90 likes | 239 Views
Universality, means testing and the Universal Credit. Paul Spicker Scottish Policy Innovation Forum 7 th March 2014. Definitions. Universality : for and against. Selectivity : for and against. The problems of means testing. Problems of selectivity complexity exclusion non- takeup
E N D
Universality, means testing and the Universal Credit Paul Spicker Scottish Policy Innovation Forum 7th March 2014
The problems of means testing Problems of selectivity complexity exclusion non-takeup equity costly administration intrusiveness boundary problems the ‘poverty trap’ Problems of means testing threshold definition and tapers capital equivalence and household composition changing circumstances self-employment
Universal Credit: the plan The plan ‘Digital by default’ The ‘claimant commitment’ Monthly payment ‘Real time’ ‘Direct payment’ The problems Slow progress The IT The limited pilots The ‘fortress’ mentality
Universal Credit: The designProblems of benefits in generalignorance complexity stigmapolicing the boundaries Problems of means testing threshold definition and tapers capital equivalence and household composition identifying circumstances fluctuations in income self-employment Universal Credit has the lot Recent failures benefits without clear entitlement repayment expecting sick people to work medical reassessment penalties not linked to knowledge cohabitation rule multiple dimensions