600 likes | 942 Views
“The Future for Investors” by Jeremy Siegel. Kevin Kranzler Lisa Lajeunesse Ray Ng John Schmidt. Agenda. Who is Jeremy Siegel? Part 1: “The Growth Trap” Part 2: “Overvaluing the Very New” Part 3: “Sources of Shareholder Value” Part 4: “The Age Wave” Part 5: “Portfolio Strategies”
E N D
“The Future for Investors”by Jeremy Siegel Kevin Kranzler Lisa Lajeunesse Ray Ng John Schmidt
Agenda • Who is Jeremy Siegel? • Part 1: “The Growth Trap” • Part 2: “Overvaluing the Very New” • Part 3: “Sources of Shareholder Value” • Part 4: “The Age Wave” • Part 5: “Portfolio Strategies” • Overall Book Review
Jeremy Seigel, Ph.D. • Professor of Finance at the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania • Received many awards over his career • The Senior Investment Strategy Advisor of Wisdom Tree Investments Inc.
The Growth Trap • Everyone wants to ‘beat the market’ & invest in the next big thing. • However, as Siegel points out, pursuing returns through growth continually disappoints investors.
What actually happened? • IBM: $1000 initial investment became $961,000. • Standard Oil of NJ: $1000 initial investment became $1,260,000.
What matters! • Long-term returns on stock depends not on the actual growth of its earnings but on how those earnings compare to what investors expected!
Looking for the Corporate El Dorado • The Golden company that continually performs better than the markets • Siegel computed the P/E ratio for all 500 firms on the S&P and computed their prices
What Siegel Found… • High P/E stocks earn lower returns and low P/E stocks earn high returns, on average
Characteristics of Corp El Dorado's • Earnings expectations are only slightly above average, but actual earnings growth was considerably large • No P/E ratio was above 27 • All paid constant and rising dividends • Most have high quality brand name recognized products that are marketed worldwide • Consumer have trust in their product quality
Sector Growth • Investment strategies based on industry/sector are growing in popularity • Morgan Stanley & Goldman Sachs
Summary Do not be seduced by that hot new company or investors Overwhelming demand for stocks overvalues those stocks which lowers the return for investors
How To Spot a Bubble • 1.) Valuations are critical • 2.) Never Fall in Love with your Stock • 3.) Beware of Large, Little Known Companies • 4.) Avoid Triple Digit P/E Ratios • 5.) Never Sell Short in a Bubble
Response to Wall Street Journal Article “Good morning, Mr. Siegel. I hope you’re happy. You cost me $14,000.00 for no reason! What do you have against this mammoth company? Are you jealous because you didn’t get in on the run-up? Did you want to buy in cheaper? You have no business making decisions like this. After all, you’re still a child when it comes to Internet knowledge.
Response to Wall Street Journal Article “You’re a preschooler in diapers when it comes to recognizing opportunities. By the way, when was the last time you got laid? You’re a party pooper. Thanks a lot, jerk. I suggest you go to the streetadvisor.com to read about why you’re so wrong idiot. Do you even know how to get a Web site, you child?”
IPO Relative Returns Figure 6.2 Annualized Returns on Yearly IPO Portfolios Minus Returns on Small Stock Index, Returns Measured Through December 31, 2003
Creative Destruction • “Innovative entry by entrepreneurs is the force that sustains economic growth” - wikipedia.com • Investors in IPO’s are actually not making money (the ground floor) • If the new are not making money for investors then who is attaining profits? • Venture Capitalists • Investment Banks
Capital Pigs • Technology is a productivity creator, and a value destroyer • Profits reinvested into the company is money that is not paid out in dividends, destroying investor return • Fallacy of Composition
Success Amongst Failure • Wal-Mart’s Strategy for Success • Southwest Airlines low cost structure • Nucor Steel use of new technology
Winning Management • “consistency of the company, and our ability to project its philosophies throughout the whole organization, enabled by our lack of layers and bureaucracy” • The business structure should look to always minimize costs • Define the largest controllable cost and minimize it, this is a company’s competitive advantage
Summary • Never forget the fundamentals of investing • Watch out for bubbles • IPO’s are a bad investment for investors, • Individual company analysis is important; look for • Lower Capex Ratios • Low P/E ratios • Winning management
Correlation between Dividends and Returns • Higher dividend paying companies provide greater returns • Lower dividend paying companies provide less returns • Not just due to extra cash flow
Purpose of Dividends • Provides credibility • Indicates real earnings • Shows strength in time of economic downturn • Price drops and dividend yield goes up
Importance of Bear markets • One reason for the correlation (dividends/returns) • Reinvest (increased) dividends at lower price • Cushions portfolio in decline • Accelerates returns when price goes up
Phillip Morris Example • Cigarette company facing lawsuits and fierce competition • Share price fell but dividends rose • Reinvested dividends (’92-’03) increased shares by 100% • 7.15% annually – trailed market • Prices recovered and returns magnified
Measuring Earnings to Value a Company • Net Income – sanctioned by FASB/GAAP • Operating Income – reconciles one-time cost/revenues • More accurate - restructuring costs • Manager indiscretion - amortization
Red flags to watch out for • Option expenses • Do not legally have to be recorded as expenses • Not accurate portrayal in Income statement • Pension Plan Structure • Serious claim on future earning • High Accruals • Indicate low quality earnings
Summary • There is a positive correlation between dividends and returns • There are numerous ways to value a company
Problems • Lower productivity from decreased workforce • Increased demand from more retirees • Retirees sell their assets during retirement • Flood of financial assets on market • Drive prices of equities and bonds down • Securities’ value is determined by price buyer is willing to pay
More Problems • Retirement age is decreasing • People are living longer • Results in longer non-working time • Greater pension/planning needs • Fastest age bracket growth is age 100+
Possible Solutions • Reduce benefits of pension plans • Decrease the standard of living • Creates generational conflict • Increase Productivity • Offsets the population imbalance • Difficult to create/predict/depend on
Possible Solutions • Increase Immigration • Increase productivity • 400 million people will be required to offset the population wave
The Global Solution • Developing countries have opposite population wave than the Developed countries • India and China can support the western countries with goods and services/buy assets • Maintain the standard of living in developing countries
The Global Solution [3] • Enable aging nations to enjoy longer retirement • Communications revolution will aid in economic growth – free flow of information • Free trade will become increasingly important • Advance the globalization of the world’s economic system
Summary • Baby boomers retirement poise a difficult transition period for investors • Investors must seek a global solution
Global Market Trends • Growth Prospects in China & India • Growth Trap • Example: Brazil vs. China • Emerging Chinese Economy • Home Equity Bias • Correlation of US & World markets