240 likes | 503 Views
WRAP Fugitive Dust Handbook. Richard Countess Countess Environmental Westlake Village, CA WRAP Workshop May 24, 2006 Sacramento, CA. Fugitive Dust Originates from Many Different Source Categories. Overview.
E N D
WRAP Fugitive Dust Handbook Richard Countess Countess Environmental Westlake Village, CA WRAP Workshop May 24, 2006 Sacramento, CA
Fugitive Dust Originates from Many Different Source Categories
Overview • The handbook is intended to be a comprehensive resource on emission estimation methodologies and control measures to reduce fugitive dust emissions. • The methods for estimating dust emissions rely on AP-42 and alternative methods adopted by air quality agencies in the WRAP region. • Because many formulae and factors incorporate default values that have been derived for average US conditions, area-specific factors should be used when available. • The handbook and associated website will be updated as new information becomes available.
Handbook Features • Comprehensive documentation of emission estimation methods adopted by federal and state agencies plus methods in the developmental stage • Detailed discussion of demonstrated control measures • Lists of published control efficiencies for a large number of fugitive dust control measures for each fugitive dust source category
Handbook Features (continued) • Sample regulatory formats adopted by state and local agencies in the WRAP region • Sample compliance tools to assure that the regulations are being followed • Detailed methodology for calculating the cost-effectiveness of different control measures • Sample calculations for control measure cost-effectiveness for each fugitive dust source category
CATEGORY AP-42 CARB OTHER Agricultural Tilling X Construction and Demolition X MRI Materials Handling X Paved Roads X X Unpaved Roads X X Agricultural Wind Erosion X Open Area Wind Erosion X MacDougall Storage Pile Wind Erosion X Emission Estimation Methodologies for Eight Fugitive Dust Source Categories Covered in the 2004 Handbook
Source Category Control Measure Control Efficiency Agricultural Tilling Conservation practices 25 - 100% Construction/Demo. Water unpaved surfaces 10 – 74% Materials Handling Wet suppression 50 – 70% Paved Roads Sweep streets 4 – 26% Unpaved Roads Apply water 10 – 74% Wind Erosion Artificial wind barriers 4 – 88% Published PM10 Control Efficiencies for Control Measures Show Large Variability
Evaluation of Fugitive Dust Control Measure Options Due to large uncertainties in published control cost-effectiveness estimates, which range over several orders of magnitude, a standardized methodology was developed to calculate the cost-effectiveness of fugitive dust control measures rather than presenting published estimates.
Technical Approach for Calculating Cost-Effectiveness of Control Measures • Developed a uniform step-by-step methodology for calculating the cost-effectiveness for different control measures • Provided a generic sample calculation for each fugitive dust source category • Included lists of published control efficiencies for different control measures • Evaluation of control measure options should be based on cost data and assumptions applicable to the specific situation (location, season, etc.)
Steps to Calculate Cost-Effectiveness of Specific Control Measures • Identify applicable emission factor equation • Select a specific control measure for the fugitive dust source • Specify the basic parameters required to calculate uncontrolled and controlled emissions • parameters used in the emission factor equation • source extent (activity level) • control measure implementation schedule (freq./application rate) • Calculate emission factor from the applicable emission factor equation
Cost-Effectiveness Calculation (continued) • Calculate the annual uncontrolled emission rate as the product of the emission factor and the source extent • Determine the control efficiency of the control measure • Calculate annual controlled emission rate • Calculate emissions reduction due to control measure (uncontrolled minus controlled emission rate) • Gather cost estimates for implementing control measure • annualized capital costs • annual O&M/overhead/enforcement/compliance costs
Cost-Effectiveness Calculation (continued) • Calculate annualized capital investment cost • Calculate total annualized cost (sum of annualized capital investment cost plus annual O&M/overhead/enforcement/compliance costs) • Calculate cost-effectiveness ($/ton PM10 reduction) of selected control measure (total annualized costs divided by the emissions reduction)
2006 Revisions to the Handbook • Revise each chapter and sample cost-effectiveness calculation to account for new estimates of PM2.5 fraction of fugitive dust being considered for adoption by the EPA based on MRI’s 2005 laboratory results • Address new source categories • Agricultural Harvesting • Mining and Quarrying • Livestock Husbandry • Abrasive Blasting • Expand existing chapters to incorporate new information
Agricultural Harvesting (new chapter) • AP-42 Emission Estimation Methodology (Section 9.3) • last updated Feb. 1980 • addresses PM7 rather than PM10 • CARB’s Emission Estimation Methodology (Section 7.5) • last updated Jan. 2003 (currently under review) • PM10 EFs developed for cotton, almonds and wheat serve as a baseline for over 200 other crops • PM2.5/PM10 = 0.222 • Control measures listed on CAPCOA’s website (http://capcoa.org/ag_clearinghouse.htm) • Control efficiencies for control measures are 8% - 70%
Mining & Quarrying (new chapter) • AP-42 Emission Estimation Methodology (Section 11) • 16 of 31 mineral products industries involve mining and quarrying • last updated in late 1990’s • PM10 EFs not available for all industries • lists EFs for both uncontrolled and controlled emissions • not all particulate emissions are fugitive • Supplemental EFs in EPA’s emissions trends documents • PM10 and TSP EFs and PM10/TSP ratios • Addressed at the District level rather than the state level in California (e.g., SCAQMD Rule 1157 adopted January 2005)
Mining & Quarrying (continued) • NEI Emission Estimation Methodology • utilizes the sum of emissions from metallic ore, nonmetallic ore, and coal mining operations • extraction of ore from the earth involves overburden removal, drilling and blasting, loading and unloading • coal mining also involves overburden replacement, and loading and unloading of the overburden • amount of overburden = 10 X coal mined • EFs for mining copper ore applied to all metallic ores • EFs for coal mining applied to all nonmetallic ores
Mining & Quarrying (continued) • NEI Emission Estimation Methodology (continued) • does not include the following activities that are assumed to be well controlled (CE = 78% to >99.5%) • transfer and conveyance • crushing and screening • storage • travel on haul roads • PM10 EFs • 0.054 lb/ton for metallic mining • 0.29 lb/ton for nonmetallic mining • 0.51 lb/ton for coal mining
Other New Chapters for the Handbook • Livestock Husbandry • Not addressed in AP-42 • CARB Emission Estimation Methodology (Section 7.6) • PM10 EF for dairies = 6.7 lb/1000 head/day • PM10 EF for feedlots = 29 lb/1000 head/day • PM2.5/PM10 ratio = 0.114 • Abrasive Blasting • AP-42 PM10 EF = 26 lb/ton of sand • Using grit or shot instead of sand as the abrasive media reduces PM emissions by 76% and 90%, respectively • PM2.5/PM10 ratio = 0.10
Planned Expansion of Existing Chapters • Incorporate DEJF’s definition of fugitive dust • Include discussion of fugitive dust transport issues • Incorporate Environ’s work addressing wind erosion emission estimates • Incorporate new information on demonstrated control measures
Fugitive Dust Websitewww.wrapair.org/forums/dejf/fdh • Website populated with material from the handbook • primary menu laid out by source category • includes links to other useful resources • Downloadable files include: • Word & PDF text files for each source category plus for the entire handbook • Interactive Excel cost-effectiveness calculation spreadsheets with lookup tables of default values for different parameters for each source category • History of revisions
ANY QUESTIONS? For further information, contact: rcountess@aol.com