1 / 12

Accessing the Foxtel/Telstra Network: an Open and Shut Case

Accessing the Foxtel/Telstra Network: an Open and Shut Case. Communications Research & Strategy Forum 2005, Sydney. Chronology (1): Pay Television Delivery. Chronology (2): Access-related Events. Chronology (3): Access-related Events.

kalyca
Download Presentation

Accessing the Foxtel/Telstra Network: an Open and Shut Case

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Accessing the Foxtel/Telstra Network: an Open and Shut Case Communications Research & Strategy Forum 2005, Sydney

  2. Chronology (1): Pay Television Delivery

  3. Chronology (2): Access-related Events

  4. Chronology (3): Access-related Events

  5. How did the Foxtel/Telstra pay tv network achieve closed access? • Unrestricted business entry • Telstra faced none of the restrictions then prevalent in the US and UK

  6. How did the Foxtel/Telstra pay tv network achieve closed access? • Unrestricted business entry • Minimal competitive threat • Telstra’s ‘telephony defence’ neutralised Optus network • Foxtel/Optus programming agreement neutralised Optus content • Only broadcasters sought pay tv access, not Telcos, and both defeated • No Telco or ISP ever sought cable modem access

  7. How did the Foxtel/Telstra pay tv network achieve closed access? • Unrestricted business entry • Minimal competitive threat • Delayed access • Insufficient analogue channel capacity • Persistent legal and regulatory delays whilst market position consolidated, competitors wasted away and analogue technology replaced by digital

  8. How did the Foxtel/Telstra pay tv network achieve closed access? • Unrestricted business entry • Minimal competitive threat • Delayed access • Dictated terms of access • Arbitration prolonged until ready for access undertakings • Analogue agreement useless • Digital agreement competitively neutered • ACCC worn down by labyrinthine process

  9. What political and legal opportunities were exploited? • Carrier Associates Direction (1995 - 1997) • Optus subterfuge in avoiding common carrier obligations • Government caught over a barrel by Optus threat not to invest in alternative telephony infrastructure • Digital technology would alleviate capacity constraint by around 1997 anyway?

  10. What political and legal opportunities were exploited? • Carrier Associates Direction (1995 - 1997) • Protected Contractual Right (1996/97 – 2001/2) • Telstra and Foxtel signed Broadband Cooperation Agreement July 1996; lobbied new Howard government for protection from third party access > TPA amendment • Applicable if a contract in force as at 13 September 1996 • All court cases based on PCR were defeated, but delay the prime goal

  11. What political and legal opportunities were exploited? • Carrier Associates Direction (1995 - 1997) • Protected Contractual Right (1996/97 – 2001/2) • Anticipatory Exemption (2002 – 2004?) • PC & government: reduced regulatory uncertainty would foster new telecommunications investment • Telecommunications Competition Bill: Access providers can seek exemption from standard access obligations even prior to investment being made > ACCC granted orders • Seven Network appealed to Competition Tribunal and set aside orders

  12. Conclusions • Cable television has been the most significant new wireline access network investment since the PSTN. • Governments have never really committed to third party access. • Regulatory process for access is now labyrinthine and wide open to gaming. • Fibre to the Home, the next (& last) wireline access network, is highly likely to remain closed to third party access > a monopolist’s dream!

More Related