1 / 30

Discounting

Discounting. The Appointed Actuary Seminar Presenter: Patricia Hladun September 20, 2004. Topics. The Move to Discounting Annual Return Results Unpaid Claims and Loss Ratio Analysis Exhibit Sample Review – 10 Companies Some Filing Guidelines. The Move to Discounting.

maine
Download Presentation

Discounting

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Discounting The Appointed Actuary Seminar Presenter: Patricia Hladun September 20, 2004

  2. Topics • The Move to Discounting • Annual Return Results • Unpaid Claims and Loss Ratio Analysis Exhibit • Sample Review – 10 Companies • Some Filing Guidelines

  3. The Move to Discounting Discounting for P&C companies policy liabilities came into effect Jan 1, 2003 Historical reasons for not allowing discounting: • Short tailed business • Low interest rates • No actuarial requirements (e.g. actuarial report) • Lack of standards of practice • Implicit margin

  4. The Move to Discounting Changes in historical conditions: • Increased litigation • Coverage provided becomes longer tailed and therefore investment income becomes material • Introduction of actuarial requirements by regulators • Development of actuarial standards

  5. The Move to Discounting Reasons for OSFI requiring discounting: • Consistent with OSFI’s reliance approach • Provides a more realistic measure of financial performance • Provides for the explicit determination of margins for adverse deviation • Makes financial reporting practices more consistent with the economic realities • Improves the consistency of Canadian P&C financial reporting

  6. The Move to Discounting Changes to Actuarial Reports: • Opinions are not qualified anymore • New CIA educational note was developed (regarding the runoff of unpaid claims on a discounted basis) • Appendix II was removed and the Unpaid Claims and Loss Ratio Analysis Exhibit was added

  7. The Move to Discounting Changes to the Annual Return: • Policy liabilities are on a discounted basis • Page 60.41(run-off on a discounted basis) was added

  8. Annual Return Results Expected Results based on 12/2001: • Net claims liabilities reduced by $350 million: • 1 ½ % of net undiscounted reserves • 8 – 10 points on MCT/BAAT

  9. Annual Return Results Use of prior period adjustment at 12/2002: • Canadian (20.40.04.02) 67 million • Foreign (20.45.04.02)120 million 187 million

  10. Annual Return Results Discounting results at 12/2002: • Net outstanding ¾ of 1% • Capital 1% • MCT/BAAT: • Canadian 1% • Foreign 9% • Total 3%

  11. Annual Return Results Discounting results at 12/2003: • Net outstanding 0.8% • Capital 1.1% • MCT/BAAT: • Canadian 2% • Foreign 10% • Total 4%

  12. Annual Return Results Use of Exhibits 60.40 & 60.41: • 60.40 Net Undiscounted O/S Claims 24,925 m • 60.41 Net Discounted O/S Claims 24,714 m • Change 211 m

  13. Annual Return Results

  14. Unpaid Claims & Loss Ratio Analysis Exhibit • Hard copy was included in the AAR • Electronic copy was to be filed by June 1, 2004

  15. Unpaid Claims & Loss Ratio Analysis Exhibit Problems: • Companies unaware of June 1 deadline • Software problems • Incorrect data formats

  16. Unpaid Claims & Loss Ratio Analysis Exhibit Results: • Co-ordination between Quebec regulator and OSFI • Industry results will most likely be shared • Target release for early December

  17. Unpaid Claims & Loss Ratio Analysis Exhibit Next year: • For 2004, electronic exhibits are due with the Annual Return filing on March 1 or April 15

  18. Sample Review – 10 Companies • 10 of the largest federally regulated companies (8 Canadian and 2 Foreign) • Primary insurers

  19. Sample Review – 10 Companies $ millions Total undiscounted unpaid claims 10,287 Present value of unpaid claims 9,123 Change 1,164 Percentage Change (11.3%)

  20. Sample Review – 10 Companies Discount as % of Undiscounted Auto BI 11.5% Auto PD 3.7% Auto AB 11.3% Auto Physical Damage 1.9% Property – Personal 4.6% Property – Commercial 3.5% Liability 14.4%

  21. Sample Review – 10 Companies Range of change in present values to total undiscounted: • Low: 6.9% • High: 13.4% Differences were mainly due to: • Mix of business • Auto AB

  22. Sample Review – 10 Companies PfAD – Claims • $949 million • 83% of PfAD • Average MfAD is 10.4% • MfAD range is 6.5% to 12.8%

  23. Sample Review – 10 Companies PfAD – Claims • Auto BI • MfAD range: 8.4% to 13.8% • Average MfAD: 11.1% • Auto PD • MfAD range: 2.5% to 7.4% • Average MfAD: 4.7%

  24. Sample Review – 10 Companies PfAD – Claims • Auto AB • MfAD range: 0.4% to 13.7% • Average MfAD: 9.3% • Auto AB (excluding one company) • MfAD range: 6.1% to 13.7% • Average MfAD: 10.4%

  25. Sample Review – 10 Companies PfAD – Claims • Auto Physical Damage • MfAD range: 2.5% to 7.4% • Average MfAD: 4.5% • Personal Property (excl one company) • MfAD range: 2.5% to 9.4% • Average MfAD: 5.2%

  26. Sample Review – 10 Companies PfAD – Claims • Commercial Property • MfAD range: 2.6% to 9.6% • Average MfAD: 6.5% • Liability • MfAD range: 7.4% to 14.3% • Average MfAD: 11.8%

  27. Sample Review – 10 Companies PfAD – Reinsurance • $21 million • 2% of PfAD

  28. Sample Review – 10 Companies PfAD – Interest Rate • $172 million • 15% of PfAD

  29. Sample Review – 10 Companies $ millions Total undiscounted unpaid claims 10,287 Total discounted unpaid claims + PfADs 10,265 Change – Sample of 10 companies 0.2% Change – Industry Total 0.8% Actuarial reserves as % of undiscounted 99.8% Range 98.1% to 101.3%

  30. Some Filing Guidelines

More Related