180 likes | 244 Views
Explore effective mitigation measures to reduce wildlife mortality, habitat fragmentation, and other impacts of highways. Discover strategies to enhance wildlife crossings and preserve genetic diversity while considering changing ecosystems. Learn about successful and unsuccessful methods, including modifying driver and animal behavior.
E N D
Mitigation Measures for Highway Impacts to Wildlife Amanda Hardy ahardy@coe.montana.edu *modified by Sandra Jacobson for Innovative Approaches to Wildlife and Highway Interactions Shortcourse NCTC 2008
Identify the Problem • Mortality • Loss of habitat connectivity • Daily or seasonal habitat needs • Genetic diversity • Loss of habitat • Pollution impacts • Disturbance • Associated Linear Infrastructure • Invasive species
Mitigation Triggers • Safety concerns • Sensitive or endangered species • Low population survival probability • Mass mortality • Public interest
Ways to define what “works” • “Effectiveness” may be defined as: • Reduced animal-vehicle collisions (AVCs) • Number of crossings by target species • Adequate number of crossings (how many?) • Connectivity maintained to sustain populations, communities, ecosystem functions • Measures of effectiveness may be: • Specific goals (e.g. 50% reduction in AVCs, cost-benefit ratio threshold >1)
Effective Mitigation Measures • Most effective for reducing mortality and maintaining habitat permeability is a combination of fencing, crossing structure and escape structure • Banff: • Ungulate-vehicle collisions reduced by 96% • All animal-vehicle collisions by 80% • Wildlife use of crossings increases over time
More Information Needed to Determine Effectiveness • Herd reductions • Roadside clearing • Signs • Education • At-grade crossings • In-vehicle warning systems • Crossing structures for some objectives such as genetic diversity or for low mobility species
Methods with Limited Demonstrated ‘Effectiveness’ • Lighting • Intercept feeding • Repellents
Ineffective Methods • Reflectors • Deer whistles • Flagging signs
Ecosystems are dynamic and constantly changing How mitigation performs over the long-term depends on accommodating changes in: Wildlife distributions, abundance and behaviors; Global warming effects; Climate change
General Mitigation Approaches • Avoid roading good habitat • “Ausbau über Neubau!” • Reduce (over-) populations • Modify • Driver behavior • Animal behavior
Modifying Driver Behavior • Signs: standard, enhanced, limited use (seasonal), real-time detection/warning activation • Reduced speed limits • In-vehicle warnings • Increased visibility • Education
Modifying Animal Behavior • Two approaches: • Sensory & physical control
Modifying Animal Behavior • Sensory control • Reflectors • Flagging • Whistles • Repellents • Intercept feeding • Road salt alternatives
Modifying Animal Behavior Physical control • Fencing with: • Under- & overpasses • At-grade crossings Photos: Anthony Clevenger
Steeper than necessary cut slopes “Elk rock” @ $45 per linear foot
Florida • Tonto NF, AZ • Banff • Banff NP, Canada Photos: Anthony Clevenger