1 / 13

Selection Procedure for TGai Authors

This presentation discusses the selection procedures for TGn, TGr, TGac, TGad, and TGah as references for TGai. It covers the defined documents, procedure/evaluation methodology, and necessary and sufficient conditions for documents.

kquinones
Download Presentation

Selection Procedure for TGai Authors

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Selection Procedure for TGai Authors: Date: 2011-03-15 Yukimasa Nagai, Mitsubishi Electric

  2. Abstract This presentation shows selection procedures of TGn, TGr, TGac TGad andTGah as references for TGai selection procedure Yukimasa Nagai, Mitsubishi Electric

  3. Selection procedure discussed in TGai • Defined documents for TGai in January meeting. • We’ve not defined • Procedure / evaluation methodology for CFP, down selection, etc • Necessary and sufficient condition for documents (11-11/0201r00) Yukimasa Nagai, Mitsubishi Electric

  4. Selection Procedures Documents in others • PHY/MAC: TGn, TGac, TGad • MAC Only: TGr, etc • PHY Only(?): TGah, etc Yukimasa Nagai, Mitsubishi Electric

  5. e.g. TGn Selection Procedure Flow Chart Yukimasa Nagai, Mitsubishi Electric

  6. e.g. TGac Selection Procedure Flow Chart Yukimasa Nagai, Mitsubishi Electric

  7. e.g. TGah Selection Procedure Flow Chart March 2011 Slide 7 Yukimasa Nagai, Mitsubishi Electric

  8. e.g. TGad Selection Procedure Flow Chart Yukimasa Nagai, Mitsubishi Electric

  9. e.g. TGr Selection Procedure Document • Definitions for documents • Functional Requirements– A list of mandatory features, performances and behaviors of the amendment. These requirements shall be consistent with the PAR, the 5 Criteria and the Usage Models. The Functional Requirements document shall contain a template that defines the format that presenters shall use to declare compliance with the requirements. • Comparison Criteria – A list of metrics and their definitions by which proposals shall be compared. The Comparison Criteria document shall contain a template that defines the format that presenters shall use to state their responses. • Other definitions in TGr: Complete Proposal, Partial Proposal. • Steps of the Procedure • TGr shall adopt Usage Models for the IEEE 802.11r amendment. • Deleted • TGr shall adopt Functional Requirements that must be met by all complete proposals. (ToDo: necessary?) • TGr shall adopt Comparison Criteria that must be addressed by all proposals. (ToDo: delete?) • TGr shall issue a call for proposals. • Prior to the first vote, the presenters shall classify their proposals as partial or complete. (continued Step 21) Yukimasa Nagai, Mitsubishi Electric

  10. e.g. Proposed TGai Selection Procedure Need to Update Yukimasa Nagai, Mitsubishi Electric

  11. Suggestions • Define following unclear subjects before CFP ! • Procedure / evaluation methodology for CFP, down selection, etc • Necessary and sufficient condition for documents • Use Case • Functional Requirement • Evaluation Criteria • accept partial proposals or not • etc Yukimasa Nagai, Mitsubishi Electric

  12. Straw poll • Should we need further discussion on this topic in TGai? • Yes28 • No 0 • Don’t care 1 Yukimasa Nagai, Mitsubishi Electric

  13. References • 11-03-0665-09-0000-tgn-selection-procedure.doc • 11-09-0059-06-00ac-802-11ac-proposed-selection-procedure.doc • 11-09-0935-05-00ad-selection-procedure.doc • 11-11-0239-02-00ah-proposed-selection procedure.docx • 11-04-0782-00-000r-tgr-selection-procedure.doc • 11-11-0201-00-00ai-tgai-closing-report-losangels-january-2011-ppt.ppt Yukimasa Nagai, Mitsubishi Electric

More Related