550 likes | 756 Views
The Florida BRITE Project: Screening and Brief Interventions for Older Adult at Risk of Substance Misuse. Larry Schonfeld, Ph.D . Interim Executive Director, Florida Mental Health Institute schonfel@usf.edu http://BRITE.fmhi.usf.edu Presented at the FADAA/FCCMH Conference Aug. 7, 2013.
E N D
The Florida BRITE Project: Screening and Brief Interventions for Older Adult at Risk of Substance Misuse Larry Schonfeld, Ph.D. Interim Executive Director, Florida Mental Health Institute schonfel@usf.edu http://BRITE.fmhi.usf.edu Presented at the FADAA/FCCMH Conference Aug. 7, 2013
Today’s presentation • Overview of substance abuse issues and treatment for older adults • Presentation on the Florida BRITE Project • Pilot project funded by Florida DCF (2004-07) • Expansion through national SBIRT initiative funded by SAMHSA/CSAT $14 million grant • Lessons learned from conducting SBIRT in Florida
National Household Survey: % Adults Aged 18+ Reporting past month use of alcohol/drugs by age group in 2000 (NHSDA, 2001) 12% of 55+ age group are either binge or heavy alcohol users Percent Reporting Use in Past Month
U.S. Substance Abuse Treatment Admissions in 2006Trunzo & Henderson (Gerontological Society of America presentation 2008) NALL ADMISSIONS= 1,798,000 NADMISSIONS OVER 50= 189,000 35-44 yrs27% 45-49 yrs11% 50-54 yrs: 6% 50+ yrs11% 25-34 yrs25% 55-59 yrs: 3% <18 yrs8% 18-24 yrs18% 60-64 yrs: 1% 65+ yrs: <1%
Admissions Under 50 and Age 50+by Primary Substance * Excludes methadone
Older adults are often “hidden” alcohol abusers • Fewer indicators compared to younger adults: • DUI’s • Work-related problems • Marital Problems • Peer pressure • In contrast, older adults are more likely to be isolated, drinking alone • More likely to identified in healthcare settings as secondary problem to the reason for admissions to ER, primary care.
Alcohol Affects the Elderly Differently • Induced impairment increases with age due to: • Higher body fat content, less lean muscle mass, and reduced water volume (alcohol is water soluble) • Decreased absorption rate in gastrointestinal system due to decreased blood flow • Affects alcohol’s distribution within the body • Affects alcohol’s elimination • Results in increased sensitivity and decreased tolerance to alcohol and drugs in older individuals • Drugs and alcohol remain in the body longer and at higher rates of concentration
Older Adults: Adverse Drugs Events • People age 65+ make up 12% of U.S. Population, but • account for 34% of all prescription medication use • account for 30% of all over-the-counter medication use • Annually, 1 in 3 adults ages 65+ experience adverse drug events • Susceptible to problems due to altered: • pharmacodynamics (how the drug affects individual) • pharmacokinetics (how the body absorbs, distributes, metabolizes, eliminates a drug)
Misuse in older people is often unintentional(Glantz, 1981; Schwartz et al., 1962). • Difficulty of regimen (too many meds to keep track) • Memory issues • Adverse drug reactions • Synergistic effects of multiple drugs • Cost & Access • Multiple prescribing physicians • Lack of understanding of the instructions • They are less likely to ask physician or pharmacist questions or receive written information about prescriptions (Olins, 1985). • Use of/interactions with OTC meds (Coons et al., 1988) • Early discontinuation of medications
Medications & Alcohol Use • Use of drugs in combination with alcohol carries greater risk: • hepatoxicity with acetaminophen • increased lithium toxicity • enhanced CNS depression for those prescribed tricyclic antidepressants • death - for those taking benzodiazepines and barbiturates
Expert panel recommendations for screening and treating the older adult: SAMHSA/CSAT Treatment Improvement Protocol (TIP) #26
TIP#26 Expert Panel Recommendations • Age-specific, group treatment that is supportive, not confrontational • Attend to depression, loneliness; address losses. • Teach skills to rebuild social support network • Employ staff experienced in working with elders • Link with aging, medical, institutional settings • Content should be age-appropriate and offered at a slower pace. • Create a “culture of respect” for older clients • Broad, holistic approach recognizing age-specific psychological, social & health aspects. • Adapt treatment as needed to address gender issues
FMHI - developed group treatment Relapse prevention, Cognitive-behavioral/Self-management skills • Gerontology Alcohol Project (1979-1981) –successfully treated late onset, older alcohol abusers and improving social support, mood (Dupree, Broskowski & Schonfeld, 1984) • Substance Abuse Program for Elderly (1986-1994) extended GAP approach to all older adults irrespective of age of onset and type of substance (Schonfeld & Dupree, 1991; Schonfeld , et al., 1995; Schonfeld & Dupree, 1995; 1998) • Replications - programs in other states based on our model • Chelsea Arbor Older Adult Recovery Center in Ann Arbor, Michigan (1990’s) • GET SMART Program (West Los Angeles VA Hospital; 2000-2011) (Schonfeld et al. 2000) • Zablocki VA Medical Center (Milwaukee, 2006) • Older Adult Substance Abuse Treatment Program – Tennessee (2005 - 2008) (Outlaw et al. 2012)
The Result: A 16-session curriculum manual for conducting brief treatment (Dupree & Schonfeld, CSAT, 2005) http://kap.samhsa.gov/products/manuals/pdfs/substanceabuserelapse.pdf
A Three Stage CBT/Self-Management Treatment Approach(Dupree & Schonfeld, SAMHSA/CSAT manual, 2005) • For each person begin by identifying his/her antecedents and consequences for substance use to create an individualized “substance use behavior chain” using the Substance Abuse Profile for the Elderly • Teach the person how to identify the components of that chain so that he or she can understand the high risk situations for alcohol or drug use. • Teach specific skills to address these high risk situations to prevent relapse.
