1 / 18

Landis Run Intermediate School Lancaster, PA

Landis Run Intermediate School Lancaster, PA. Matt Stevenson Adviser: Robert Leicht Construction Management. Presentation Overview. Matt Stevenson|Construction Management. Landis Run Intermediate Lancaster , PA. Breadth Topics:

kopec
Download Presentation

Landis Run Intermediate School Lancaster, PA

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Landis Run Intermediate School Lancaster, PA Matt Stevenson Adviser: Robert Leicht Construction Management

  2. Presentation Overview Matt Stevenson|Construction Management Landis Run Intermediate Lancaster, PA Breadth Topics: Breadth Topic #1: Mechanical System Reduction (Tied into Analysis #1) Breadth Topic #2: Acoustical Study of Modular Wall (Tied to Analysis #2) • Presentation Overview • Project Background • Analysis #1: Geothermal Heat Pumps • Analysis #2: Modular Classroom Wings • Breadth #1: Noise Reduction of Modular Walls • Analysis #3: Electrical Rough-In Method • Analysis #4: Project Delivery Method • Summary and Conclusion • Acknowledgements Depth Topics: Analysis #1: Feasibility and Impact of Geothermal Heat Pumps Analysis #2: Feasibility and Impact of Modular Classrooms Analysis #3: Analysis of Electrical Underground Rough-In Method Analysis #4: Project Delivery Method Analysis

  3. Project Background Matt Stevenson|Construction Management Landis Run Intermediate Lancaster, PA Building Systems: Facade • Brick and Decorative CMU Veneer • Glazing Structural System • Load Bearing Masonry • Open Web K Joists • CIP Concrete on Composite Deck Mechanical System • VAV System w/ Nine AHUs • Presentation Overview • Project Background • Analysis #1: Geothermal Heat Pumps • Analysis #2: Modular Classroom Wings • Breadth #1: Noise Reduction of Modular Walls • Analysis #3: Electrical Rough-In Method • Analysis #4: Project Delivery Method • Summary and Conclusion • Acknowledgements General Project Information: • 210, 000 SF Middle School (5th & 6th Grades) • Total Building Cost $26.4 Million • One Story in Areas A & B • Three Stories in Areas C & D • Striving for LEED Silver • Building Layout: • Area A: Administrative Suite, Gymnasium, Cafeteria • Area B: Mechanical Room, Music Classrooms • Area C: Classrooms • Area D: Classrooms and Library

  4. Geothermal Heat Pumps Matt Stevenson|Construction Management Landis Run Intermediate Lancaster, PA • Presentation Overview • Project Background • Analysis #1: Geothermal Heat Pumps • Background Information • Feasibility and Construction Impact • Cost Impact • LEED Impact • Analysis #2: Modular Classroom Wings • Breadth #1: Noise Reduction of Modular Walls • Analysis #3: Electrical Rough-In Method • Analysis #4: Project Delivery Method • Summary and Conclusion • Acknowledgements Potential Problem/Opportunity • LEED Silver Commendable • Possibility of Achieving Higher • Great Deal of Space on Site • Long Life Span Can Sustain Longer Payback Periods for Renewable Energy Goal Is To Determine: • Cost Impacts • Construction Impact • LEED Impact

  5. Geothermal Heat Pumps Matt Stevenson|Construction Management Landis Run Intermediate Lancaster, PA • Presentation Overview • Project Background • Analysis #1: Geothermal Heat Pumps • Background Information • Feasibility and Construction Impact • Cost Impact • LEED Impact • Analysis #2: Modular Classroom Wings • Breadth #1: Noise Reduction of Modular Walls • Analysis #3: Electrical Rough-In Method • Analysis #4: Project Delivery Method • Summary and Conclusion • Acknowledgements • Quantity & Placement • GLD Software:150 Wells at 343’ • Two Well Fields to East of Building • Minor Construction Traffic Interrupted • Schedule • Assuming 2 Wells Per Day • Drilling Would Start 5/25/11 • Drilling Would End 9/7/11 • Earliest AHU Tie-In 10/7/11

  6. Geothermal Heat Pumps Matt Stevenson|ConstructionManagement Landis Run Intermediate Lancaster, PA • Initial Cost • Deduct $104,438 • Add$1,008,000 For Wells • Mechanical Contract Will • Increase By 18.4% to $5,803,562 • Presentation Overview • Project Background • Analysis #1: Geothermal Heat Pumps • Background Information • Feasibility and Construction Impact • Cost Impact • LEED Impact • Analysis #2: Modular Classroom Wings • Breadth #1: Noise Reduction of Modular Walls • Analysis #3: Electrical Rough-In Method • Analysis #4: Project Delivery Method • Summary and Conclusion • Acknowledgements • Long Term Cost • Requires System Design, Building Loads, etc. • Less Maintenance Required • Longer Life Expectancy • Efficiency Typically In the 300-450% As Compared With 80-90% of Typical Boilers

