50 likes | 178 Views
Reminder on Technical Motivations, Objectives and Plans E.Carlier , B. Goddard, V. Mertens Technical Review on UPS power distribution of the LHC beam dumping system (LBDS) 20 June 2012 Outline: Technical motivation LBDS reliability requirements 2012 incidents Plans
E N D
Reminder on Technical Motivations,Objectives and Plans • E.Carlier, B. Goddard, V. Mertens • Technical Review on UPS power distribution • of the LHC beam dumping system (LBDS) • 20 June 2012 • Outline: • Technical motivation • LBDS reliability requirements • 2012 incidents • Plans • System modifications • Testing, analysis, reviews • Review objectives
LBDS reliability requirements Energy in ‘ultimate’ 7 TeV LHC beam is > 500 MJ Already running with above 100 MJ Massive damage potential if uncontrolled beam loss LBDS MUST work if beam permit loop opens Reliability requirement for the whole machine protection systems (including LBDS, BIS, QPS, BLM, PIC, …) is SIL3. Reliability calculation (2006) “unsafety/year” (LBDS alone) of 2.4×10-7 (x 2 for 2 beams), largely SIL 4 (if post-dump checks to rec. “as good as new” state). Severe damage to SPS TT40 magnet vacuum chamber following uncontrolled loss of 2 MJ 450 GeV p+ beam. V.Mertens / LBDS UPS power distribution review, introduction / 20.6.2012
2012 incidents • Powering failures/weaknesses observed in 2012 which were not expected from previous analyses: • Type 1: Faults of crate power supplies, propagating through the electrical distribution and switching off groups of subsystems (consequence in case of beam would be asynchronous dump). • Type 2: Finding (on test bed) that stable short circuit of +12 V triggering and synchronisation crate would prevent ANY trigger from propagating to the dump kickers (= NO dump, consequence in case of beam almost certainly severe machine damage). V.Mertens / LBDS UPS power distribution review, introduction / 20.6.2012
Plans for system modifications Plans for further testing, analyses, reviews • Powering system modifications, against type 1 issues: • Short term: fixes already in place (described later) • LS1: all crates connected to completely indep. electrical feed for full redundancy • All WIENER crates to be replaced by crates with internal protection (BE-CO) • TSDS powering modifications, against type 2 issues: • Short term: surveillance of 12 V + connection to retriggering system (consol. in TS2) • LS1: separation of the two TSU into independent VME crates • No major system changes (in powering and triggering) foreseen beyond LS1 • Testing: • Powering failure mode scenarios (UPS & mains) to be fully tested at the end of LS1 (has not been possible in 2006). • Analyses: • Impact of powering failures to be reevaluated within reliability analysis of the LBDS. • Reviews: • UPS powering: today • Overall LBDS system: end 2012 • Triggering and BIS link (date ?) • Overall LHC MP, requested by LMC (date ?) V.Mertens / LBDS UPS power distribution review, introduction / 20.6.2012
Review objectives • Provide focus for LBDS team to investigate powering aspects of system • Get input from other system experts, who will have different experience and viewpoints • Foster cross-system technical knowledge sharing • Validate proposed LS1 technical changes • Answer specific questions: • Is the system analysis sufficient ? • Are the HW testing and validation sufficient ? • Is the present system design (with modifications) solid ? • Are there still any potential issues or risk items ? • Are the underlying assumptions well-founded ? • Are the documentation and change procedures adequate ? V.Mertens / LBDS UPS power distribution review, introduction / 20.6.2012