1 / 7

COA Critique from CP spec

The following slides show how KANAL results can be used in answering some of the questions in the CP spec. COA Critique from CP spec. Engagement of Main Elements of Enemy combat power (B.3. 1 st paragraph 2nd line ): Q: “Are the assigned Blue units sufficient against the Red force?”

laurettac
Download Presentation

COA Critique from CP spec

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. The following slides show how KANAL results can be used in answering some of the questions in the CP spec

  2. COA Critique from CP spec Engagement of Main Elements of Enemy combat power (B.3. 1st paragraph 2nd line): Q: “Are the assigned Blue units sufficient against the Red force?”  For each step, check the preconditions that compare the required force ratio of the given task with the actual force ratio

  3. Agree Agree Agree Agree Disagree Disagree Disagree Disagree KANAL results for the answer • … • Step: Attack by Fire (aviation battalion attacks Red artillery) • … • Checking effects Remaining strength of 29th Guards is 60% • Step: Holding Attack: supporting attack by 1st brigade against 29th guards • Checking conditions actual force ratio (1.2) >= requred force ratio (1)  this condition succeeded • Step: Attack to Destroy: main attack by 3rd and 4th brigade against 29th guards • Checking conditions actual force ratio (3.5) >= requred force ratio (3)  this condition succeeded • Checking effects Remaining strength of 29th Guards is 50% • Step: … : modify critiquing knowledge Disagree

  4. COA Critique (cont) • Risk (Q15 of section 3.4) Q: Have I accepted too much risk to my own forces in this COA?  Highlight the tasks with large attrition

  5. Agree Agree Agree Agree Disagree Disagree Disagree Disagree KANAL results for the answer • … • Step: Moving 1st and 2nd brigade on Axis Green to Jayhawk • Checking conditions Units can move on the path (axis green)  This condition succeeded • Checking effects 1st and 2nd brigade is near Jayhawk • Step: Attack to Destroy: main attack by 1st and 2nd brigade against 29th guards • Checking conditions Required force ratio >= 3 (2.9)  this condition succeeded • Checking effects Remaining strength of 29th Guards: 70% Remaining strength of 1st and 2nd brigade: 60% • Step: …

  6. COA Critique (cont) • Mission Accomplishment (c.4.1) • Use expected effects

  7. Agree Disagree KANAL results for the answer • … • Step Move • You said that 3rd and 4th brigade should be near Jayhawk after this step The effect is in fact achieved • … • Expected Effects of the COA You said that • Red unit should be destroyed (remaining strength < 50%) ;; Destruction of 29th guards This effect is in fact achieved • Blue is located at Jayhawk ;; seizure of Obj Jayhawk This effect is in fact achieved • Blue strength > 90 % This effect is not achieved • end tasks by 1720 hrs This effect is in fact achieved details

More Related