  7. Geothermal Heat Pumps Matt Stevenson|Construction Management Landis Run Intermediate Lancaster, PA • Existing LEED Rating • 44 Credits For 52 Points • 2 Regional Priority Credits Missing For 2 Points • Public Transportation Access • Storm Water Design – Quality Control • Presentation Overview • Project Background • Analysis #1: Geothermal Heat Pumps • Background Information • Feasibility and Construction Impact • Cost Impact • LEED Impact • Analysis #2: Modular Classroom Wings • Breadth #1: Noise Reduction of Modular Walls • Analysis #3: Electrical Rough-In Method • Analysis #4: Project Delivery Method • Summary and Conclusion • Acknowledgements • Probable Additional Credits • Optimize Energy Performance • Unknown Possible Point Value • On-Site Renewable Energy • Probable 7 Points • Revised LEED Rating • Obtain LEED Gold with 61 Points

  8. Modular Classrooms Matt Stevenson|ConstructionManagement Landis Run Intermediate Lancaster, PA • Presentation Overview • Project Background • Analysis #1: Geothermal Heat Pumps • Analysis #2: Modular Classroom Wings • Background and Benefits • Module Assumptions • Cost and Schedule Impact • Breadth #1: Noise Reduction of Modular Walls • Analysis #3: Electrical Rough-In Method • Analysis #4: Project Delivery Method • Summary and Conclusion • Acknowledgements Potential Opportunity • C & D Are Repetitive Both Horizontally & Vertically • 70% of Building Square Footage • Could Dramatically Impact Project Efficiency Goal Is To Determine • Cost Impact • Schedule Impact

  9. Modular Classrooms Matt Stevenson|ConstructionManagement Landis Run Intermediate Lancaster, PA Module Assumptions • All Systems (MEP),Finishes, & Casework Preinstalled • Each Classroom Comprised of Two Modules • Interior Module Layout Two • Cost Savings of 20% • Four Modules Can Be Set per Day • Presentation Overview • Project Background • Analysis #1: Geothermal Heat Pumps • Analysis #2: Modular Classroom Wings • Background and Benefits • Module Assumptions • Cost and Schedule Impact • Breadth #1: Noise Reduction of Modular Walls • Analysis #3: Electrical Rough-In Method • Analysis #4: Project Delivery Method • Summary and Conclusion • Acknowledgements

  10. Modular Classrooms Matt Stevenson|ConstructionManagement Landis Run Intermediate Lancaster, PA Schedule Impact • 186 Modules / 4 (mod/day) = 46.5 Working Days • Area C Accelerated 347 • Area D Accelerated 363 Days • Presentation Overview • Project Background • Analysis #1: Geothermal Heat Pumps • Analysis #2: Modular Classroom Wings • Background and Benefits • Module Assumptions • Cost and Schedule Impact • Breadth #1: Noise Reduction of Modular Walls • Analysis #3: Electrical Rough-In Method • Analysis #4: Project Delivery Method • Summary and Conclusion • Acknowledgements Cost Impact • Overall Project Savings of $3.72 Million • Results in Cost Savings of 14.1%

  11. Noise Reduction of Modular Wall Matt Stevenson|ConstructionManagement Landis Run Intermediate Lancaster, PA • Presentation Overview • Project Background • Analysis #1: Geothermal Heat Pumps • Analysis #2: Modular Classroom Wings • Breadth #1: Noise Reduction of Modular Walls • Analysis #3: Electrical Rough-In Method • Analysis #4: Project Delivery Method • Summary and Conclusion • Acknowledgements Goal • Determine Difference in Noise Reduction of Existing & Modular Wall • Ensure Modules Still Meet Acoustical Prerequisite Results • Significantly Differ At 2k and 4k • Modular Wall Still Performs Adequately • Prerequisite Only Based on Area and NR Rating of Ceiling Materials • Classrooms Still Meet Acoustical Prerequisite

  12. Electrical Rough-In Method Matt Stevenson|ConstructionManagement Landis Run Intermediate Lancaster, PA • Presentation Overview • Project Background • Analysis #1: Geothermal Heat Pumps • Analysis #2: Modular Classroom Wings • Breadth #1: Noise Reduction of Modular Walls • Analysis #3: Electrical Rough-In Method • Background • Schedule & Cost Impact • Analysis #4: Project Delivery Method • Summary and Conclusion • Acknowledgements Potential Problem • Underground Rough-In Used for All Ground Floors • Activity Part of Critical Path, & Delays Dry-In • Possibly More Expensive, Longer Goal Is To Determine • Cost Impact • Schedule Impact

  13. Electrical Rough-In Method Matt Stevenson|ConstructionManagement Landis Run Intermediate Lancaster, PA • Presentation Overview • Project Background • Analysis #1: Geothermal Heat Pumps • Analysis #2: Modular Classroom Wings • Breadth #1: Noise Reduction of Modular Walls • Analysis #3: Electrical Rough-In Method • Background • Schedule & Cost Impact • Analysis #4: Project Delivery Method • Summary and Conclusion • Acknowledgements Schedule Impact • Overhead Performed After Dry-In • Underground Performed Prior To Slab Pouring • OH Finishes on Average 23 Days Sooner Duration Impact • Electricians: 2.6 Hours Less per Classroom with OH • Equals Saving 34.5 Working Days By Using Overhead RI

