180 likes | 198 Views
Study Period on the Integration of MDR/MFI. Scenario for the Integration of MDR&MFI. 2009.08 Ad-hoc Meeting, Wuhan H. Horiuchi. Balloting Comments(SC32N1857). Approval : 6 Approval W/ Comment: 1 (Canada) Abstain W/ Comment: 1 (Germany). The project was Approved.
E N D
Study Period on the Integration of MDR/MFI Scenario for the Integration of MDR&MFI 2009.08 Ad-hoc Meeting, Wuhan H. Horiuchi
Balloting Comments(SC32N1857) • Approval : 6 • Approval W/ Comment:1 (Canada) • Abstain W/ Comment:1 (Germany) The project was Approved
Current Status of SC32WG2 2010 1997 2000 2005 MFI 1,3, SC32 Formulated MFI 2,4 3-ed2 5 6 7 8 TR MDR 3-ed.3 MDR ed.2 1,2,3,4,5,6 MDR 1,2,3,4,5,6 20944
Trends on Information Technology ServiceOriented Information Productivity Model Oriented SOA Object Oriented Data Oriented BPR Process Oriented Office Automation SIS Web2.0 Business Computerization Internet + Web Tech. Initiation System Re-construction 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010
Market Requirements Discover & Casting Web Service Semantic Registry Sharing of knowledge Cross Domain Interoperation Metadata Registry ROR Sharing of Software Sharing of Data DD/DS Sharing of development Methodology
SSOA Requirements • Ontology Discovering • Cloud Discovery • ROR (Registry Service Integration Architecture) • On demand Selection of Cloud • Semantic Interoperation • Etc.
Expected Evolution of MDR & MFI (1) –Align the Two Families of Standards soThat Common Facilities Can Be Built Common Administration Information 11179 & 19763 “Common Facility” for both MDR & MFI Metadata Registration Model Registration ISO/IEC11179 Edition 3 ISO/IEC19763 ISO/IEC11179 Edition 2 MOF (ISO/IEC19502) ISO/IEC11179 Edition 1 MOF (OMG) Data Elements IRDS (ISO/IEC 10728) SC14
Expected Evolution in MFI MFI-XX: ROR MFI-6: Registration Proc MFI-XX: MM4 XXXX MFI-8: MM4Role & Goal MFI-7: MM4 Service Reg. MFI-5: MM4 Process Reg. MFI-4: MM for Model Mapping MFI-3: MM for Ontology Reg. MFI-2: Core Model MFI-1: Reference Model
Naming data element owner Identification & Classification Stewardship Registration Authority Overview of MDR Metamodel MDR Metamodel describe
Overview of MFI Metamodel Administerd Items of MDR MFI Metamodel describe Naming Models owner Identification & Classification Stewardship Registration Authority MFI Part 6 can align with MDR Part 6 and normatively reference the Relevant clauses of MDR Part 6
We should define INTEGRATION POLICY
Policy Jeju-1 • Align 11179 Part 6 (new edition) with 19763-6 (new standard). These are different standards, but should be aligned, not combined. • During development of the two standards, the editors should be careful to align the specifications of the two standards. • We should not combine 11179-6 and 19763-6 into a single standard. To be reconsidered (2009.08.22)
Also, to be defined CONSTRAINTS TO BE DEFINED
How to Proceed • Oxford Univ., London2 days (out of WG2 meeting) “Study period Meeting on Integration of MDR/MFI” • Email discussion • SC32WG2-interest (News) • SC32WG2-integration@metadata-standards.org • Technical Issues stocktaking (List of Issues); By 2009. 09.30 • Masao Okabe, Ray Gates, Kevin Keck • Baba, Frank, Horiuchi • Expected Deliverable : • Issues list • Strategy • Rationale • Proposal • Editors work together to align: Horiuchi
How to Promote? • What are sharable between 11179-3 & 19763? ( Identification, Naming, Administrative clauses) • Is it possible to define a new part as independent standard ? (When: the end of 11179-3 ed.3 ) New 11179-5+ • Align specifications between MDR & MFI for example, as we are trying to do with 11179-3 & 19763-3. keep consistency on the terminology & definitions • Actions to look for area between two standards where we need work on alignment. For example, as we are trying to do with 11179-6 & 19763-6. • 20943-6 (Procedure for the specification of Web ontology ) should cover both MDR-3 & MFI-3 • A new edition of 11179-5(Naming & Identification) should be possible after completing 11179-3 Ed3. • We should consider the possibility of aligning a new MDR-5 between MFI & MDR. • Registration Procedure(Part 6) of 11179 & 19763