360 likes | 589 Views
Field Area Networks. March 19, 2014. Outline. Opening Introductions FAN Introduction Network Evaluation Backhaul Spectrum Standards Application Example. Introduction and Acknowledgement. UTC: Klaus Bender* EnerNex: Erich Gunther* , Doug Houseman* , Aaron Snyder* Acknowledgement
E N D
Field Area Networks March 19, 2014
Outline • Opening Introductions • FAN Introduction • Network Evaluation • Backhaul • Spectrum • Standards • Application Example
Introduction and Acknowledgement • UTC: Klaus Bender* • EnerNex: Erich Gunther*, Doug Houseman*, Aaron Snyder* • Acknowledgement • Alcatel Lucent: Mark Madden* • CLECO: Troy West • Council Rock Engineering: David Rodriquez • Exelon Corp: Doug McGinnis • Fujitsu Network Communications: John Chowdhury • Salt River Project: Chris Campbell and Ron Taylor • West Monroe Partners: Dan Belmont* *Contributing Author
Field Area Networks-Definition • Securely connects devices used to monitor and control the power system to the hardware and software used to accomplish those tasks • Monitoring and Control: meters, line sensors, capacitor bank controllers, transformer load tap changers, relays/reclosers, etc. • Communications: wireless private or public radio spectrum, cellular telephone, wired, or power line carrier
Field Area Networks-Application • Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) • Demand Response (DR) • Distribution Automation (DA) • Wide Area Monitoring, Protection, and Control (WAMPAC) • Substation Automation (SA) • Field Worker Data Connectivity • Physical Security • Substation Operational Voice • Enterprise Voice/Data
Network Evaluation • Requirements Conditions: • Steady State • Outage • Restoration • Firmware Push • Also consider mode changing • Architecture dependent (PTMP, Mesh)
Network Evaluation Mesh Considerations A: single relay point B: long hop C: deep and narrow D: back chain E: non-communicating location
Network Evaluation - PTMP • Tower Lessons Learned, Summary • Coverage overlap critical, invest in field measurements to verify • Some filtering may be needed for other signals • Avoid power line proximity • Understand emergency condition operation for multi-carrier towers • Topology Lessons Learned, Summary • There are a limited number of simultaneous conversations per tower • Different message headers, priority groups, or slightly different frequencies may reduce some issues • Report-by-exception devices may be difficult to verify if no program is in place
Network Evaluation - Mesh • Tower Lessons Learned, Summary • Installation locations may suffer from multihop Ping-Pong messaging • Variable latency may prove troublesome for some operational applications • Performance during outages and communications overload may be mitigated by longer lasting batteries • Head-end Lessons Learned, Summary • Most systems are intended for batch processing, not real-time operations • Grid traffic concerns, latency, and interface design key • Operation schedules should dictate firmware upgrades and other system maintenance
Network Evaluation - Hybrid • Rigorous design and testing should be performed for each location • Seasonal conditions will impact performance, clear skies, storms, snow, ground clutter • Assume worst case foliage conditions • Testing and modeling equipment is worth the expense • Hybrid networks combine both the strengths and weaknesses of PTMP and Mesh
Backhaul Technology Considerations
Backhaul Considerations Cost of Ownership Analysis, FAN
Backhaul Considerations Technology Comparison, WiMAX vs. LTE
Spectrum - Footprint Suburban Rural Urban Vertical Urban
Spectrum - Types Licensed Unlicensed Technology and Standards Direct Sequence Spread Spectrum (DSSS) Frequency Hopping Spread Spectrum (FHSS) Examples: IEEE 802.11b, 802.15.4, 802.16
Spectrum Options Full Coverage in Appendix B of White Paper
Standards and Technology Adoption • Identify a Use Case • Identify Requirements • Identify a Business Case • Identify Business Requirements • Identify a Testing and Certification Process • Do not just quote standard numbers
Application Example Use Case: Outage and Restoration Management • Implementation variations include: Environmental, Network Architecture, Demographic • Example leverages power outage/last gasp • Number of hops a key issue • Possible hidden pockets of outages and restored areas
Application Example - Payload • Electric Meter Encounters Loss of Power
Application Example - Payload • Electric Meter Detect Power Restored
For Your Information • This presentation is based on a white paper recently released by UTC’s Smart Networks Council with support of UTC members and the Edison Electric Institute (EEI) • The paper was written by EnerNex, members of the SNC board and UTC staff • The SNC FAN paper is available for download at: http://www.utc.org/online-store
Erich Gunther, Chairman and CTO erich@enernex.com Doug Houseman, Vice President doug@enernex.com Aaron Snyder, Deputy Director aaron@enernex.com Thank you!