  14. Electrical Rough-In Method Matt Stevenson|ConstructionManagement Landis Run Intermediate Lancaster, PA Cost Impact • Estimate Yields OH is $.49 Cheaper • Differing Items Include Conduit, Wire, Hangers, & Trench Digging • Results In A Savings of $50,086.71 • 1.7% of Electrical Contract • 0.18% of Overall Building Cost • Presentation Overview • Project Background • Analysis #1: Geothermal Heat Pumps • Analysis #2: Modular Classroom Wings • Breadth #1: Noise Reduction of Modular Walls • Analysis #3: Electrical Rough-In Method • Background • Schedule & Cost Impact • Analysis #4: Project Delivery Method • Summary and Conclusion • Acknowledgements

  15. Project Delivery Method Matt Stevenson|ConstructionManagement Landis Run Intermediate Lancaster, PA The Pennsylvania Separations Act of 1913 • Requires Government Entities To Seek & Hold Separate Contracts For Electrical, Heating, Ventilation, and Plumbing In Excess of $4,000 • Only Three Other States Have Similar Laws (ND, IL, NY) • Present In Both State Law & School Code • Presentation Overview • Project Background • Analysis #1: Geothermal Heat Pumps • Analysis #2: Modular Classroom Wings • Breadth #1: Noise Reduction of Modular Walls • Analysis #3: Electrical Rough-In Method • Analysis #4: Project Delivery Method • Background and Separations Act of 1913 • Results For Variety of Government Owners • Summary and Conclusion • Acknowledgements Potential Problem • Using Multiple Prime; • Increases Coordination & Communication • Increases Owner Paperwork & Organization Load • Multiples Costs • Increases the Litigation Potential Against Owner • Increases Chances of Miscommunication & Mistakes Goal • Determine How Government Projects Can Gain Exemption To The Pennsylvania Separations Act of 1913

  16. Project Delivery Method Matt Stevenson|ConstructionManagement Landis Run Intermediate Lancaster, PA Exemptions • The Act Has Long Since Been Repealed For: • Boroughs • Townships • Second-Class Townships • Third Class Cities • Counties • Presentation Overview • Project Background • Analysis #1: Geothermal Heat Pumps • Analysis #2: Modular Classroom Wings • Breadth #1: Noise Reduction of Modular Walls • Analysis #3: Electrical Rough-In Method • Analysis #4: Project Delivery Method • Background and Separations Act of 1913 • Results For Variety of Government Owners • Summary and Conclusion • Acknowledgements Department of General Services • Places Requirements on DB Contractor • Contractor Must Identify Major Subs Before Hand • At Discretion of DGS Department of Education • Waiver Program As Part of EEA • Could Apply To Be Waived From Separations Act • Challenged In Court But Ultimately Upheld • Expired in 2010, No Similar Programs or Plans To Renew

  17. Summary & Conclusion Matt Stevenson|ConstructionManagement Landis Run Intermediate Lancaster, PA Electrical Rough-In Method - Implement • OH RI Saves $50,000 • Dry-In Dates Accelerated 23 Days on Average • Activity Duration Reduced By 35 Working Days Geothermal Heat Pumps - Implement • Initial Cost Increased By 18.4% • Lower Utility & Maintenance Cost • Reduces Emissions • No Significant Construction Impact • Pushes Project To LEED Gold • Presentation Overview • Project Background • Analysis #1: Geothermal Heat Pumps • Analysis #2: Modular Classroom Wings • Breadth #1: Noise Reduction of Modular Walls • Analysis #3: Electrical Rough-In Method • Analysis #4: Project Delivery Method • Summary and Conclusion • Acknowledgements Modular Classrooms - Implement • Substantial Completion Date of Areas C & D Accelerated • Savings of $3.72 Million or 14.1% of Project Cost Alternative Project Delivery Method – Not Possible • Design Build May Be Used For DGS Projects At Their Discretion • Previously Used To Be Able To Use Single Prime For DOE But No Longer Can • Multiple Prime Not Required For Boroughs, Townships, Second-Class Townships, Third-Class Cities, and Counties

  18. Acknowledgements Matt Stevenson|ConstructionManagement Landis Run Intermediate Lancaster, PA Academic Acknowledgements Dr. Robert Leicht Dr. Moses Ling Dr. Linda Hanagan All Penn State AE Faculty Industry Acknowledgements Warfel Construction Crabtree, Rohrbaugh & Associates MBR Construction Services Special Thanks To: Brett Calabretta Kyle Goodyear John Hess Jim Spence Joshua bower Manheim Township School District Family & Friends Questions/Comments?

More Related