1 / 6

Ethical Aspects of Controlling Genetic Doping

Ethical Aspects of Controlling Genetic Doping. Christian Munthe Department of Philosophy, Göteborg University. Genetic Interventions: Prospects of Detection 1. Genetic Testing (as the basis for (pre)selection) Gamete, embryo, fetus / child, adolescent, grown-up

lute
Download Presentation

Ethical Aspects of Controlling Genetic Doping

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Ethical Aspects of Controlling Genetic Doping Christian Munthe Department of Philosophy, Göteborg University

  2. Genetic Interventions: Prospects of Detection 1 • Genetic Testing (as the basis for (pre)selection) • Gamete, embryo, fetus / child, adolescent, grown-up • (Pre)selection against sports related health risks • (Pre)selection for sports related ‘extra talents’ • Impossible to detect • Probably impossible to classify as doping anyway • Germ-line Genetic Modification • Gamete, 1-5 day embryo • Construction of individuals that carry an initial genetic ‘extra talent’ for (specific) sports • Impossible to distinguish from ‘natural’ mutations • Impossible to detect • Perhaps impossible to classify as doping anyway

  3. Genetic Interventions: Prospects of Detection 2 • Somatic Genetic Modification • Modification of (some part of) the initial genetic make-up of an individual’s own cells • Transplantation of ‘foreign’ genetically modified (or otherwise genetically suitable) cells • In their natural place (muscle cells in the muscles etc.) • Hidden depots • Repair, cure or prevent disease or injury • Enhance initial athletic capacities • No sharp line to be found • Unclear what changes are to be classified as doping • Can perhaps be detected through genetic testing, but... • Credible control programs will probably require initial complete genome scans + very many and repeated tests from many different parts of the body

  4. Ethical Issues in Genetic Testing (crash course) • Safety and burdens of sample taking • More relevant for the sports context • Reliability of predictions • Risks of misunderstanding • Handling of ‘extra’ information • Probably even more relevant for the sports context • Risks of harm but also chances of benefit • Third party interests • Relatives • Insurance companies, employers etc. • Requirement of Informed Consent • Need for Genetic Counselling • What is ‘good enough’ to offer to patients?

  5. Consequences for the Sports Context 1 • Athletes not as initially vulnerable as patients • Athletes less prepared for information of consequence for health and well-being • Risks and burdens in some ways much more serious in the sports context • Much less is at stake if testing is not done • Stronger responsibility to minimise harm in the sports context

  6. Consequences for the Sports Context 2 • Strong case for initial information and counselling • Preparedness for dealing with consequences of ‘extra information’ imperative • Classic informed consent model impossible (opting out means being excluded from competition) • There is a limit to what hardships and risks should be required of athletes in order to secure competitions free of ‘gene doping’ • Sports officials have to consider that ethical reasons may: • Make control programs much more expensive and complicated • Impede the realization of the goal of making competitions free of gene doping • Make gene doping bans vulnerable to strategic choices of gene doping procedures that would require too budensome testing procedures to be detected

More Related