvp.com
Evaluating Business Opportunities • The Deal Scorecard • Real World Feedback • Q&A
The Deal Scorecard 1 10 1. Management 2. Market 3. Competition 4. Product/Technology 5. Ability to Forecast Results 6. Capital Intensity
Management 10 1 Senior Team Proven Record No Operating Experience • Good Teams have: • Done their jobs before (no OJT) • Experienced ramp from startup to big company • Relevant industry experience & contacts • Specialized expertise and insight • Ability to adapt to change • Brains and hunger • Example: SilverStream
Management • A Good Incomplete Team • Vision • Energy and hunger • Efficient • Wants to be the best and hire the best • Appropriate role for each person • Acknowledges management gaps • Values muscle building over time • Example: HighWired.Net
Market 10 1 > $1 Billion CAGR > 30% Stagnant • Attractive Markets: • Big • Adopt new products quickly • Customers that feel real pain • Customers that can be reached economically • The time is (will be) right • Example: Centra
Competition 10 1 Potential for Leadership Several Established Players • Leading Companies: • Typically first to market • Leaders define “Market” • Leaders get market share • Market share critical to success • Example: MyTeam.com, B2B marketplaces
Product/Technology 10 1 Clearly Superior Providing Leverage No Advantage • Leading Products: • Difficult to replicate • Special technical skills required • Special domain knowledge required • Proprietary technology (patents) • Many man*months (time, $) • Improve rapidly with customer feedback • Example: Phase Forward
Ability to Forecast Results 10 1 High Low • Great companies create and execute operating plans: • Plan is financial expression of strategy • Defines business model • Shows interrelation of timelines, functions, hires • Reflects detailed understand of the business • Example: 2nd Century Communications
Capital Intensity 10 1 Low High • A function of: • Capital expenditure needs • Working capital needs • Gross margins • Sales and marketing expenses • Example: SmarterKids.com
No Single Recipe A B C 1 10 1. Management 2. Market 3. Competition 4. Product/Technology 5. Ability to Forecast Results 6. Capital Intensity
Real World Feedback • Friends and family • Interviews with: • Customers, Analysts, Potential hires, • Potential partners, Other CEOs • Where is the pain? • Would you buy? • How many? • How do you buy? • What could we do better? • Listen, Listen, Listen • Example: Rajmataj