170 likes | 264 Views
Retail Chains – Abuse of Buyer Power The Irish Experience. William Prasifka Chairperson, The Competition Authority 11 November 2009. Grocery Reports. The Grocery Monitor Project Report 1: The Structure and Operation of Grocery Retailing Report 2: Price Trends
E N D
Retail Chains – Abuse of Buyer PowerThe Irish Experience William Prasifka Chairperson, The Competition Authority 11 November 2009
Grocery Reports The Grocery Monitor Project • Report 1: The Structure and Operation of Grocery Retailing • Report 2: Price Trends • Report 3: Retail Planning System Retail-related Import and Distribution Study
The Problem • Buyer Power • Retailers are moving supply to the UK • Unfair demands are squeezing suppliers • Allegations of millions in hello money & slotting allowances • Fear of consequences • Delisting • Job Losses “The forced payment of up to €160m in ‘Hello Money’ to large supermarket chains by Irish suppliers is jeopardising thousands of Irish agri-business jobs” Member, Irish Parliament
The Solution Proposal to introduce: • Code of Practice in Ireland • Grocery Ombudsman • Based on the UK Model Key Objective : Protect Suppliers from • Unfair Practices • Hello Money & Slotting Allowances
Current Legislation The Competition (Amendment) Act 2006 prohibits • Imposing resale price maintenance • Apply dissimilar conditions to equivalent transactions • Slotting allowances • Hello Money These prohibitions are subject to a competition test
Our Experience Competition (Amendment) Act 2006 never been used • Few complaints • Anecdotal fear of coming forward • No private actions Will an Ombudsman change this?
UK Experience Different competitive dynamics • EDLP v’s High/Low pricing • Shoppers travelling to Northern Ireland – not vice versa Has the UK Supermarket Code been effective? • Fear among suppliers • Failure to use the code to resolve disputes • Few cases mediated
Ombudsman v’s Act • No Competition Test • No new incentive to come forward • Costly • Has little power The Code will “do a lot of harm by trying to do a little good” ESRI
Buyer Power If this is the problem, what is the solution? Changing the rules - Regulation? Ombudsman? Will Result in: Those with buyer power changing behaviour • Find alternative methods of “squeezing” • Encourage trading with non-Irish suppliers
Buyer Power Only effective remedy is new entry But… Irish planning laws restrict entry • Maximum retail floorspace caps • Grocery Store: 3,000/3,500 m2 • Discounters (ALDI/Lidl): 1,000/1,500 m2 • Trade Diversion Test • Process used strategically to frustrate competition
The IKEA Effect Attempts to enter Irish market • Planning issues - Restricted due to floorspace caps • 2005 Caps lifted for non-food stores in certain areas • 2006 IKEA Planning application • 2007 Planning permission granted Finally opened 27 July 2009 And Then What Happened ?????????