A Three Stage CBT/Self-Management Treatment Approach(Dupree & Schonfeld, SAMHSA/CSAT manual, 2005) • For each person begin by identifying his/her antecedents and consequences for substance use to create an individualized “substance use behavior chain” using the Substance Abuse Profile for the Elderly • Teach the person how to identify the components of that chain so that he or she can understand the high risk situations for alcohol or drug use. • Teach specific skills to address these high risk situations to prevent relapse.
However, a change was needed • In Florida, the actions of several task forces and Florida Coalition on Optimal MH and Aging shaped a new agenda: • identified elders as an underserved population • Policy changes identifying them as a target pop. • Despite older adults’ positive outcomes in treatment programs, relatively few actually entered treatment. • In 2000, less than 2% of adults in Florida’s treatment for substance abuse problems, were age 60+ despite the fact that they represent about 24% of the population
SBIRT A national initiative for screening, brief intervention, and referral to treatment
Substance Abuse Severity and Level of Care Adapted from the SAMHSA TIP #34 (1999) and Institute of Medicine (1990) None Substance Abuse Severity Mild Moderate Severe Specialized Treatment Brief Intervention Primary Prevention
Screening and Brief InterventionsEarly Examples • Used within Emergency Departments • Bernstein E, Bernstein J, Levenson S: Project ASSERT: An ED-based intervention to increase access to primary care, preventive services, and the substance abuse treatment system. Ann Emerg Med , 1997; 30:181-189. • Used within primary care practices as “Brief Physician Advice” for older adults • Fleming, MF., Manwell, LB, Barry, KL, Adams, W, & Stauffacher, EA Brief physician advice for alcohol problems in older adults: A randomized community-based trial. J FamPract; 1999 48(5): 378-84
Motivational Interviewing (MI) • People who “screen positive” for substance misuse may be reluctant to seek help and are often ambivalent about making a decision to change behavior • Confrontation & labeling will produce “resistance” or the person will be labeled as being “in denial.” Resistance can also be raised prior to treatment (e.g., spouses, employers, coercion from the legal system). • With MI, resistance is viewed as a reaction to the in-session behavior of the counselor.
