1 / 8

Humanitarianism and the Privatization of Security: Rationales, Challenges, and Prospects

Humanitarianism and the Privatization of Security: Rationales, Challenges, and Prospects. Dr. Christopher Spearin 4 May 2006. Outline. Sections How private security companies (PSCs) interact with non-governmental organizations (NGOs) Prospects of an independent humanitarian role for PSCs.

maya
Download Presentation

Humanitarianism and the Privatization of Security: Rationales, Challenges, and Prospects

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Humanitarianism and the Privatization of Security: Rationales, Challenges, and Prospects Dr. Christopher Spearin 4 May 2006

  2. Outline • Sections • How private security companies (PSCs) interact with non-governmental • organizations (NGOs) • Prospects of an independent humanitarian role for PSCs Rationale for relationship ► Rise of non-state actors - “NGOization” of politics - development of the private security industry ► NGO security needs - caught in crossfire - subject to direct attack for political and economic reasons ► PSC desire for remuneration and international legitimacy

  3. Challenges in the NGO-PSC Relationship - I • Some NGOs prefer to follow the humanitarian ethic or the acceptance strategy to ensure security • Challenges in learning about the PSC-NGO relationship • Uncomfortable talking about armed actors • Worried about offering legitimacy • Fearful of donor wrath • Do not want to bring internal divides into the open • Difficulties in a collective NGO response to PSCs • PSCs protecting client confidentiality

  4. Images taken from http://www.moles.org/ProjectUnderground/pix/eologo.gif; http://www.brookings.edu/rios/data/sources/portrait/474894142b16ff3b6ed6fde10a141465.jpg ; http://www.help-for-you.com/news/May2002/May15/ap_somalia_factional_fighter_150.jpg Challenges in the NGO-PSC Relationship - II • Culture clash between NGO and PSC personnel • Will likely still impact upon local conflict dynamics • Reliance on indigenous expertise for financial reasons • Fuel conflict dynamics • Draw individuals away from indigenous security sector institutions • Linkages to other clients • Foreign and indigenous clients (state and non-state) • PSCs desire an economy of scale, perhaps to the detriment of NGO activities Peter Singer

  5. Images taken from http://www.hatsofflynden.com/images/Flags%20Of%20The%20World/United%20Nations.JPG; http://www.cyberie.qc.ca/images/denard4.jpg Challenges in the NGO-PSC Relationship - III • NGO developing, but often minimal, expertise in private security matters • Lack of knowledge as to how a firm operates • Lack of knowledge about capabilities, past operations, characteristics of PSC personnel • Difficulties in developing a pan-NGO approach or databank of lessons learned • Minimal support from the United Nations • Schizophrenic approach (emphasis on soldiers of fortune) • OCHA guidelines

  6. Images taken from http://www.brownalumnimagazine.com/photos/minear.jpg; http://www.watsoninstitute.org/images_news/Antonio_Donini.jpg A “Humanitarian” Space for PSCs? • Shift from avoidance/containment strategies to peace consolidation strategies involving state and non-state actors • Difficult for some NGOs • Continued/increasing violence against NGOs • Pullouts • Targeted because viewed as part of the foreign presence Humanitarian Alibi Larry Minear Mobilizing Myth Antonio Donini

More Related