420 likes | 596 Views
Natural History of Picornavirus Colds in Adults. 69% self-diagnosed cold within 8 hours Sore throat most common first symptom Rhinorrhea most bothersome symptom Fever uncommon Sleep disturbed 4 days 7-to 11-day duration of symptoms 25% have symptoms for 2 weeks.
E N D
Natural History of Picornavirus Colds in Adults • 69% self-diagnosed cold within 8 hours • Sore throat most common first symptom • Rhinorrhea most bothersome symptom • Fever uncommon • Sleep disturbed 4 days • 7-to 11-day duration of symptoms • 25% have symptoms for 2 weeks Arruda, et al. J Clin Micro. 1997;35:2864 Monto, et al. J Infect Dis. 1987;156:43 Gwaltney, et al. JAMA. 1967;202:294
Current Management of Colds • Leading reason for physician visits • ~17% of colds result in an office visit • Antibiotics • 30-50% of visits result in antibiotic prescription • No reduction in symptoms or complications • No treatment for the underlying viral cause McIsaac, et al.J Fam Prac. 1998;47:366 Gonzales, et al.JAMA. 1997;278:901 Gonzales, et al.Ann Intern Med. 2001;134:479 Rosenstein, et al.Pediatrics. 1998;101:181
Current Management of Colds • 75% of patients with colds self medicate • Symptom relief treatments • Cough preparations (84%), combination cold products (83%), analgesics (83%), decongestants (57%), antihistamines (56%) • Benefits are variable and transient • Do not shorten illness duration • Side effects and precautions McIssac, et al. J Fam Prac. 1998:47:366 SVI Consumer Segmentation,October 2001
Human Picornaviruses Enteroviruses Rhinoviruses Common Cold Herpangina Hand-foot-and-mouth Meningitis/encephalitis Myocarditis Neonatal Sepsis Meningoencephalitis Common Cold Otitis Media Sinusitis Exacerbation of Asthma, COPD, and CF LRT Infections in Immunocompromised
Capsid Binidng Compound: Early Development Candidates 1985 Disoxaril (WIN 51711) 1989 WIN 54954
VP 63843 (Pleconaril) 1992 • Not metabolized by CYP450 enzymes • Microsome T1/2 = >200 min
Protection by Pleconaril ofAdult Mice Infected With CVB3 Pevear et al Antimicrob Agents Chemother, 1999.
Structural Studies of Anti-rhinovirus Agents1985 - 2002 Purdue University Eddy Arnold Sungsoo Kim Alan Simpson John Badger S.Krishnaswamy Tom Smith Michael Chapman Ming Luo Gerd Vriend Andrea Hadfield Jodi Muckelbauer Rui Zhao Kyung Kim Marcos Olivera Ying Zhang ViroPharma(Stirling Winthrop) University of Wisconsin Guy Diana Beverly Heinz Frank Dutko Wai-Ming Lee Jim Groarke Roland Rueckert Mark McKinlay Debbie Shepard Dan Pevear Wensheng Wang
101 Rhinovirus Serotypes (Prototypic Strains) 53 Enterovirus Serotypes (Prototypic Strains) Distribution of Susceptibility to Pleconaril 10 10 1 1 EC50 mg/mL 0.1 0.1 0.01 0.01 0.001 0.001 Serotypes Serotypes
Thermal Instability of Coxsackie B3 Viruses with Reduced Drug Susceptibility Wild type % Surviving PFU I92L I92M I92M Time at 46oC (min)
Phase 3 design PPPhase • Two randomized, placebo-controlled trials of identical design • 2096 patients randomized • Protocol 043: 1052 patients • Protocol 044: 1044 patients • 197 centers across the US and Canada • Enrollment from August – November 2000
Entry Criteria • Otherwise healthy subjects ≥18 years old • Answer ‘Yes’ to “Do you have a cold today?” • Moderate or severe rhinorrhea • At least one other respiratory symptom • nasal congestion, cough, sore throat • Symptom duration ≤24 hrs • Exclusions • active allergic rhinitis or asthma • fever ≥100ºF
Patient Self-Assessments (Days 1-18) • Rhinorrhea, nasal congestion, cough, sore throat, malaise, myalgia: absent, mild, moderate, or severe, twice daily • Presence or absence of cold twice daily • Tissue counts once daily • Sleep disturbance once daily • Impairment of normal activity level once daily • Concomitant use of cold symptom relief medications
Virological Assessments Nasal mucus sample Baseline, Day 3, and Day 6 Baseline RT-PCR + Baseline RT-PCR – Virus culture Virus culture + Virus culture – Culture Day 3 and Day 6 samples Susceptibility testing on culture positive samples
Placebo (N=262) Pleconaril (N=276) Placebo (N=301) Pleconaril (N=290) Antiviral Effect: Percentage Change in Relative Virus Levels 12 9 6 3 0 % of Baseline RT-PCR Level p< 0.001 p= 0.011 p< 0.001 p= 0.121 Day 3 Day 6 Day 3 Day 6 Study 044 Study 043
Safety Conclusions: 5 Day Treatment • Most common adverse events were headache and GI symptoms • No clinically significant effects on laboratory safety parameters • Increased menstrual disorders in OC users; 3.5% with pleconaril treatment dose • No evidence of increased incidence of pregnancy in women taking pleconaril • Safety profile supports empiric treatment of colds
Compassionate Use Program • Compassionate Use Patients (2001) • Chronic Meningoencephalitis 51 • Encephalitis/Meningoencephalitis 40 • Myocarditis 62 • Bone Marrow Transplant 16 • Neonatal Enteroviral Disease 45 • Many anecdotal accounts of dramatic improvement in patient status • 475 treated patients as of May 2002 of who 366 recovered
Conclusions • Pleconaril is the first antiviral drug to treat the predominant cause of the common cold • Pleconaril reduces the duration and severity of picornavirus colds • Safety profile supports empiric treatment
FDA committee decision March 19th 2002 Potential of producing virulent viral strains too great relative to benefits gained Problem of women on birth control drugs: warning messages are thought to be ineffective Benefits of an anti-common cold drug too small relative to possible risks of side effects. Concern over inappropriate use with the possibility of generating virulent strains Committee voted 15 to 0 against licensing of drug.