1 / 22

Metaphysics- Reason (evidence) for reality?

Knowledge and Evidence “ What grounds or beliefs in reality are the reasons we have for them” - Plato “ …are any things that exist independently of us that cannot be the immediate objects of our sensations .“ - George Berkley. Metaphysics- Reason (evidence) for reality?.

mason
Download Presentation

Metaphysics- Reason (evidence) for reality?

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Knowledge and Evidence“What grounds or beliefs in reality are the reasons we have for them”- Plato“…are any things that exist independently of us that cannot be the immediate objects of our sensations.“ - George Berkley

  2. Metaphysics- Reason (evidence) for reality? • Tries to explain truth and knowledge? • Why we believe the things we do? • Two big camps: • Our senses tell our brains what to do (empiricists) • Objects are how we sense them • Reason is used to understand an objective reality (rationalists) • Objects and properties • How do non physical ideas fit into this world? • Love, Freewill, Passion

  3. Truth Information that we believe to be true and for which we have experiences for justification and evidence. • Rationalist: Truth through reason (computer, objective) Truth is dependent on correct definitions (categories) • Empiricist: Truth through senses (virtual reality, subjective) Truth is dependent on correct interpretation of experience

  4. R: mind-independent objects and a physical nature? E: Immediate experience and inference, through 5 senses What makes truth? Answer two questions Is there a solid evidence that allows us to infer the conclusion? What is the best process to understanding that evidence? Problems Empiricists: What are the right senses? (Descartes) Rationalists: What is the standard of evidence needed to make TRUTH (belief becomes knowledge)? Truth, external world (infer)

  5. Biases truth – “our truth” • Social Peer Pressure • Politics • Other Beliefs • Our family tree of thought • Misevaluation and Assumptions • Mistakes or predications with no basis • Lack of cognitive skills • Don’t have the tools • Critical Thinking

  6. Review RationalistFor animals do not see in order that they may have sight, but they have sight that they may see - Aristotle Truth= Is this a table? What are the qualities?

  7. Review Empiricists“If a tree falls in a forest and no one is around to hear it, does it make a sound?” ― George Berkeley Truth= Am I sensing a table or a chair?

  8. Belief and knowledge – the truth process?

  9. Knowledge- Historical thoughts • Truth is knowledge (Plato/Socrates) • Gods create perfect objects– archetypes. Imperfection our in the human world. • Physical objects have properties • Knowing all the properties is knowledge? • Impression is knowledge (Locke/Hume) • Experiences make impressions in our mind. • Knowledge is just a bundle of impressions • Matters of fact are contingent on experiences • Self beliefs is knowledge (Rousseau) • “Let the child be a child”, we learn by participation • Real wisdom is not the knowledge of everything, but the knowledge of which things in life are necessary, which are less necessary, and which are completely unnecessary to know.

  10. Rationalists knowledge • Plato states, “we can only know things that are absolutely true.” • 100% true all the time…requires certainty • Very hard standard to meet • Think of the problems Descartes had just trying to prove the simple fact that he, himself, existed. • Now extend out to other things

  11. Problem with rationalists knowledge • How much then? • 51% • Beyond a REASONABLE DOUBT? • Best explanation • What standard do you use to claim you KNOW something?

  12. Empiricists Knowledge • We know things by experiencing them • You need to test the claim yourself • The process of knowing that is important • Reality cannot exists without the a sensation connected with it. • No truth around us, we make our truth

  13. Problems with empiricism • What of Memory • How do we retain Beliefs to form knowledge? • How do we know of senses are correct • Descartes doubts (sight, feeling) • How can we ever have community discussion or laws or commonality? • How do we process senses? No truth?

  14. Immanuel KantReality & Knowledge-- objective We indeed, rightly considering objects of sense(s) as mere appearances..[appearances] are based on upon a thing in itself, though we know not this thing in itself, but only know its appearance, namely, the way in which our senses are effected by this unknown thing.

  15. Immanuel Kant- Beliefs subjective • Knowledge comes from understanding physical world with good reason. • However– • Noumenal: Things lying beyond senses [objective world], "things-in-themselves” never 100% know truth of these– slighted by perception.. truth is impossible • Phenomenal: Beliefs confirmed or denied by perception (senses), organized and structured by the mind (reason). This becomes knowledge.

  16. Immanuel Kant– 5 steps • The human mind does not receive and imprint ideas of objects onto a blank slate (impressions). Experience does not make knowledge. • There is no knowledge without the reasoning skills first. (Computer processor) • World exits independent from the mind. The mind must sort out knowable things and beliefs. (Proof) • Every effect has a cause. Objective and independent from experience. • Knowing comes from knowing cause and effect relationships. This is reality and truth

  17. Tree of knowledge • Roots are our strongest held knowledge • Strongest and hold up the beliefs • Highest points limbs are our least held beliefs • Weak, but support our knowledge • Water and sun are the evidence that help the beliefs and knowledge grow

  18. Volmar’s TreeThe Role of Reason– “the sap” • Filters evidence- good or bad • Connects our beliefs to reality– valid or invalid • Importance of skepticism- thoughts, ideas, memories, emotions are fair game for investigation • Through perception (evidence) reason beliefs becomes knowledge. • good sap = good roots

  19. Evidence Characteristics – Logic, organized beliefs • Proves or disproves a viewpoint or statement. • Premises lead to the conclusion All apples are Red This is an apple ---------------------------- Therefore, it is red Evidence, or premises, can be true or false

  20. Evidence Characteristics – Know influences • Big event– sticks with us more • Suggestiveor leading language • How fast were you going when you…. • Collidedwith that car (guilt) • Slid together with that car (even) • That car collided with you (innocence) • False memory (beliefs) • Recalling an event that never happened • Wrong about the event

  21. Evidence Characteristics – Source credibility (Expert in the field) • Appeal to inappropriate authority • My uncle says I have a fever • My barber says my radiator needs fixing • Factors of credibility • Education…training • Experience…work in the field • Reputation…other in the field view • Accomplishments…awards in the field

  22. Evidence Characteristics – Evaluation knowledge base • Confirmation Bias • Look for only evidence that supports your view • Looking for your side • Blinded by the truth • Contradiction in evidence • Not only why your claim is good • BUT why the other claims are bad • Human Egotism • We like to be right! • Physically- releases endorphins • Mentally- emotional comfort

More Related