310 likes | 577 Views
Cost Effective Pilot Plant Design and Construction. R P Palluzi ExxonMobil Research & Engineering Co CSR Research Support Services Clinton, NJ. Background. PPLE is ExxonMobil’s center of excellence for pilot plant and laboratory work Design Construction Operation Start-up
E N D
Cost Effective Pilot Plant Design and Construction R P Palluzi ExxonMobil Research & Engineering Co CSR Research Support Services Clinton, NJ
Background • PPLE is ExxonMobil’s center of excellence for pilot plant and laboratory work • Design • Construction • Operation • Start-up • Upgrades and modifications • Safety • Relocations • Consulting • Standards
Background (cont’d) • Provide services to ExxonMobil and its affiliates worldwide • From consulting to projects ($10,000-$65,000,000) • New construction, relocations, upgrades, safety reviews, start-ups, operation problems, etc. • Located in Clinton Township facility • 850,00 SF modern research facility • Relocated from older Linden facility in 1981 • Specialty shops, engineering facilities and support areas
Challenges • Increased global competition demands more cost effective and faster research effort • Costs and time to design, construct and start-up a pilot plant can be significant • Reduced resources available due to downsizing New approaches required
EMRE’s Response To These Challenges • Modular design and construction • PC/PLC based control systems • Pilot plant specific standards and designs • CAD/CAE • Improved S/H/E planning • Improved start-up planning and techniques
Modular Construction • Palletization of all new units • Allows efficient shop construction • Reduces relocation, modification and demolition costs (life cycle costs) • Specialized construction shop • 20+% savings over field construction • Improved safety • Improved construction quality • Standardized designs • Reduces design effort • Significant reduction in start-up effort (10+%)
Modular Construction (cont’d) • Standardized assemblies • Reduces construction time • Promotes savings through bulk procurement • Reduced troubleshooting time • Reduced risk of failure to perform • Experienced staff • Engineering, design and craft • Familiarity promotes efficiency • Allows delegation of many tasks to lower, less expensive resource
Modular Construction (cont’d) • Improved wiring techniques • Junction boxes on all pallets to allow relocation and facilitate troubleshooting • Multiconductor cable • Spare wiring as part of initial construction • Extensive use of lay in duct or cable tray to facilitate initial wiring and modifications • Improved utility piping • Prefabricated manifolds • Spare taps • Multi-tubing bundles where appropriate
Improved Control Systems • Computer control of all new units • Operational efficiencies far outweigh initial costs • Reduced operating personnel • Improved product quality (product and/or data) • Personal computers (PC) or programmable logic controller (PLC) based • Standalone systems increase reliability • Inexpensive to install, modify and expand • Final selection usually driven by size
Improved Control Systems (cont’d) • Cost effective integration/isolation of control and safety systems • Standard: PC for control, PLC for safety interlocks • Alternate: high-end PLC for control, low end PLC for interlocks • Ensures safest cost effective separation • No recorded failure in 20 years • Specialized programming • Promotes efficient operation • Minimizes operator attention to routine tasks • Promotes efficient data collection, reduction and analysis • Allows integration of other data or transmission of unit data
Improved Control Systems (cont’d) • Unattended operation incorporated into all units • 50+% decrease in operating staff since 1983 • Significantly improved product quality (70% in one case!) • Allows further staffing reductions at low cost later
Pilot Plant Specific Designs • Pilot plant specific standards speed design process • Reduces design effort • Encourages building block approach • Ensures tested, trouble-free installations • Reduces start-up time (50% since 1980) • Standardized assemblies speed design and construction • Decreases construction time (10% since 1980) • Reduced potential for error and rework
Pilot Plant Specific Designs (cont’d) • Assembly line construction of many common elements • Relief valve manifolds • Gas feed systems • Utility headers • Instrument cabinets • Pilot plant specific construction management • Reduces costs • Improves quality control through better focus
CAD/CAE • Heavy investment in automated design • State of the art CAD system decreases design time • Automated bill of materials • Standard drawing assemblies • Ability to cut and paste from thousands of other units • On-line estimating system • Improved accuracy with reduced effort • Better historical trending • Improved validation
CAD/CAE (cont’d) • Numerous on-line design programs • Many pilot plant specific • Decreases expensive engineering effort • Electronic transfer of information • Eliminates wasteful duplication of information • Ensures single source for all info reducing error
Improved S/H/E Planning • Conceptual safety reviews identify issues earlier • Allows time to effectively address from start of design • Improves evaluation of alternatives • Often results in process or program shifts to avoid costly or time-consuming issues • Pilot plant specific risk assessments • Improves realism • Eliminates inappropriate concerns • Reduces effort
Improved S/H/E Planning (cont’d) • Pilot plant specific standards • Reduces review effort • Ensures acceptable design • Reflects actual operating experience
Improved Start-Up Planning and Techniques • Start-up technical review conducted before finalizing design • Allows identification of potential problem areas early enough to allow resolution • Allows obvious problems to be corrected before construction • Captures 70% of the obvious problems • Utilizes experienced start-up team • Start-up planning initiated shortly after unit approval • Ensures start-up issues are addressed with adequate time for resolution
Improved Start-Up Planning and Techniques (cont’d) • Start-up sequence for all units • Sequential listing of all start-up tasks • Includes estimate of resources and effort • Allows realistic start-up estimate and schedule • Allows identification of resource, skill area and/or specific issues early enough to be worked • Specialized start-up equipment and facilities • Flushing carts • Leak testing equipment • Troubleshooting equipment • Calibration shop