1 / 20

Regional impact of the crisis: Political economy, governance dimensions

Regional impact of the crisis: Political economy, governance dimensions. Ben Slay Senior economist UNDP Bureau for Europe and CIS 6 July 2010. Main points. Macroeconomic impact of the crisis First phase over . . . . . . Second phase now starting? Threat of European “double-dip” recession

moral
Download Presentation

Regional impact of the crisis: Political economy, governance dimensions

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Regional impact of the crisis: Political economy, governance dimensions Ben Slay Senior economist UNDP Bureau for Europe and CIS 6 July 2010

  2. Main points • Macroeconomic impact of the crisis • First phase over . . . • . . . Second phase now starting? • Threat of European “double-dip” recession • Less fiscal space—pressure on social sector • Which countries are most at risk? • Regional impact of crisis: • Political economy dimensions • Governance dimensions (“six myths”)

  3. Macroeconomic impact of the crisis • First phase over • Global economy recovering . . . • . . . Thanks to significant policy stimulus • Much fiscal space used in 2008-2009 • Greek crisis: Threat of European “double-dip” recession? • Less favourable public debt dynamics • In EU-15: “PIIGS” • In our region: Hungary • Regional recovery: Very uneven

  4. Who’s the worst hit region? We are . . . Regional GDP growth trends (I) Source: IMF World Economic Outlook, April 2010

  5. Regional growth trends: Another perspective Source: IMF World Economic Outlook, April 2010

  6. Which economies got hit worst in 2009? Source: IMF World Economic Outlook, April 2010

  7. Is the recovery happening? In much of the world—Yes Growth relative to previous quarter. Source: JPMorgan, June 2010.

  8. But not in Europe . . . Growth relative to previous quarter. Source: JPMorgan, June 2010.

  9. “PIIGS” and friends: Bank bailouts boost public debts Gross public debt as share of GDP. Eurostat data.

  10. “PIIGS”: Key risks for “neighbourhood” • Trade—slow euro zone growth means: • Slow export growth in “wider neighbourhood” • More pressure on external balances • Capital markets: • Slow growing “wider neighbourhood”—less attractive than other emerging markets • Results: • Weaker currencies • Higher interest rates, less long-term borrowing • Less consumption, investment

  11. But: Public debts don’t explain everything Sources: IMF, EIU, Eurostat.

  12. National crisis responses: Political economy issues • Policy weaknesses: • Recognition lags • Implementation lags • Uncertain implementation capacity • Philosophical issue: Whom to protect? • Key sectors, firms/banks? • Middle class? • Most vulnerable? • Instruments: Transfers or public works?

  13. Policy weaknesses: Causes, implications • Recognition lags: • Economics: Different points of business cycle • Technical issue: Forecasts have been too optimistic • Politics: Electoral cycles, other factors • Implementation lags: • Exchange rate policy: • Devaluation can work fastest . . . • . . . But is not an option for many non-CIS countries • Monetary policy effectiveness limited by: • Fixed exchange rates/euro adoption • Deleveraging, dollarisation, demonetisation • Fiscal policy: How much fiscal space?

  14. Political economy of response: Country drivers • Political drivers: • Parliamentary democracies: Electoral cycle • CIS countries: • Can political leadership admit there’s a “crisis”? • Do they even know? • Economics—Different countries: • Are at different points in business cycle • Have more or less fiscal space • Are affected differently by markets’ risk appetite: • Collapsed in mid-2008 • Recovered in 2009:H2 • Weakened in 2010:Q2 with Greek crisis

  15. Uncertain implementation capacity: Social safety nets Source: World Bank. Social insurance (e.g., pensions) not included

  16. Social policy reform implications

  17. Governance and the crisis: Myths and realities (I) • Myth I: Quality of governance and market reform are correlated with extent of crisis • Reality: No clear relationship, positive or negative • Economies that did well in 2009: • Were resource exporters . . . • . . . With fiscal reserves from previous years . . . • . . . That attracted FDI • Myth II: Exporting primary products minimizes effects of crisis • Reality: Not necessarily—Russia, Ukraine are also exporters of primary products

  18. Governance and the crisis: Myths and realities (II) • Myth III: Devaluations are good • Reality: Successful devaluations with relatively small tradable sectors (Poland, Turkey, Central Asia) • For other countries—devaluation risks: • Significant pass-through inflation • Balance-sheet mismatches  financial crash • “Beggar-thy-neighbour” competitive devaluations • Myth IV: The crisis was exported to the region by foreign banks • Reality: Region’s banks didn’t acquire “toxic assets” • Instead: Foreign parent banks—and taxpayers—have bailed out local banks across region

  19. Governance and the crisis: Myths and realities (III) • Myth V: ECB’s emphasis on price stability (over growth)  EU must rely on fiscal policy • Reality: EU is torn between “constitutional” SGP and fiscal discretion (pragmatic use of “fiscal space”) • Myth VI: Greek crisis—calamity for Europe • Reality—Greek crisis is helping solve some of Europe’s problems: • Euro too strong, exports not competitive? • Greece  Weaker Euro • Absence of integrated fiscal framework, to support monetary union? • Greece  European Stabilization Mechanism

  20. Thank you very much! I don’t claim to have the answers . . . . . . But I hope I’m asking the right questions Ben.Slay@undp.org

More Related