330 likes | 361 Views
The Value of Patient Education Kiosks. Jackie A. Smith, Ph.D. April 12, 2000. Introduction Use of Kiosks + and - Findings Kiosk in learning centers. Kiosk providers Format options Costs Research, evaluation Future directions . Presentation Topics. What is Kiosk? . Types.
E N D
The Value of Patient Education Kiosks Jackie A. Smith, Ph.D. April 12, 2000
Introduction Use of Kiosks + and - Findings Kiosk in learning centers Kiosk providers Format options Costs Research, evaluation Future directions Presentation Topics
Types • Advertise product • Dispense information • Exchange information
Design Factors • Services provided • Goals • Functional requirements • Filtering needed • Target population • Location • Monitoring
Issue The Web “A Competing Medium”
Issue Technology is changing.
Issue Leaders change
Kiosks in Health Care • Information • Interactive
Direction giving Discussion groups Decision making Referral tools Links to providers Profile the “at risk” Medical reminders Handouts Disease monitoring Self-care Uses
Interactive Programs • CD-based • Interactive videodisk • Shared-decision making • Health risk assessment • Simulations
Interactive Big databases Stores and organizes Fast retrieval Recent info. Patients in control Time efficient Increases satisfaction Increases compliance Better outcomes Advantages
Cognitive domain Expensive Complex Limited use for some patients Hardware failure Space Immovable Time required to teach staff Patients require help Maintenance Hard to evaluate Disadvantages
Findings Patients welcome computers across groups.
Findings Clinic 3
Findings Cost Savings
Review of Literature • Lewis (JAMIA, Jul/Aug 1999) • All computer-based approaches had positive impact.
Impacts • Knowledge • Clinical outcomes • Self-care • Skill development
Urine collection Sexual history Rheumatoid arthritis Asthma Diabetes Arthritis Medication recall Coronary artery disease Medication knowledge Hyperlipidemia Topics
Providers • HealthWise • Helios • X-Plain • HealthTouch • HealthVision
Evaluating Software • Validity • Value • Use
Format Networked or Stand-alone computer
Printing Location Simplicity Interface Internet failure Remote monitoring Visual consistency Measuring response Key board Other options Languages Other options ADA compliant Factors
Building a Kiosk • Hardware • Software • Components
Choice of application Quality of application Security Cost/benefit analysis Overall interface Screens Turnaround Accessibility Comfort Convenience Accessibility Output Standards Enabling evaluation Security Auditing Response Evaluating a System - Morris et. al.
Costs Shared -decision making programs License = $1,000/year Video system = $6,000 to $8,000/year
Costs HUD $16,000/unit
Costs If purchase 100 Kiosks, average monthly cost over 5 years is $250/month or $15,000 total.
Costs • Renting - 2x cost of purchase per month. • Value must be greater than $500/month to be cost effective.
Evaluating Use • Videotape • Verbal • Online feedback • Personal interviews • Focus groups • Automatic tracking • Manger feedback
Future Directions • Long-term outcomes • Interaction of culture, etc. • Age and learning styles • Knowledge acquisition • Retention • Cost-benefit analysis • Consequences of providing information • Customized information
Future Directions Information Appliances Questions?