230 likes | 539 Views
The 5Rs of Managerial Renewal. L.R. Jones Naval Postgraduate School Fred Thompson Willamette University. Management by New Names?. Restructuring Reengineering Reinvention Realignment Rethinking . 5Rs. Restructuring. Identify the organization’s core competencies.
E N D
The 5Rs of Managerial Renewal L.R. Jones Naval Postgraduate School Fred Thompson Willamette University
RestructuringReengineeringReinventionRealignmentRethinking 5Rs
Restructuring • Identify the organization’s core competencies. • Cut everything out of the organization that does not add value -- especially red tape, rules that inhibit performance. • Contract everything out of the organization that is not a core competency.
Tools: TQM, value-chain analysis, activity-based costing (ABC). • Chart the entire flow of activities needed to design, create, and deliver a service; • For each activity and step within the activity determine its associated cost and the cause of that cost, or cost driver; • Determine whether or not the step adds value for the customer and, if it is non-value adding, identify ways to eliminate it and its associated cost; • Determine the cycle time of each activity and calculate its cycle efficiency (value-added time/total time); and • Seek ways to improve cycle efficiency and reduce associated costs due to delays, excesses, and unevenness in activities.
SERVICE PERFORMANCE IN SUPPLY MANAGEMENT Service efforts Service Accomplishments EFFICIENCY = Inputs Required to Achieve Outputs EFFECTIVENESS = Customer Satisfaction
SERVICE PERFORMANCE IN SYSTEMS ACQUISITIONS (Information collected by Program, Center, phase, and/or acquisition category) Service Efforts Service Accomplishments EFFICIENCY = Procurement Dollars Managed per Dollar Spent, RDT&E Dollars Managed, Technical Order Dollars Managed, Sustainment Dollars Managed Per Dollar Spent EFFECTIVENESS = Satisfaction of MAJCOMs, SAF Acquisition Office, etc.
Reengineering: • Start over rather than trying to “fix” existing processes with “band aid” solutions. • Put the computer and other information technologies at the center of the operation. • Build from the ground up rather than from the top down. • Base organizational design on processes rather than functions and positions on the organizational chart. • Focus on improving service quality, reduced cycle time, and costs.
Tools: modern data bases, expert systems, and information technologies; teaming, benchmarking, cycle-time burdening.
Accounts Payable: U.S. Navy vs. Ford • Navy = twenty-six manual accounting transactions and nine reconciliations -- thirty-five steps in all. • Ford = 3 steps: order, receipt, and payment • Computerization could cut steps in the Navy’s accounts payable to fourteen • Navy fails to capture information once and at the source. Instead each step in the supply process -- requisition, receipt, certification of invoice, reconciliation, and revision -- is repeated on up the chain of command. • The people who produce information do not process it. Processing is handled by financial-management specialists • Navy does not build financial control into job designs. Commanders should be evaluated during peacetime in part on the basis of their success in managing costs.
Reinvention • Develop a planning process. • Establish a service/market strategy. • Move the organization toward new service delivery modes and markets.
Tools: strategic planning, market research, target costing, networks and alliances.
Realignment • Align the Organization’s Administrative and Responsibility Structures with its market and service delivery strategy. • Align the organization’s Control/Reward Structure with its administrative and responsibility structures • Align the organization’s Human Resource Management Practices its control/reward structure.
Realignment 2 • Successful organizations: Provide job security; Carefully recruit based upon the right attitudes, values, and cultural fit; Rely on self-managed multidisciplinary teams and decentralization of decision-making as basic principals of organizational practice; Pay high wages contingent upon performance; Provide extensive training; Share performance and financial information widely; Reduce status distinctions. • Put mission centers first control functions such as personnel or finance are not core missions; if they are not core missions, they should be treated as support centers.
Tools: High commitment HR practices, PBOs, multi-divisional structures, lean production, responsibility budgeting and accounting, transfer prices, high-powered incentives.
REALIGNED RESPONSIBILITY STRUCTURE FOR THE U.S. DOD $ Military Departments Supply trained and equipped military units to COMBAT COMMANDS Unified & Special Commands COMBAT COMMANDS Supply Budgetary Resources To MILITARY DEPARTMENTS
Rethinking • Speed up the observation, orientation, decide, act cycle -- both to improve performance and to learn faster. • Empower front line workers to evaluate service performance and provide feedback on service delivery and strategy. • Build a learning, adapting organization.
Tools: decentralization, flexible controls, working capital, quick and dirty analysis, learning models.