1 / 24

Week 4

Week 4. Dr Supriya Akerkar. Building upon the last lecture. In the last lecture, we learnt how new self-consciousness: caste, ethnicity, tribal emerged as a result of the ‘invention of tradition’ in Zimbabwe/Africa/India/South Asia

keren
Download Presentation

Week 4

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Week 4 Dr SupriyaAkerkar

  2. Building upon the last lecture • In the last lecture, we learnt how new self-consciousness: caste, ethnicity, tribal emerged as a result of the ‘invention of tradition’ in Zimbabwe/Africa/India/South Asia • In this lecture we will understand how new self consciousness about ethnic identities got polarised, using the case of Rwanda and its implications

  3. Outline of the lecture • Understanding the Rwanda conflict • Historical antecedents • What happened in 1994? • Who is responsible? • Is there a way out?

  4. Rwanda Small country: 26,338 sq km Mountainous: above 1000 m High population density Groups: Tutsis, Hutus, Twa Economy: mainly agriculture

  5. The genocide of 1994 What happened?

  6. What happened? • http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/video/2008/dec/18/rwanda-genocide

  7. Why did it happen? • What were the reasons for the genocide?

  8. Understanding the history of differentiation of social groups in Rwanda • Hutus, Tutsis and Twa • Same language: Bantu • Lived side by side and intermarried • Displayed different physical features • Are these social groups or tribes? • Rwanda and colonial rule • German presence (1897-1916): indirect colonial rule • Belgian colonial rule was effected since 1916 through military conquest

  9. How was the difference marked in social terms?Source: Prunier, 1997 p. 6 Twa: “He is small, chunky, muscular and very hairy.... He is quite similar to the apes whom he chases in the forest” Hutus: “short, thick-set with a big head....like to laugh and lead a simple life” Tutsis: “ ... Is of good race has nothing of the negro, apart from his colour. He is usually tall... His features are very fine, a high brow, thin nose, and fine lips... He is a natural-born leader, capable of extreme self control and of calculated good will”

  10. Creating of New Myths • The superior Tutsis were invaders of the Hutu territory and have skillfully subjugated the ‘inferior’ Hutus. • “The Tutsis were meant to reign. Their fine presence is in itself enough to give them a great prestige vis a vis the inferior races which surround” • Belgian administrator in 1920s • Source: Prunier, p11

  11. Colonialism and changing political economy of Rwanda • Considered as ‘better’, ‘active and ‘intelligent’ the Belgian government consciously decided to work mainly with the Tutsis from 1916. • Existing Hutu chiefs were replaced by Tutsis making their dominance total. • By the end of 1959, 43 chiefs out of 45 chiefs were Tutsis and 549 sub-chiefs out of 559 were Tutsis.

  12. Colonialism and changing social-political economy in Rwanda during Belgian rule • Introduction of forced labour or corvee as individual obligation. • Tutsis used the social support of Belgian rule to gain traditional Hutu lands. • Grazing lands were privatized. • Transformation of Ubuhake contracts • Introduction of Christainity, a new moral order and creation of centralized, non-traditional, modern and brutal ‘Rwanda’.

  13. What are the end results of these changes? • Introduction of racial prejudice with Tutsis as superior race • Rwandan kingdom was centralised with Tutsi kingship although real power was with the Belgian administrators • Deprived of all political power, Hutus felt materially exploited by Tutsis and European colonizers. • Tutsis (including poor Tutsis) started to believe that they were a ‘superior’ race.

  14. Genocide and its antecedants • “It has a massive impact on the natives themselves. The result of this heavy bombardment with highly value-laden stereotypes for some sixty years ended by inflating the Tutsi cultural ego inordinately and crushing Hutu feelings until they coalesced into an aggressively resentful inferiority complex........ A dangerous social bomb was almost absent-mindedly manufactured......” (Prunier, p.9)

  15. Do you agree that the racialisation of the Rwandan society during the colonial rule led to the 1994 Genocide?? • Discuss

  16. Some facts about Rwanda • There was no history of violent ethnic violence between Hutus and Tutsis before the arrival of Europeans or in pre-colonial Rwanda. • Much of the wars were against rival kingdoms. Such war also acted as social coagulant where Tutsis, Hutu and Twa although unequal were first and foremost ‘Banyarwanda’ facing a common enemy. • These wars were never on the scale of 1994 genocide..

  17. A time line since 1959 • A violent ethnic conflict had started in 1959 after the end of the Belgian rule. • In 1959, the Tutsi king and several other Tutsis ran away to live in exile in Uganda. Later an Armed Rwandan Patriotic Front (RPF) of Tutsis was formed from Uganda. • Hutu political party comes to power with Hutu president in 1959. • In 1994, the plane of the Hutu president, Habyarimana who had signed a peace agreement with the Tutsis was brought down killing him and the Burundi president. A massacre followed, led by the Hutu militia group ‘Interahamwe’ of the Tutsi residents in Rwanda.

  18. videoRwanda: The Human Brutality, part 1 • http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sks8UYcYw2I&feature=related

  19. videoRwanda, the human brutality, part II • http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IgWOOwQNGtU&feature=related

  20. Discussion Question: Who was responsible for the Genocide? • The unwillingness of the international community to intervene? • Racialised ideology amongst Rwandans? • Burden of history?

  21. Making a difference • http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q2WFMtJUVz0 • http://www.unmultimedia.org/tv/21stcentury/2008/07/rwanda-lessons-from-a-hero.html

  22. Discussion question • Is there a way out of the felt ethnic polarities? • What can we learn from the acts of those who resisted the ideology of genocide?

  23. Next lecture • The next lecture will focus on The Idea of Human Rights: Exclusivity and Universalism

  24. Thank You

More Related