570 likes | 1.24k Views
Cruise Line Industry. By: Daniel Novick, Spencer Roane, Vinamra Laddha and Wazir Browne. Industry Background. Value of industry 2012 Gross Revenue Forecast: $29 billion Barriers to Entry Capital Intensive “ Big Five ” and Others Market Share Growth/Trends. Barriers to Entry.
E N D
Cruise Line Industry By: Daniel Novick, Spencer Roane, Vinamra Laddha and Wazir Browne
Industry Background • Value of industry • 2012 Gross Revenue Forecast: $29 billion • Barriers to Entry • Capital Intensive • “Big Five” and Others • Market Share • Growth/Trends
Barriers to Entry • High cost of acquiring ships • Necessity of place of port • Finding and hiring qualified crew • Captain, Chefs, etc. • Government regulations and international tariffs • High price of oil and energy to power ship
Legal Hurdles • Each cruise ship must be registered to a specific country • Creates issues for staffing (union vs. non-union) • US law requires the ship to be built and staffed by Americans for it to be “flagged” to the US • Ships are safety-inspected four times per year • Captain has ultimate authority to enforce laws and policies • Flags of Convenience
Industry Functions • Transportation • Sleeping accommodations • Dining accommodations • Amenities • Entertainment • Off-ship excursions
Major Players: “Big Five” • What is the Big Five? • Carnival • Royal Caribbean • Norwegian • MSC Cruises • Disney • Nights sold for each in 2007 (in millions): • Carnival: 36.32 • Royal Caribbean: 19.66 • Norwegian: 8.44 • Disney: 1.66
Company Profile: Carnival Corporation • Founded: 1972 • Based in: US and UK • Brands: Carnival Cruise, Costa Cruise, Cunard Line, Holland America, Princess Cruises, Seabourn Cruise • Revenues: $15.8B in 2011 • Employees: 10,200 employees & 75,000 crew • Size of Fleet – 103 Cruise Ships (209,420 passengers) • Key facts: • Ticker symbol: CCL • 1.4 times the fleet of closest competitor
Company Profile: Royal Caribbean • Founded: 1968 • Based in: Florida, US • Brands: Celebrity Cruise, Royal Caribbean • Revenues: $5.21B in 2011 • Employees: 5,700 • Size of Fleet – 40 Cruise Ships (96,270 passengers) • Key facts: • Ticker symbol: RCL • Operates 40 cruise ships to 400 destinations
Company Profile: MSC Cruises • Founded: 1987 • Based in: Geneva, Switzerland • Brands: None • Revenues: $1.98B in 2011 • Size of Fleet – 12 Cruise Ships (27,750 passengers) • Key facts: • Fleet of 12 cruise ships increasing to 14 by 2013 • 5.8% world market share
Company Profile: Norwegian Cruise • Founded: 1966 • Based in: Florida, US • Brands: None • Revenues: $2.31B in 2011 • Size of Fleet – 11 Cruise Ships (25,280 passengers) • Key facts: • Filed with SEC for up to $250M IPO in July, 2011 • 11 ships in current fleet, two more to join over ‘13-14
Company Profile: Disney Cruise • Founded: 1998 • Based in: Florida, US • Brands: None • Revenues: Up 4% from 2010 • Size of Fleet – 4 Cruise Ships(8,510 passengers) • Key facts: • Disney Cruise Line is considered a segment of Disney Parks and Resorts • Fleet includes only four ships
Industry Competition – Solo Traveler • Fred Olsen • Spirit of Adventure • P&O Cruises • Hebridean Island Cruises • Costa Cruises
Competition and Structure • We can study the HHI by combining subsidiaries or by looking at individual cruise lines • HHI with subsidiaries: 998 • HHI without subsidiaries: 3091
2012 World Wide Market Share Royal Caribbean Carnival
Growth of Industry/Trends • Increase in number of passengers (in thousands)
Perceptual Map Formal Pricey Inexpensive Relaxed
Industry-wide price elasticity • Lerner Index = (1663 - 612)/1663 = .63199 • (1/.63199) = 1.58 = elasticity
Pricing Strategies • Temporal Pricing • Time of Purchase • Seasonal Pricing • Third-Degree Discrimination • Second-Degree Discrimination • Overbooking • Loyalty Programs
Temporal Pricing • Inter-temporal Pricing • Similar to airline Industry • Last minute discounts • Seasonal Pricing • Price spikes in summer months and December
Temporal Pricing – Time of Purchase • As the sail date approaches the price of tickets increases due to the increase in demand at the last moment • However, within the last week it is possible to get cruise ticket discounts because Cruise Liners want to leave with full capacity and minimize the fixed cost/person
Third-Degree Price Discrimination • Different prices for ships • Carnival Imagination 4 day trip 350 • Carnival Victory 4 day trip 480 • Room prices • 7 day trip to Caribbean from Miami • Interior 670 • Suite 1,679 • Early Saver plan
Second-Degree Discrimination • Two-Part Tariff • Ticket Price to get on the ship • Shopping on the boat • For example • Carnival Cruise Excursions • Lobster Champaign and beach Excursion • $120 • Island Safari 4x4 Adventure • $80
Overbooking Strategy • Better than Hotels? Why? • Captive Audience • No business travelers • No holdovers or early departures • Packed ship important to the cruise ambience • Cruises have big-time repeat customers • Great package for less than $100 a day • Great ties with travel agents • Long booking periods
Loyalty Programs • Many cruise lines have them • However, they are not very publicized • Have very limited benefits
Recommendations? • Differentiate based on brand and ship experience • Encourage citizens of all ports to tour the cruise ship • Improve loyalty programs and market them more • Allow passengers to stay at a destination and come back on another cruise • Works for cruise destinations that are visited routinely