170 likes | 307 Views
Extending the MDR for the Semantic Web - Enforcing the MDR for supporting ontology concept -. 6 December 2007 ISO/IEC SC 32/WG 2 Interim Meeting Seoul, Korea Dongwon Jeong ( djeong@kunsan.ac.kr ), Kunsan National University Doo-Kwon Baik ( baikdk@korea.ac.kr ), Korea University.
E N D
Extending the MDR for the Semantic Web- Enforcing the MDR for supporting ontology concept - 6 December 2007 ISO/IEC SC 32/WG 2 Interim Meeting Seoul, Korea Dongwon Jeong (djeong@kunsan.ac.kr), Kunsan National University Doo-Kwon Baik (baikdk@korea.ac.kr), Korea University
Motivation and Background MDR (ISO/IEC 11179) Environment Change (Semantic Web) An Extension of the MDR, which can support the Semantic Web Concept Next?
Motivation and Background (cont.) • Semantic Web (SW) and Ontology • Semantic Web • is recognized as a next generation Web (Intelligent Web) • To realize the Semantic Web, ontologies (Web Ontologies) should be built • Web Ontology • consists of classes, instances, properties • Class = Concept, Type • Instance = Individual, Object • Property = Relation, Role • Ref.: Lecture Notes: Ontology Languages for the Semantic Web, http://www.cs.man.ac.uk/~horrocks/Teaching/cs646/ • can be expressed as 3-tuple, <subject, predicate, object> • Triple set (Statement set)
Motivation and Background (cont.) • An Ontology Example • Ref.: RDF Primer W3C Recommendation 10 February 2004 nancy frank hasMother fred Staff frances rdfs:subClassOf rdfs:subClassOf Male Female rdfs:subClassOf rdfs:subClassOf spencer Person author cook author author eatCheese author moveCheese crisis Book
author Person Book Class Level Instance Level author cook crisis Motivation and Background (cont.) • The Ontology Example can be classified into two levels • Class level and Instance level nancy frank hasMother fred Staff frances rdfs:subClassOf rdfs:subClassOf Male Female rdfs:subClassOf rdfs:subClassOf spencer Person author cook author author eatCheese author moveCheese crisis Book
Motivation and Background (cont.) • MDR Standardization Status • ISO/IEC 11179 has been being extended for supporting the ontology concept • The extension is for support the ontology concept at the class level • No consideration at the instance level (WG2 Note: This is not true) • A Key Region of the Extension Part (ISO/IEC 11179 CD2, ED. 3) • Relations Region
Purpose • Main Goal of our Proposal • Enforcing the current MDR for the Semantic Web by managing data at the instance level as well as at the concept level • This Proposal is • to support an ontology registration at the instance level as well as at the concept level • to endow the MDR to more powerful reasoning ability • to make it suitable for the Semantic Web environment • to make it more practical
Progress Status • Discussion History of the Proposal • SC32 Study Periods Meeting, Clearwater, FL, February 2007 • SC32 Plenary and WG Meetings • Request for a study period on Extending the metadata Registry for the Semantic Web • Documents: SC32N1659, WG2N1043 • In this Meeting, SC32/WG2 Interim Meeting • More clear scope definition • More details of our proposal • Metamodels • Registration processes • Hope to get much more comments
Scope: Conceptual Model MDR (Metadata registry) 11179 Ed. 2 To support the ontology concept 11179 Part 3, Ed. 3 (Concepts + Properties) Proposal Semantic (Instance, Individual) Registry (Individuals + Properties) To support the ontology concept at the instance level register Ontology Registration Process For a standardized ontology registration
Scope: Key Issues • Metamodels for Data Management • The following data should be managed • Instances • Mapping information between Concepts and Instances • Relation information (properties) between instances • Assumption (?) • Concepts and relevant properties are managed by the current extension • Ontology Registration Processes • Main processes • Concept-to-Instance mapping process • Valid Instance-to-Instance property assignment process • User groups • Groups for submission, verification, administration, etc. • Roles of each group
author cook crisis Metamodels for Data Management • Data to be Managed (i.e., required metamodels) • Generating (Instantiating) Instances • Concept-to-Instance relations • Mapping information between Concepts and Instances, <Concept, Instance> Pairs • Concepts at the concept level (MDR); Instances at the instance level (Proposal) • Instance-to-Instance relations • Relation information (properties) between instances • Reuse properties at the concept level for instance-to-instance links author Person Book Concept Level Instance Level`
Metamodel for Data Management (cont.) • Metamodel for Management of Information : concept-to-individual relations, individuals, individual-to-individual relations Concept_Property Concept +link +end * 2..* +reused +abstraction 1 1 CP_IP_Link Concept_Instance_Link +CP_id[1..1]: Concept_Property +IP_id[1..1]: Instance_Property +concept_id[1..1]: Concept +Instance_id[1..n]: Instance +reuse +instantiation * * Instance_Property Instance • CP: Concept_Property • IP: Instance_Property +link +end * 2..*
Metamodel for Data Management (cont.) • Considering the Relations Region Link_End Relation_Role +link_end_role[1..1]:Relation_Role +link +end Relation Link Concept * 2..* +reused +abstraction 1 1 CP_IP_Link Concept_Instance_Link +CP_id[1..1]: Concept_Property +IP_id[1..1]: Instance_Property +concept_id[1..1]: Concept +Instance_id[1..n]: Instance +instantiation +reuse * * Instance_Property Instance +link +end * 2..*
Metamodel for Data Management (cont.) • Considering the Relations Region • Link_End and Instance_Link_End +link +end Relation Link Concept * 2..* Link_End Relation_Role +link_end_role[1..1]:Relation_Role +reused +abstraction 1 1 Necessary or Not CP_IP_Link Concept_Instance_Link +CP_id[1..1]: Concept_Property +IP_id[1..1]: Instance_Property +concept_id[1..1]: Concept +Instance_id[1..n]: Instance Instance_Link_End +link_end_role[1..1]:Relation_Role +instantiation +reuse * * Instance_Property Instance +link +end * 2..*
Ontology Registration Process repetition Statement Registration (Register a Statement, <Instance, Property, Instance>) Valid Property Assignment (Select Valid Properties for two Instances) Concept-to-Instance relations Instance to Concept Mapping (Map an Instance to a Concept) Concept-to-Instance relations Instance Generation (Instance Set) Instance list
Conclusion and Next Step • Summary of the Current Development Status • Defined a metamodel for the instance management • Defined the registration processes • Further Work for the Next Plenary Meeting • Definition of more metamodels • for support of multiple ontologies • for management of additional information, if needed • Definition of user groups and their roles • Providing various and concrete examples • Defining data models for practical use • RDB-based model and/or OODB-based model • might be provided as an appendix • And ......
Q/A Thank you! Dongwon Jeong (djeong@kunsan.ac.kr), Kunsan National University Doo-Kwon Baik (baikdk@korea.ac.kr), Korea University