E N D
1. Seismic Working Group 9/27/2007 1 U Colorado Boulder Workshop on Dam Safety R&D Needs
2. 9/27/2007 2 U Colorado Boulder Workshop on
Dam Safety R&D Needs
3. 9/27/2007 3 U Colorado Boulder Workshop on
Dam Safety R&D Needs
4. 9/27/2007 4 U Colorado Boulder Workshop on
Dam Safety R&D Needs
5. 9/27/2007 5 U Colorado Boulder Workshop on
Dam Safety R&D Needs
6. 9/27/2007 6 U Colorado Boulder Workshop on
Dam Safety R&D Needs
7. 9/27/2007 7 U Colorado Boulder Workshop on
Dam Safety R&D Needs
8. 9/27/2007 8 U Colorado Boulder Workshop on
Dam Safety R&D Needs
9. 9/27/2007 9 U Colorado Boulder Workshop on
Dam Safety R&D Needs
10. 9/27/2007 10 U Colorado Boulder Workshop on
Dam Safety R&D Needs
11. Survey Responses Research Needs Included:
Inelastic behavior
Seismic Excitation
Post-EQ Analyses (back analyses)
Validation of Structural Analyses
Failure Modes
Initiation of failure and post-EQ damage
Deformation and liquefaction of embankment dams
Soil-Structure interaction of spillway walls next to embankments
Probabilistic Methods of Analysis
See next slide
Simplified Methods for Low Seismic Zones
Particularly in Eastern US
9/27/2007 U Colorado Boulder Workshop on
Dam Safety R&D Needs 11
12. 9/27/2007 12 U Colorado Boulder Workshop on
Dam Safety R&D Needs
13. 9/27/2007 13 U Colorado Boulder Workshop on
Dam Safety R&D Needs
14. 9/27/2007 14 U Colorado Boulder Workshop on
Dam Safety R&D Needs
15. Concrete Dams Failure Modes
Validation of structural analyses
Damping
Foundation Stability Analysis
Shear keys, lift lines & contraction joints
Validated material and damage models
Uplift during and after an EQ
Silent boundary conditions
Spatially varying EQs
Displacements of gravity dams – prediction & limits
Strengthening concrete dams 9/27/2007 U Colorado Boulder Workshop on
Dam Safety R&D Needs 15
16. Spillways Gated spillway structures during EQs
Hydrodynamic loads on spillway gates
Rehab schemes 9/27/2007 U Colorado Boulder Workshop on
Dam Safety R&D Needs 16
17. Present Small Scale EQ Testing Dynamic excitation tests
Lab shake table tests
Small scale centrifuge tests
Strong motion instruments 9/27/2007 U Colorado Boulder Workshop on
Dam Safety R&D Needs 17
18. Large Scale EQ Testing Benefits Would allow improved treatment of:
Material Properties
Mass concrete properties
Concrete tensile threshold
Constitutive models
Fracture, shearing and sliding
Embankment wrap-arounds etc
Loading
Uplift
EQ inputs, spatially varying etc
Hydrodynamic interaction
Damping (from elastic to damage)
Radiation damping
FEM
Validation and benchmark tests using large scale models
Dynamic Response 9/27/2007 U Colorado Boulder Workshop on
Dam Safety R&D Needs 18
19. 9/27/2007 19 U Colorado Boulder Workshop on
Dam Safety R&D Needs
20. Conclusions There is substantial uncertainty in present modeling
This is particularly so as we move in Risk Informed decisions where we need to describe behavior to failure
Current small scale testing has limitations
Large scale testing would offer better validation opportunities 9/27/2007 U Colorado Boulder Workshop on
Dam Safety R&D Needs 20