100 likes | 363 Views
Group Think. Mark Hydeman, P.E., FASHRAE Taylor Engineering, LLC mhydeman@taylor-engineering.com. Scenario. New four story classroom and office building with:
E N D
Group Think Mark Hydeman, P.E., FASHRAE Taylor Engineering, LLCmhydeman@taylor-engineering.com
Scenario • New four story classroom and office building with: • Water-cooled chilled water plant with 2 each chillers, towers CHW pumps and CW pumps. All components have VSDs so they are efficient at part-load. • Central built up VAV air handling unit with 2 supply fans, 6 relief fans and air-side economizer. • PBX rooms on each floors located near the shaft. • Small data center on the first floor (3,000 ft2 <100w/sf). • The PBX rooms and data center need 24X7 cooling, the rest of the space operates ~3,000 hrs/yr.
Design options As a group consider the following design alternatives for serving the PBX rooms and data center: • VAV boxes from the central AHU • Dedicated CHW fan coils • Dedicated split-system air-cooled DX units • Dedicated water-cooled DX units
1: Variable Air Volume with Reheat Data Center or PBX room
2. Chilled Water CRAC Units CHWS&R to chillers on roof 2-WAY!
Heat exchanger connected to cooling towers at central plant on roof 4: Water Cooled CRAC
Consider the following attributes • Energy • First cost • Maintenance impact • Spatial impact • Redundancy and reliability
Score Sheet Score for that system and attribute Relative importance of attributes Sum of the product of all weights and scores for that system. Higher is better.