Key Principles of Motivational Interviewing • Avoiding labeling and confrontation • Enhance Self-efficacy (confidence in one’s coping strategies) • Enhance internal-attribution • Roll with resistance – use it to further explore client’s views • Use cognitive dissonance as a tool – the client is asked to provide more and more evidence that problem(s) exist
Videos – examples of Brief Intervention • Boston University: BNI-ART Institute http://www.bu.edu/bniart/sbirt-in-health-care/sbirt-educational-materials/sbirt-videos/ • Provide scenarios for using screening and brief intervention during the delivery of healthcare. • Videos illustrate the use of MI techniques
The Pilot: Florida BRITE Project 2004-07 (BRief Intervention and Treatment for Elders) 3,497 people ages 60+ screened and/or served Schonfeld et al (2010) Am. J. of Public Health Four sites in pilot project Broward County Elderly & Veterans Services = 2,116 Gulf Coast Jewish Family Services (Pinellas) = 638 Coastal Behavioral Health Care (Sarasota) = 426 Center for Drug Free Living (Orange) = 317 Most (67%) identified via BRITE outreach & prescreening at health fairs, senior centers, and via referral network. Positive prescreens invited to participate in BI Most received multiple sessions of brief intervention
The Florida BRITE ProjectPilot Project (2004-2007) Center for Drug Free Living – added in 2005 Gulf Coast Jewish Family Services Orlando Broward County Elderly & Veterans Services Coastal Behavioral HealthCare
The Pilot: Florida BRITE Project 2004-07 (BRief Intervention and Treatment for Elders) Purpose: to identify people ages 60+ who misused or were at risk for misusing: Alcohol Prescription medications Over-the-counter (OTC) medications Illicit drugs Depression and suicide risk also screened by BRITE Depression - most frequent antecedent to substance abuse in elders (Dupree et al., 1984; Schonfeld & Dupree, 1991, Schonfeld et al., 2000) Elders - highest rate of suicides among all age-groups
The Pilot: Florida BRITE Project 2004-07 (BRief Intervention and Treatment for Elders) 10% - referred for potential alcohol problems 69% of all 3,497 screened were drinkers 18% of drinkers had 3 or more drinks on a drinking day 26% referred for prescription misuse 32% needed education/assistance on proper med use 17% could not recall purpose of 1 or more meds 11% reported wrong amount for 1 or more meds 8% took medications for wrong reasons/symptom 8% referred for potential OTC misuse 1% referred for illicit drug use
The Pilot: Florida BRITE Project 2004-07 (BRief Intervention and Treatment for Elders) • Depression (Short-Geriatric Depression Scale) • 64% of all referrals were for depression • SGDS scores: 25% moderate, 10% serious • Among those referred for reasons other than depression: • SGDS: 18% moderate, 4% serious • Suicide Risk: Only 0.6% referred for suicide risk • But 13% contemplated suicide at some time in the past (most of these within the past year)
The Pilot: Outcomes 2004-07Significant improvement at D/C and Follow-ups • Significant decrease in alcohol scores at D/C (n=102) • No further changes at 30 day follow-ups (n =60) • Prescription Medications: a 32% decrease in “flags” at D/C over the number at baseline (n=180) • OTCs: 23 of 24 people flagged at baseline, no flag at D/C • Illicit drugs: 75% of those with flags at baseline (n=12) showed no flag at D/C • Significant decrease1 in depression scores at D/C (n=323) • Further decrease at 30 day follow-up (n = 203)
Florida BRITE Project – the SBIRT Grant:(BRief Intervention and Treatment for Elders) $14 million SAMHSA/CSAT grant to Florida Five years: Oct. 2006-Sept. 2011 Funding mostly went towards direct services Large scale screening in medical, other settings Majority of people are expected to screen negative (receive Screening & Feedback only) Positive screens were typically followed by 1 session of Brief Intervention People could receive 5 BI or 12 BT sessions Referred out for detox, residential care, etc.
30 provider agencies contracted to conduct screening in over 70 sites in 18 counties
SBIRT Approach • Universal prescreening (7 items: alcohol, drugs, medications, depressive symptoms) • Full screen (ASSIST) for those with positive prescreens • Level of risk dictates type of service: • Screening & Feedback (SF) for negative screens • Brief Intervention (BI) for moderate risk • Brief Treatment (BT) for moderate to high risk • Referral to Treatment (RT) - high risk/problem use
Alcohol, Smoking and Substance Involvement Screening Test (ASSIST)World Health Organization (WHO) • An interview style screen administered only if there is a positive prescreen • The ASSIST was developed to help healthcare professionals detect and manage substance use • Scores provide a “level of risk” for alcohol or for other substances and type of service that follows: • Low risk = screening & feedback (SF) about results • Moderate risk = indicates the need for brief intervention (BI) using motivational interviewing • Moderate to High Risk = Brief treatment (BT) • High Risk = Referral to treatment
Florida BRITE Project Reasons for Positive Screens at Baseline (n=8,165)
BRITE Services Received • For those who screened positive and agreed to receive services: • BI n = 6,338 • BT n = 675 • RT n = 899
Sustainability of SBIRT • Nationally, a number of actions and events are fostering SBIRT’s sustainability: • The BIG (Brief Intervention Group) Initiative for EAP programs and Hospitals cross North America • American College of Surgeons’ Committee on Trauma requires SBIRT in Level I & II trauma centers • Billing codes for SBIRT available to providers • Local adoption of BRITE as a model in Florida and nationally (to bill through Older Americans Act $s)
Billing codes for SBI were adopted Feb. 2008 • Reimbursement for screening and brief intervention is available through commercial insurance CPT codes, Medicare G codes, and Medicaid HCPCS codes • Florida has not approved Medicaid codes for billing purposes