1 / 23

Effectiveness of Paper Towels as a Makeshift Respirator

Effectiveness of Paper Towels as a Makeshift Respirator. David Leith Dept. of Environmental Sciences and Engineering University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. Is This a Crazy Idea?. Recent events: People feel vulnerable Attack of 9/11 Anthrax attacks SARS

masako
Download Presentation

Effectiveness of Paper Towels as a Makeshift Respirator

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Effectiveness of Paper Towelsas a Makeshift Respirator David LeithDept. of Environmental Sciences and EngineeringUniversity of North Carolina at Chapel Hill

  2. Is This a Crazy Idea? • Recent events: People feel vulnerable • Attack of 9/11 • Anthrax attacks • SARS • What can people do to protect themselves? • Authorities say: Use duct tape, plastic sheets

  3. What Can You Do? • Many potential threats • Terrorist attacks seem unlikely but get attention • Fires at home kill 2000-3000/yr from smoke • Concern about SARS • Most people don’t have a respirator • Could something else be used…

  4. Objectives of This Study • Evaluate makeshift measuresfor respiratory protection • Readily available at home or office • Evaluate masks and respiratorscommercially available • Collection efficiency for respirable particles • Pressure drop (resistance to breathing )

  5. Protective Measures Evaluated • Makeshift four household items • Dust Mask three commercially available masks • N95 NIOSH Certified Respirator three commercially available respirators

  6. Makeshift Measures: • Handkerchief • Folded three times; eight layers thick • Bath Towel • Folded twice; four layers thick • T-shirt • Folded twice; four layers thick • Paper Towels • Full roll; half roll Wet andDry

  7. Paper Towels • Need mouthpiece,plug, perforated roll • Breathe through mouth only • Face seal unnecessary Anyone can use

  8. No Warning on Mask Dust Masks • Package: • “use only for sweeping, mowing, pollen relief” • “use for comfort and breathing relief from cold air, non-toxic dusts, pollen, cut grass” • Cost about $0.40 • Readily available

  9. Warning on Mask N95 Respirators • Package: • “helps protect against certain particles” • “misuse may result in sickness or death” • “meets OSHA recommendation for protection against SARS” • Cost about $1.75 • Available, if you look

  10. RoomAerosol 40 LPMTotal RoomAerosol RoomAerosol Mask Mask Rotameter Flow Divider Aerosizer DMP Five Replicate Tests 1 - Mask, No Mask;2 - No Mask, Mask;3 - Mask, No Mask;4 - No Mask, Mask;5 - Mask, No Mask Procedure

  11. Perfect Sealing • Edges taped • Best possible seal • No air flow bypass • Best possible efficiency

  12. Makeshift Respirator Performance Dry 4 0.4

  13. Full Towel Roll – Effect of Air Flow 4 0.4

  14. Half Towel Roll – Effect of Air Flow 4 0.4

  15. Bath Towel – Wet is Worse 0.4 4

  16. T-Shirt – Wet is Worse 0.4 4

  17. Handkerchief – Wet is Worse 0.4 4

  18. Dust Masks are Ineffective 4 0.4

  19. N95 Respirators are Good 0.4 4

  20. Pressure Drop is Low • Ranged from 0.01 to 1.90 inches of water • Wet DP > Dry DP • No difficulty breathing through any of the devices

  21. Other Issues for Paper Towels • How does the cardboard roll get perforated? • Manufacturers could do it • Simple punch could be made • What about pollutant gases? • What is adsorptive capacity for paper towels? • Would toilet paper work as well?

  22. Conclusions • Dust Masks offer Little Protection • Low efficiency for respirable particles • Makeshift Measures offer Some Protection • Bath towel and T-shirt better than handkerchief • Wetting fabrics decreased performance

  23. Conclusions, cont’d • N95 Respirators worked Best • All had efficiencies above 80% for 0.2 < d < 4 mm • Edges taped; best possible performance • Paper Towels worked Relatively Well • Need mouthpiece, plug, and perforated tube • No edges to seal • Efficiency similar to N95 respirators • Possible to remove pollutant gases?

More Related