1 / 11

The OPERA Anomaly - a Quick Summary with Comments

The OPERA Anomaly - a Quick Summary with Comments. Physics 841, Fall 2011 Prof. Brian Meadows. OPERA Experiment (Gran Sasso, Italy). Purpose: Look for “appearance” of ¿ leptons from a º ¹ “beam” from CERN (SPS) 730 km away. At CERN ¼ ( K ) mesons decay ¼ § ( K § )  ¹ § º ¹

levi
Download Presentation

The OPERA Anomaly - a Quick Summary with Comments

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. The OPERA Anomaly - a Quick Summarywith Comments Physics 841, Fall 2011 Prof. Brian Meadows Brian Meadows, U. Cincinnati.

  2. OPERA Experiment (Gran Sasso, Italy) • Purpose: • Look for “appearance” of ¿ leptons from a º¹ “beam” from CERN (SPS) 730 km away. • At CERN ¼(K) mesons decay ¼§(K§) ¹§º¹ • The º¹ travel to OPERA Possibly º¹º¿ • At OPERA some º(very few) interact to make either ¹§’s or ¿’s that can be observed. Brian Meadows, U. Cincinnati

  3. Time of Flight Measurement • Individual º’s are not timed by “start” and “stop” signals • There is a profile of positions over some 10’s of meters from which the º’s originate (where the ¼ or K decays can occur) • There is also a profile of positions over several meters where the arriving º’s are observed • A convolution of individual flight times ¢ti can therefore be made to arrive at the most likely value for the mean time of flight T PDF for Interaction of º’s PDF for Birth of º’s Individual ¢t’s Brian Meadows, U. Cincinnati

  4. Baseline Measurement L • By this we mean average distance between the two PDF’s • Briefly, use was made of GPS locators at each end • Some difficulty with this since both ends were under several meters of rock I believe • Local site surveys were also required • Note that GPS devices are reasonably accurate (~ 1m) • They only achieve this precision by making corrections for refraction (a delay) in the ionosphere and for general relativistic effects upon the satellite orbits • The discrepancy reported (60 ns) corresponds to about 20m Brian Meadows, U. Cincinnati

  5. OPERA’s Result • The OPERA team make a “no frills” comparison of T with the baseline length L T – L/c = - 60.7 ± 6.9 (stat.) ± 7.4 (sys.) ns • NOTE this is negative by ~ 6 standard deviations Brian Meadows, U. Cincinnati

  6. A few Comments • º’s are known to experience the MSW effect on passage through material (effectively a refractive index effect). • This makes the discrepancy even worse • Photons also have a (different) refractive index • Gravitational red shift makes the distance from end to end longer than simple geometric length • Again, makes the discrepancy worse – same for photons • A direct “race” between a  and a º would be the best test !! Physics 841, U. Cincinnati, Fall, 2011 Brian Meadows, U. Cincinnati

  7. SN1987a - Race Between º and ° • A supernova occurred in the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC) approximately 150 Klyr away • This produced much light and nuclear fusion in the implosion produces a huge ºe (and ºe) flux • Both light and º pulses were short and simultaneous • In 1987, about 150,000 years later, this was observed visually on Earth • Within an hour, some large º detectors observed ~2-5 º interactions • Usually only see ~1 or 2 in a 24 hr period • These were AFTER the light pulse, so º’s are SLOWER than light! • If º’s from LMC and CERN are the same, the ones from LMC should have arrived 4 years earlier ! Brian Meadows, U. Cincinnati

  8. Some Observations • The OPERA result is reported as a “discrepancy” • The authors call for other º experiments to check the finding • They also ask for constructive comments on their methodology • One could also ask that any tapes from a few years before SN1987a be checked to see if there were any º “bursts” about 3-4 years earlier • Let’s hope for another nearby supernova soon • Maybe not too near though! • Suppose we have just observed tachyons for the first time !! • It would be a surprise, • It would not help to understand “dark matter” since this seems to hover around galaxies and cannot be made of tachyons A bit like finding the ¹ when we were looking for the Yukawa particle ? Brian Meadows, U. Cincinnati

  9. A few Comments on GPS D Earth • GPS technology has complexities that may shake our blind belief that we can really measure distances of 730 km as accurately as claimed? • Basic principal • 4 satellites in each of 6 orbits equally oriented wrt the equator • Measure distance D and use triangulation to find position on Earth Physics 841, U. Cincinnati, Fall, 2011 Brian Meadows, U. Cincinnati

  10. GPD … • Two effects it has to deal with are • The ionosphere slows down the signal by an amount \propto the electron density that varies with Sun activity, etc. • Satellites are not stationary(!) and their orbits precess in the solar wind and due to GR. • A target on Earth like a car also moves (though CERN and Opera tend to stay where they are!) • So corrections of several 10’s of feet are required. [We DO assume that the signals do not travel with speed >c, though!] Physics 841, U. Cincinnati, Fall, 2011 Brian Meadows, U. Cincinnati

  11. Two solutions D2 D1 Earth • Differential GPS • The position can be found using signals from a nearby, fixed station with known position and for which the ionosphere effect is similar. • Only works for distances up to ~ 30 km. • Use of two frequencies • Two frequencies calibrate the ionosphere effect • Works for larger distances but uncertainty is larger. Physics 841, U. Cincinnati, Fall, 2011 Brian Meadows, U. Cincinnati

More Related