E N D
1.
Jonathan Mant, Professor of Primary Care Research Primary & Community Perspective on Stroke Care
2. Patient pathway and primary care
3. Prevention of stroke
4. Who is at high risk of stroke? Lifestyle factors:
Obesity; physical inactivity; excessive alcohol consumption; smoking; diet
Medical factors:
Hypertension; atrial fibrillation; carotid artery stenosis; diabetes mellitus
(Raised cholesterol)
Existing disease:
Previous stroke or TIA; coronary heart disease
5. How common are these risk factors for a GP with list size 2,000?
6. What evidence based treatments? Blood pressure lowering Agents
Statins to lower cholesterol
Anti-platelet agents (aspirin)
Carotid endarterectomy
Anticoagulation for atrial fibrillation
Lifestyle intervention
7. Vascular disease prevention strategies Much stroke prevention is same as coronary heart disease prevention
Identification of people at raised cardiovascular risk & treat with cholesterol lowering therapy and blood pressure lowering therapy
Current threshold 20% 10 year cardiovascular risk
Stroke specific strategies (TIA; AF)
Population strategies aimed at
Smoking; diet; exercise
8. Change in stroke incidence 1981-2004
12. Stroke specific primary prevention Strategies that are stroke focussed are:
Rapid treatment of transient ischaemic attack
Detection and treatment of carotid artery stenosis
Detection and treatment of atrial fibrillation
13. Early treatment of TIA
20. Express Study: before and after study of effect of urgent treatment of TIA/ minor stroke Phase 1
GP referral to daily clinic
Treatment recommendations faxed to GP
Patients advised to see GP asap Phase 2
No appointment required
Treatment initiated immediately in clinic
22. Express treatment protocol Aspirin 300mg given in clinic (then 75mg daily)
Clopidogrel 300mg then 75mg daily if within 48 hrs
Simvastatin 40mg daily
BP lowering therapy if systolic BP = 130mmHg
Anticoagulation if indicated
Carotid imaging during following week
CT scan during clinic if incomplete symptom resolution
23. Differences in process of care from phase one to phase two in EXPRESS Speedier assessment after symptom onset (3 days to less than one day)
Faster treatment (20 days to less than one day)
Greater use of preventive medicines at one month follow up:
Aspirin + clopidogrel: 49% v 10%
Statin: 84% v 65%
On BP lowering: 83% v 62%
Lower BP at one month: 136/75 v 142/80
24. Questions in TIA care Which treatments are effective in acute TIA management?
Should GPs initiate treatment?
25. Evidence base for specific therapies in acute phase of TIA/ minor stroke Aspirin v
Carotid endarterectomy v
Addition of second anti-platelet agent?
BP lowering
Long term v
Early phase ?
Cholesterol lowering
Long term v
Early phase ?
26. Effectiveness of Endarterectomy in relation to timing of surgeryRothwell et al, Lancet 2004 (20th March)
27. Detection and treatment of atrial fibrillation
31. NICE guidelines: caution with warfarin Aged over 75
On anti-platelet drugs
Polypharmacy
Uncontrolled hypertension
History of bleeding (eg peptic ulcer; cerebral haemorrhage)
History of poor anticoagulation control
34. BAFTA Results Risk of primary end point:
Warfarin v aspirin
1.8% p.a v 3.8% p.a
RR 0.48 (0.28-0.80)
NNT: 50 for 1 year
p = 0.0027
35. BAFTA bleeding risk per annum
36. Secondary prevention Aspirin + dipyridamole
Simvastatin 40mg
Blood pressure lowering
Anticoagulation if indicated
37. Effect of statin on risk of stroke and cardiovascular eventsHeart Protection Study, Lancet 2004 (6th March)
39. PROGRESS – sub group analyses P value for heterogeneity: <0.001 for combination versus singleP value for heterogeneity: <0.001 for combination versus single
42. Quality markers (1) High quality specialist rehabilitation
Stroke units
Early supported discharge
Longer term availability in the community
End of life care
Responsive care with appropriate skills
43. Quality Markers (2) Seamless transfer of care
Clear discharge plan
Inter-sectoral (health; social services; transport; housing)
That is communicated
Long term care & support
Emotional and psychological factors
Adaptation of environment
Carer engagement and support
44. Quality Markers (3) Assessment and review
Health & social care
By primary care: 6 weeks; 6 months; annual
Participation in community life
Local opportunities & resources
Liaison with community & voluntary sector
Return to work
46. Community perspective - conclusion Significant advances in evidence base for stroke prevention in last 15 years
Implementation strategies need to be in place
Lots of longer term unmet need
Needs multi-disciplinary and inter-sectoral approach
Mustn’t be neglected
Current lack of service provision
Current lack of research