1 / 17

Nuts and Bolts of a Closing Argument

Nuts and Bolts of a Closing Argument. NITA Presentation for Juvenile Defenders September 18, 2011 By Michael Washington. Getting permission. I used to say . . .

mele
Download Presentation

Nuts and Bolts of a Closing Argument

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Nuts and Bolts of a Closing Argument NITA Presentation for Juvenile Defenders September 18, 2011 By Michael Washington

  2. Getting permission • I used to say . . . • Your Honor, it will only take a moment, and it will better assist the Court’s understanding of the relevant issues in this particular case.

  3. Now I say . . . • In less than 2 minutes I can help the Court understand our issues.

  4. Goals for Opening Statement • Have a Theme • Tell YOUR Story, quickly • Use clear, simple language • Start persuading

  5. Persuasive Story • Explains all known facts • Explains reasons for behavior • Told by credible witnesses • Supported by details • Is consistent with common sense

  6. Closing ArgumentParts needed . . . • Your Delivery • Your theme • Exhibits • The Law • Your best facts • Your weaknesses • Emotional connection • YOU & The Judge

  7. Your Delivery • Make eye contact • Lose the notes • Use visual aids • Create Drama • Use gestures, inflection, pauses

  8. The 60-30-10 Rule • 60 % Appearance • Body Language • Dress • Composure • 30 % Sound • Tone / Variety • Pace / Volume 10 % Content Word choice

  9. Effectiveness Statistically Speaking (7%) seven percent of information delivered verbally is remembered after three days. (65%) sixty-five percent of information delivered both visually and verbally is remembered after three days.* * UM/3M Study, Management Information Systems Center, School of Management, University of Minnesota

  10. Your Theme • Starts your closing • Links back to your opening • Provides continuity to case • Provides organizational framework for argument

  11. Exhibits • Must use some because A picture’s worth . . . • Don’t use all - choose only most persuasive • Create simple demonstratives • Practice how you will handle them and know where you will store them • Show them to opposing counsel if any issue of fairness

  12. The Law • Identify the issues in dispute • Show how the evidence/facts apply • Tie them to the verdict

  13. Your best facts • Facts first – then conclusions • Use their witnesses • Accept what they concede • Tie to your theme • Don’t try to recite all of your good facts

  14. Your weaknesses • Acknowledge them • Spin them • If you can’t spin, explain why despite them you still win

  15. Emotional connection • Find the moral outrage of the other side’s claim • Appeal to Justice, Fairness, Common Sense – not prejudice • Advocate = Persuade

  16. YOU & The Judge • Talk to her (or him) • Use plain language – simplify • Read their response (body language)

  17. Final Thoughts • Remember primacy and recency • Finish confidently (dismount) • Review, Practice, Revise • Accept the fact you might goof • Be Yourself

More Related