1 / 14

Research performance management in a CRIS environment

Research performance management in a CRIS environment. Does research evaluation affect publishing activity ? Brian Kirkegaard Lunn ( bkl@aub.aau.dk ) & Poul M. Melchiorsen, Nils Thidemann, John Kruuse , Anne Lyhne Høj , Sabine Dreier, Maria A. Madsen, Anne Marya Jensen.

kamal
Download Presentation

Research performance management in a CRIS environment

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Research performance management in a CRIS environment Does research evaluationaffectpublishingactivity? Brian Kirkegaard Lunn (bkl@aub.aau.dk) & Poul M. Melchiorsen, Nils Thidemann, John Kruuse, Anne Lyhne Høj, Sabine Dreier, Maria A. Madsen, Anne Marya Jensen CRIS2012 Conference, Prague, June 2012

  2. Why relevant in the CRIS environment • The New Public Management wave • Demands for accountability • CRIS systems hold relevant data e.g., on researchers’ publishingactivity

  3. Agenda • Background and research agenda • How to measure the prestige of publications? • Does researchers publish in more prestigeous journals?

  4. Aalborg University is... • 14,000 students • 2,000 researchers • 800 administrative and technicalstaff • With 4 faculties • The Faculty of Humanities • The Faculty of Social Sciences • The Faculty of Engineering and Science • The Faculty of Medicine

  5. CRIS at Aalborg University

  6. Bibliometric Research Indicator • Builds on the so-called‘Norwegian Model’ • Peer-reviewedpublished research publications • 68 research groups with representatives from eachuniversity • Authority list of publicationchannels • Publicationchannels is grouped in twolevels (normal and prestigous) • Weightsbetweenpublications types • Fractionisedcountswhen more thanoneauthor • Collaboration outsideonesownuniversity is rewarded (+25 %) • Used for allocatingfunds to Danish universities

  7. Political motivations for the national RES Implementation of the Bibliometric Research Indicator is expected to encourage • …to increasescientificpublications • …behaviourthatcreatesincentives for publishing in the more prestigious journals • …

  8. Research agenda • The extent to which researchers at Aalborg Universitypublish in prestigious journals, and • How publishingactivitycorrelates with implementation of a national RES

  9. How to measure prestige • Internalyardstick • Using the BFI-model'sowncategorisation of prestigious journals (level 1 or level 2) • Externalyardsticks • Using international recognised measures of prestige • Web of Science – Journal Impact Factor (JIF) • Scopus – Source NormalisedImpact per Paper (SNIP)

  10. The Internalyardstick • Publishing activitymeasured by Cumulative Authority List for Journals (percentages). The shadedareas show percentages in relation to the Authority List of Journals, only

  11. Publications in WoS and Scopus • Master lists areapplied to avoidmeasuring the growth of the databases

  12. The prestige of WoS and Scopuspublications

  13. Conclusion and future work • Results do neither support nor contradictthatinplementation of the national RES affects researchers’ publishingactivity • This said … • A few researchers expressthat the Bibliometric Research Indicatoraffectstheirbehaviour – this is to beinvestigated in cooporation with a research team at AAU • Weneed to scrutinize data further, e.g., by looking at data at the level of faculties, departments, BFI research groups or document types

  14. Thankyou for your attention

More Related