190 likes | 356 Views
Pay for Performance and Regional Variation. Michael J. Belman, MD MPH Anthem Blue Cross (California) Academy Health June 8 2008. Introduction. Integrated Healthcare Association (IHA) 5 th year of statewide measurement Over 200 groups and IPA,s in the program
E N D
Pay for Performance and Regional Variation Michael J. Belman, MD MPH Anthem Blue Cross (California) Academy Health June 8 2008
Introduction • Integrated Healthcare Association (IHA) 5th year of statewide measurement • Over 200 groups and IPA,s in the program • Incentives from 7 California health plans • Clinical quality measures, Patient Satisfaction Survey, and Internal IT Resources • Anthem Blue Cross bonus payment for measurement year (MY) 2006 was $69 million, Total bonus for all CA plans > $150m
Blue Cross of CA HMO MembershipTotal: 1.4 Million Members SACRAMENTO (2%) 1% 5% 12% 12% 4% 40% % = Percent of Blue Cross HMO members in each region 18% 7%
Health Disparities and California P4P:Market Statistics (2005 Data) Source: 2006 HealthLeaders-InterStudy Market Overview
Inland Empire Performance MetricsInland Demographics • Lower PCP and specialist numbers in Inland Empire compared to California and the nation • Lower number of college graduates and higher number with high school education or below • Ethnic breakdown amongst insured in San Bernardino County shows • Higher percent African American and Latino • Lower percent Asian and White • Lower percent insured in Inland Empire compared to California
Impact of Regional Variation on Quality Metrics including NCQA HEDIS CAHPS * Blue Cross of California * * * 65% 58% Source: Danielsen, B. and Damberg, C. (2007) Analysis of the Relative Contributions of Health Plans and Provider Organizations to the 2007 PAS scores.
North East Region WellPoint/Anthem – CT, NH, ME HealthNet – CT Cigna – NH Aetna - CT California WellPoint/Anthem Blue Cross CA HealthNet – CA Cigna – CA Aetna - CA Impact of Regional Variation on US News and World Report (2007) HMO Ranking National Plans 186-216 National Plans in Top 35 Healthplan performance largely determined by regional factors (provider network, ethnicity, SES)
Conclusions • Persistent and consistent regional variation in performance • Low performing regions in general do not improve relative performance • Inland Empire has lowest score but Los Angeles County has largest population with low scores • Membership has not declined in poor performing groups • Regional disparities may adversely impact healthplan HEDIS • Current Incentive formula perpetuates disparity in bonus award if only thresholds or rank used to determine bonus • Breakthrough improvement may require investment in personnel and infrastructure