300 likes | 455 Views
"A sustainable disease control strategy as pathogen pressures on SRC willow increase, due to climate change and larger areas of planting.". Alistair R. McCracken Applied Plant Science & Biometrics Division, AFBI. Ireland’s energy needs. Ireland imports > 91% energy
E N D
"A sustainable disease control strategy as pathogen pressures on SRC willow increase, due to climate change and larger areas of planting." Alistair R. McCracken Applied Plant Science & Biometrics Division, AFBI
Ireland’s energy needs • Ireland imports > 91% energy • Fossil fuels account for 96% of all energy used • Renewable energy grew by 15% in 2006 (mainly due to wind)
Biomass (energy crops + forestry)) • Currently making a small contribution • Has significant potential • Government incentives • Issues of supply chain
Short Rotation Coppice (SRC) willow 2008 • Northern Ireland ~ 950 ha • Republic of Ireland ~ 200 ha
Stephens Croft wood burning power plant (44MWe), Lockerbie, Scotland 20% of fuel – SRC willow by 2011 which represent ~10,000 ha
Biomass is hitting headlines as DRAX announces plans to build 3 more biomass power stations in England
Why? • To meet government targets for: • Energy from renewable sources • Reduction of GHG emissions • To slow down climate change
2020 2060 2080 Temperature Winter Spring Summer Autumn
Rainfall Winter precipitation 1961- 1990 Summer precipitation 1961- 1990 Summer precipitation 2055 Winter precipitation 2055 Winter precipitation 2075 Summer precipitation 2075
Climate and disease / pests Areas of cultivation (especially if monoculture) Climate change (temperature: rainfall: growing season) INCREASED and / or CHANGING disease / pest pressures
Susceptible Host Suitable Environment Active Pathogen Disease Triangle DISEASE
Melampsora epitea Heteroecious rust alternating on European larch (Larix decidua)
Need for non-chemical disease control strategy Fungicides cannot be used for: • Economics • Environmental • Practical • Renewable
Genotype selection and assessment • European Breeding Programme (UK) • Swedish Breeding Programme • Yield • Disease / pest susceptibility • Growth form
By using Salix Genotype Mixtures: • Delay in onset of infection • Slower rate of dissemination • Lower levels of disease end of season Significantly reduced impact of rust
Mono - susceptible 20-way mixture Rust control Trial investigating the effectiveness of willow mixtures comprising up to 20 components for rust disease control
Additional benefits of genotype mixtures • Increased yield • Better site / light / resource capture • Reduced disease pressure on individual genotypes • Important for sustainability of plantation • Opportunity for compensation
Need for diversity in mixtures? • Original trials were both INTRA and INTER species mixtures
“viminalis trial.” • Mixtures comprising of up to 7 straight Salix viminalis genotypes • Planted 2000 • Cut back 2000/01 • Harvested 2003/04 & 2007/08 • Disease assessed May – September 2000 - 2007
Mixtures with limited diversity • Do NOT give any yield benefits • Do NOT consistently reduce disease incidence • Perform more like a mono-plot • It is not recommended to plant mixtures with limited number or limited diversity of genotypes
Melampsora epitea PATHOTYPES Mixtures with limited diversity do not differ significantly form mono-plots
Commercial Recommendations • Plant resistant Salix genotypes • Swedish breeding programme • European (formerly UK) breeding programme • Tora • Sven • Torhild • Olof • Tordis • (Stott) • Parfit • Beagle • Resolution • Discovery • Endeavour • Nimrod
Planting configuration • Totally random (commercially impossible) • Short-runs (Step Planter) • Line mixtures • Mosaics • Large blocks
Other risks Willow beetles (Phratora vitellinae and Phratora vulgatissima) Black willow aphid (Pterochlorus viminalis)
Conclusions (SRC willow) • Increasing areas + climate change increases the risk of disease • Use of genotype mixtures offers an effective, cheap, sustainable method • There is a need for diversity within a mixture