240 likes | 373 Views
Con. Lifestyle Interventions are Effective Treatments of Hypertensive Patients. Thomas Pickering MD, DPhil Behavioral Cardiovascular Health and Hypertension Program Columbia Presbyterian Medical Center New York. JNC 7: Treatment Overview. Goals of therapy Lifestyle modification
E N D
Con Lifestyle Interventions are Effective Treatments of Hypertensive Patients Thomas Pickering MD, DPhil Behavioral Cardiovascular Health and Hypertension Program Columbia Presbyterian Medical Center New York
JNC 7: Treatment Overview • Goals of therapy • Lifestyle modification • Pharmacologic treatment • Algorithm for treatment of hypertension • Classification and management of BP for adults • Followup and monitoring
Effects of DASH diet on BP Study Group BP change Administered DASH HT 11.4/5.5 Provided BHT 5.5/3.0 Provided DASH/Na BHT 8.9/4.5 Provided DEW-IT HT 7.4/5.7 Provided PREMIER HT 1.7/1.6Patient ALLHAT Diuretic 12.3/8.1
Effects of DASH diet on BP Study Group BP change Administered DASH HT 11.4/5.5 Provided BHT 5.5/3.0 Provided DASH/Na BHT 8.9/4.5 Provided DEW-IT HT 7.4/5.7 Provided PREMIER HT 1.7/1.6 Patient ALLHAT Diuretic 12.3/8.1
Lifestyle Modification: PREMIER(JAMA 2003: 289; 2083) Baseline 3 mo 6 mo
Issues in the Treatment of Hypertension Drugs DASH If I do it, will it work? Yes Yes Will I do it? Maybe No Will I continue to do it? Maybe No Will it lower risk ? Yes ?Yes Is it cost-effective? Very No
Issues in the Treatment of Hypertension DrugsDASH If I do it, will it work? YesYes Will I do it? MaybeNo Will I continue to do it? MaybeNo Will it lower risk ? Yes ?Yes Is it cost-effective? Very No
Issues in the Treatment of Hypertension DrugsDASH If I do it, will it work? YesYes Will I do it? MaybeNo Will I continue to do it? MaybeNo Will it lower risk ? Yes ?Yes Is it cost-effective? Very No
Issues in the Treatment of Hypertension DrugsDASH If I do it, will it work? YesYes Will I do it? MaybeNo Will I continue to do it? MaybeNo Will it lower risk ? Yes ?Yes Is it cost-effective? Very No
Failure to Maintain Behavioral Changes over the Long Term (data of TOHP II) Months 0 -10 -20 Weight -30 Na intake -40 -50 -60 Weight (Kg) Na intake (mmol/d)
Issues in the Treatment of Hypertension DrugsDASH If I do it, will it work? YesYes Will I do it? MaybeNo Will I continue to do it? MaybeNo Will it lower risk ? Yes ?Yes Is it cost-effective? Very No
Issues in the Treatment of Hypertension DrugsDASH If I do it, will it work? YesYes Will I do it? MaybeNo Will I continue to do it? MaybeNo Will it lower risk ? Yes ?Yes Is it cost-effective? Very No
DASH - How was it done? “Each weekday, subjects ate lunch or dinner on site. After the on-site meal, the subjects received coolers containing the food to be consumed off –site. On Fridays, they also received weekend meals, all consumed off-site.”
PREMIER- How was it done? Advice only- a single 30 minute session
PREMIER- How was it done? Advice only- a single 30 minute session SBP Change -7.8 mmHg
PREMIER- How was it done? Established - Goals: Weight loss of 15 lbs Exercise 3 hours/week Restrict Na intake to 100mEq Restrict alcohol to<2 drinks/day Procedure: Over 6 months of study 14 group training sessions 4 individual training sessions Recorded food and exercise diaries
PREMIER- How was it done? SBP Change -12.5 mmHg Incremental change - 4.7 mmHg Established - Goals: Weight loss of 15 lbs Exercise 3 hours/week Restrict Na intake to 100mEq Restrict alcohol to<2 drinks/day Procedure: Over 6 months of study 14 group training sessions 4 individual training sessions Recorded food and exercise diaries
PREMIER- How was it done? Established + DASH- Goals: As for Established PLUS Increased fruit & veg intake Decrease total & saturated fat Increase low-fat dairy Procedure: Over 6 months of study 14 group training sessions 4 individual training sessions Recorded food and exercise diaries
PREMIER- How was it done? SBP Change -14.2 mmHg Incremental change - 1.7mmHg Established + DASH- Goals: As for Established PLUS Increased fruit & veg intake Decrease total & saturated fat Increase low-fat dairy Procedure: Over 6 months of study 14 group training sessions 4 individual training sessions Recorded food and exercise diaries
Comparison of Fruit/Vegetable Intake in DASH & PREMIER Servings per Day DASH PREMIER
Issues in the Treatment of Hypertension DrugsDASH If I do it, will it work? YesYes Will I do it? MaybeNo Will I continue to do it? MaybeNo Will it lower risk ? Yes ?Yes Is it cost-effective? Very No
Lifestyle Interventions are Effective Treatments of Hypertensive PatientsConclusions • Lifestyle interventions such as the DASH diet CAN produce substantial reductions of BP, and probably of risk • In reality, most patients will NOT achieve sufficient changes to have a major impact on BP